Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims

Republicans are desperate.  You would be too if the economic theory you'd imposed on the country had just pulled a Hindenburg.  Bush and Paulsen are doubling down and asking for an "Authorization for Use of Financial Force" - a no oversight, $700 billion dollar bailout that we'd call nationalization if it happened anywhere South of the Rio Grande or East of NYC.  Patrick Ruffini is begging the Congressional GOP Caucus to demagogue on the issue, economy be damned. And John McCain is asking Americans to suspend any remaining disbelief and imagine him as a populist.

My personal favorite new tactic of desperation is the blame the victims approach that Neil Cavuto and Pat Buchanan debuted on Faux News and MSNBC, respectively. Try and stay with me, but apparently the economy is in meltdown because middle-income Americans (or "minorities and risky folks" according to Mr. Cavuto) had the audacity to apply for and receive loans.

What happened exactly?  Did millions of people walk into banks with guns and demand to be approved for risky mortgages.  Then, did they storm Wall Street and force the titans of finance to take advantage of John McCain's banking deregulation to re-package these mortgages into securities that are falling faster than Bush's approval ratings post-Katrina?

Watch Cavuto below:

And, Pat (skip to the 5:15 mark):

It is preposterous and offensive to blame this crisis on hard working Americans who broke no laws and were only trying to do exactly what they're supposed to - buy homes.  Banks, lenders and financial institutions of all stripes made a series of exceptionally bad decisions, decisions made possible by a conservative economic philosophy that condones epic failures in regulation and oversight.  The blame lies with John McCain and his conservative Republican allies in Congress, who ended financial regulation as we knew it, and with George Bush, who, in shocking news, was asleep at the wheel.

Blaming consumers is the "Saddam planned 9/11" of economic excuse-making and we have to push back against it.



Display:


Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

Not Gonna Work THIS Time, I hope!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9njqqelj Ao


by gouko787 on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 10:53:02 AM EST

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

Pat Buchanan's ugly mug is blocking the recommended diaries.


Two riders were approaching......the wind begins to howl!
by John in Chicago on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 10:55:18 AM EST

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

That'll teach me to try and use tables.  Fixed.


by Aaron Banks on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 10:56:59 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

Thanks!


Two riders were approaching......the wind begins to howl!
by John in Chicago on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 12:08:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Wall St. Reckoning, The End of an Era (none / 0)

WALL STREET's RECKONING!  
(Yet, it Took 10 Years to Raise MinWage $1.00)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S27yitK32 ds

"Rule one: Rush the decision. Time the game to fall in the week before Congress is set to adjourn and just 6 weeks before an historic election so your opponents will be preoccupied, pressured, distracted, and in a hurry.

Rule two: Disarm the public through fear. Warn that the entire global financial system will collapse and the world will fall into another Great Depression. Control the media enough to ensure that the public will not notice this.   Bailout will indebt them for generations, taking from them trillions of dollars they earned and deserve to keep.

Rule three: Control the playing field and set the rules. Hide from the public and most of the Congress just who is arranging this deal. Communicate with the public through leaks to media insiders. Limit any open congressional hearings. Communicate with Congress via private teleconferencing calls. Heighten political anxiety by contacting each political party separately. Treat Members of Congress condescendingly, telling them that the matter is so complex that they must rely on those few insiders who really do know what's going on!"


by bacalove on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 12:32:04 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

Almost threw up my dinner while reading this opinion from OC Register on  September 21, 2008. This means that this letter was submitted before last Friday, September 16,2008.  This is a cordinated Repug smear.  It makes John Birch look like a ....

 Today, it seems to be the GOP blame game of the day.

 4th paragraph: 37 m ACORN blackmails mortgage industry.  Give me a fuckin break!!

 Look up ocregister... search acorn, and voila for authentification of this letter.

 "How far does Obama fall from the Acorn tree?

Barack Obama credits much of his understanding of the plight of poor people with his community organizer service, which he lists as one of his major accomplishments.

Between 1999 and 2002, Obama served on the Board of the Chicago-based Woods foundation with radical Weatherman bomber William Ayers. Together, they pumped millions in grants into organizations such as the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now. Acorn, with a $37 million annual budget, is involved in voter registration, fighting housing discrimination, and several other "grass roots" endeavors.

In voter registration drives, Acorn has added hundreds of thousands of minority voters to the Democratic Party rolls. However, Acorn has been indicted and workers convicted of voter fraud by also registering dead voters and fictitious non-existent people.

In the housing area, Acorn demonized banks and mortgage lenders for alleged "redlining" of minority neighborhoods and for denying loans to "underprivileged" borrowers. Many banks and lenders caved under Acorn threats to sue and granted "no stated income" loans, no down payment interest-only loans, and adjustable rate home loans to unqualified borrowers. The net result was the subprime meltdown and massive foreclosures when borrowers with no equity in their homes just walked away. Is this the kind of "community service" Obama is proud of?"


by ocdemocrat on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:05:28 AM EST

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (2.00 / 1)

"It is preposterous and offensive to blame this crisis on hard working Americans who broke no laws and were only trying to do exactly what they're supposed to - buy homes."

It is preposterous and offensive for white - rural voters to continue to vote AGAINST their economic interest and continue to elect GOP representatives who look out for the richest Americans.


by nzubechukwu on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:06:54 AM EST

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

The "ownership society"


by judyo on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:12:19 AM EST

This shows how little they actually know (none / 0)

about economic matters. This whole crisis really has very little to do with the actual defaults on mortgages and more to do with the people who could default or just walk away from terrible deals now that their real estate is worth 25% less than what their loans still have on it 943% of people owe more than their property is worth right now)...And even that simplistic explanation doesn't take into account the fact that even that wouldn't have posed as much risk for banks if it wasn't for the fact that all these loans are owned by about 2,000 someone elses now (most likely through 4 or 5 parties). And that still doesn't take into account the fact that all these prtgages still couldn't have brought most institutions down except for the fact that all these institutions leveraged these mortgages to each other buy issuing debt swaps guarunteeing them when they didn't own them...but yeah, it's the welfare moms again, that's the ticket!!!!


by Dingaling on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:20:11 AM EST

Re: This shows how little they actually know (none / 0)

that should read 43%, not 943%, sorry for the typo.


by Dingaling on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:21:07 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

I think it is very important to keep the Democrats' feet to the fire on this.  The inclination is to go along with most of the GOP "solution" to the crisis they are largely, but not totally, responsible for.  

The suggested solution, even when jimmied with a bit, is just not going to do it.  We need to be writing our reps and insisting that they show some courage in addressing the structural problems here.  There is NO quick fix, that is just a further abuse of working Americans.


by mady on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:23:41 AM EST

Re: BREAKING RUSE! (none / 0)

It's got nothing to do with the networks being stupid and everything  to do with them being spineless  and irrelevant.


by Lodgemannered on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 11:40:22 AM EST

It gets better (none / 0)

The far-right GOPers - the Pences and Bunnings who have been among the biggest bailout critics in GOP circules - have an alternate proposal...

This proposal is to eliminate entirely the capital gains tax.

Apparently, no one told them YOU DON'T PAY CAPITAL GAINS UNLESS YOU HAVE.... you know CAPITAL GAINS - meaning it this does nothing to address the toxic shitpile of credit default swap based securities that are driving this collapse.


by zonk on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 01:08:19 PM EST

Re: Republican Economic Plan: Blame The Victims (none / 0)

Rep. Kapture: make Wall Street pay back the loot, "right down to the tires on their Mercedes". :)


by DeanOR on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 01:55:22 PM EST

Uggh--the news (none / 0)

One advantage to living much of my time in Puerto Rico, relying on rabbit ears, and speaking very little Spanish so far is that I didn't even know who Cavuto was before seeing this clip.  Ah, bliss.

Of course, this was the first clip of Maddow I've seen too and it's nice to see someone laugh at Pat Buchanan.  While it would be nice to see Maddow more, the trade off to having to even flip through Fox News to get to her doesn't make it worth my paying for a satellite dish.

So I'll read, and reason, instead.

But here's my question:
Circumstantial evidence from the first clip suggests that Xavier Becerra could be an ethnic minority.  Was he not the slightest bit offended with Cavuto lumping all minorities into one basket with "risky" lenders?

Shouldn't he have called bullshit?


How is John McCain different than John Edwards?
by The lurking ecologist on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 02:03:19 PM EST

They weren't victims (none / 0)

There is a lot of culpability to go around in this whole mess and the banks own a lot of it, as do the individual mortgage agents.  But so do the people who took out the loans. They're not victims; they're co-conspirators.  If you make $60,000 and you're not smart enough to understand that you can't afford a $300,000 house, you deserve whatever you've got coming.

-rs1971


by rs1971 on Wed Sep 24, 2008 at 02:55:08 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.