Weekly Pulse: Healthcare industry already wavering on savings
by The Media Consortium, Wed May 20, 2009 at 09:46:53 AM EDT
By Lindsay Beyerstein, TMC MediaWire Blogger
That was quick: It took just three days for the titans of the healthcare industry to reveal the emptiness of their pledge to the Obama administration to save $2 trillion in healthcare costs over the next 10 years.
Last week, The New York Times proclaimed that Obama scored a "political coup" just by getting the industry groups and SEIU to the table. Maybe so, but writers featured in last week's Pulse remained skeptical that the industry would make good on its unenforceable cost-cutting promises. Skepticism was the healthy response.
Three days after the promise, industry groups started accusing Obama of overstating their commitment. Health Czar Nancy Ann DeParle confirmed that the president garbled the stats slightly when he said that the groups had pledged to cut the rate of growth in healthcare costs by 1.5 percentage points per year. However, the outcry over the slipup is revealing. The groups are now scrambling to reassure their members that they never promised to reduce costs by any specific amount in any given year. Of course they didn't. In order to keep that promise, they'd have to act right away-which they clearly have no intention of doing.
So, it comes as little surprise when Steve Benen of the Washington Monthly reports that Blue Cross/Blue Shield is crafting a PR campaign to trash the whole idea of a public plan, a key element of Obama's healthcare reform agenda. One of the industry groups that signed off on the aforementioned $2 trillion pledge was America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP). Several members of AHIP's board of directors work for Blue Cross or Blue Shield.
In The American Prospect, Paul Waldman notes that the same coalition of Republicans and big business that opposed President Clinton's healthcare reforms 15 years ago are gearing up for a rematch. These folks, who might as well be called Americans for the status quo are trying to own the word "reform" under the tutelage of GOP message master Frank Luntz, according to Waldman.
Some people oppose healthcare reform because they fear a tax increase. That's not a foregone conclusion, but healthcare is so expensive that reform could be a bargain even if we had to raise taxes to pay for it. In AlterNet, Dean Baker asks why his fellow economists are so complacent about the status quo where healthcare is twice as expensive and not quite as beneficial as it is in other developed countries. Baker argues that the extra costs are tantamount to a huge tax on the entire economy:
The excess health care spending comes to more than $1.2 trillion a year or the equivalent of more than $16,000 for a family of four. Paying too much for health care has the same economic impact as a health care tax. In effect, we have a health care waste tax that is about 10 percent larger than the projected federal revenue from the personal and corporate income tax combined. In short, this is real money.
This is a tax that Americans pay without realizing it. Money that could be going towards pay raises is going to support ever-increasing insurance premiums, for those who are lucky enough to have health coverage through their jobs. It's a tax that employers have to take into account when they decide whether to build a plant in the United States, or across the border in Canada where the government takes care of health insurance.
And last but not least, while you can't get blood from a stone, you can get plasma from an overextended American consumer. Credit Solutions of America, a credit counselling service advised clients to sell their blood plasma to make ends meet, Moe Tkacik reports in Talking Points Memo. That's especially ironic when you consider that medical bills cause over half of personal bankruptcies, according to a 2005 survey by Elizabeth Warren, a Harvard professor who went on to become Obama's the chief financial industry bailout overseer.
This post features links to the best independent, progressive reporting about health care.
Tags: AHIP, Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Frank Luntz, healthare costs, healthcare industry, Healthcare NewsLadder, healthcare reform, healthcare spending, medical bills, Nancy Ann DeParle, Newsladder, public plan, Republicans, selling blood plasma, tax increase (all tags)