The Conservative Pope and the Secular Media

Over the past few weeks, the Catholic Church has found itself mired in controversy, plagued by an ever-growing sexual abuse scandal unfolding in Europe. The pope himself has come under substantial criticism, to such an extent that a leading German magazine titled a report, “The Failed Papacy of Benedict XVI.”

Yet the media’s growing chorus of criticism reveals as much about itself as it does about the mishaps of Pope Benedict XVI. It reveals much about how the media thinks about itself, and about the media’s worldview of what society ought to be like.

Historically, the Catholic Church and the Western media have always had moments of tension. The two are almost naturally at odds; their philosophical foundations constitute polar opposites. The church is fundamentally a conservative institution, hierarchy-bound and traditional. It embodies a force – religion – which often works in a conservative direction.

The modern Western media could not be more different from this. If liberalism were to be characterized, describing the media could do the job well. The media sees itself as an agent of change, uncovering society’s injustices and working towards reform. Under this view, the world is consistently getting better, and media lies on the vanguard of the forces of progress. Religion, on the other hand, constitutes an obstacle standing in the path to a better world.

To many holders of this belief (i.e. the media), Pope Benedict XVI is moving the church backwards in the 21st century. Unlike his predecessor, Benedict XVI is not considered a hero, nor is he adept at media relations (or particularly photogenic, for that matter). Instead, Benedict XVI is an intellectual traditionalist who spent much of his career attacking liberal reformists in the church before becoming pope.

In many ways, therefore, the media’s negative coverage of the pope is not only due to the current sexual abuse scandal. Rather, it is a critique of everything the media dislikes about the pope – his conservative worldview, his reintroduction of the Tridentine Mass, his apathy towards dialogue with other religions, his lifting of Holocaust denier Richard Williamson’s excommunication, and his many writings condemning the forces of secularism which created the media.

This is not to defend Pope Benedict XVI nor to attack the media. The church’s mishandling of the abuse scandal does indeed merit substantial criticism; its response has been defensive and clumsy. There is plenty of material to justify the media’s criticism; the cases of sexual abuse appear quite outrageous. On the church’s side, the pope’s traditionalist views are genuinely felt while his critiques against moral relativism are often quite legitimate.

Rather, this is to look beneath the surface of the sexual abuse controversy. Its widespread negative coverage constitutes part of a deeper, long-standing conflict between a conservative church and a liberal media. It won’t be the last time the church and the media come into conflict.



Mr. Netanyahu: 'tear down this wall'

(The Apartheid Wall snakes around the rim of Bethlehem. A solitary olive tree remains standing in an area that was once thriving. Over one million olive trees have been destroyed by bulldozers in the last 4 years, many to make way for the Apartheid Wall.)

There's more...

Pope calls for two-states UPDATES Juan Cole/UN Security Council

Following the US, the EU countries, Russia, the entire Arab League of 27 states, and the words of King Abdullah of Jordan committing the entire Muslim world to the recognition of Israel (no link), the Pope has now joined the peace effort to obtain Palestinian statehood. As the leader of the Catholic world, he has essentially committed a billion Catholic worshipers to resolving the plight of the Palestinian people, to taking sides with human rights.

This world-wide opening to peace, following Obama's lead, does make one wonder whether the Gaza massacre of 1,400 Palestinians, mostly innocent families and children, did not push world opinion concerning the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to an edge, where it can no longer be denied: that Israel's military occupation and colonialism of the Palestinian territories is wrong. Indeed, it has left the world in a moral-ethical quagmire that no longer can be tolerated.

There's more...

the pope is coming...look busy!

this is a story only getting scant attention so far by major news channels, but the pope is coming and he might have an impact on the pennsylvania primary.

the state of pennsylvania has a large catholic population and even though the most recent polls suggest a tight race between hillary and obama, the pope might change this trajectory.

There's more...

The Pope and ecumenicism

In Salon, there is a reprint of an Associated Press piece about a recent re-affirmation of a document by Pope Benedict XVI about the relations between the Catholic Church and other religious institutions.  

There's more...


Advertise Blogads