The Math: overcoming media bias, 527s, and voting machines

We're up against 3 formidable independent forces in this election: a complacent (or complicit) media pushing pro-McCain, anti-Obama stories, 527 groups that are waiting to attack, and voting machine problems.

We tell ourselves "never again" about 2000 and 2004 - these three forces were in large part to blame for the losses in those years.  What are we willing to do to ensure that "never again" do we repeat 2000 or 2004?  In other words, how can we, independent of the Obama campaign's machinery, overcome these forces?  How much of a vote margin do we need to give Obama to overcome these 3 forces?

Read on to see why I believe we must recruit 198,000 new volunteers who will garner 9.9 million new votes.

Let's start with a couple assumptions:

1. The McCain and Obama campaigns will fend off attacks from one another.  Our simplistic assumption is that they will be roughly evenly matched, so no McCain attacks on Obama will stick better than Obama attacks on McCain.

2. The primary way we can help Obama get elected is by volunteering to register new voters (giving Obama a +1 net) or by flipping McCain voters (giving Obama a +2 net).

What we're up against.

Let's dive into the math.  My goal here isn't to do anything complicated, and the numbers we have to work with are very rough, but the goal is to provide a conservative estimate of how much work we need to do.

1. Impact of media bias = 2.5%.  To quantify this, I'm going to use the national polling averages from 2004, as seen here.  Using the following graph, we can see when different events shaped the polls (here shown using EVs): I'd argue that the media's bias isn't quantifiable in a positive direction but we can see the effect of Kerry overcoming media bias: the debates provided a way for Kerry to push back against the media's repetition of Bush talking points.  Thus, the bounce in early October from 43.5% to 46.0% is what we'll consider the anti-media bias bounce.

2. Impact of 527s = 3.0%.  Using the same approach as above, from the start of the SBVT 527 ads to the end, Kerry went from 48.0% to 45.0% in the national polls.

3. Impact of voting machines = 1.1%.  Voting machines are the last piece of this little math problem.  Verified Voting has an amazing map showing which states use good voting machines and which don't.  (In their map, yellow and red indicate trouble.)  They estimate that modern voting machines have a failure rate of 1.1%, so we'll use that figure.

Total margin we need to provide: 6.6%.  In other words, using this rough calculation, we need to bump Obama by 6.6% of the national vote to ensure a win despite media bias, 527s, and bad voting machines.

How do we do it?

1. Each volunteer = +50 votes.  Let's figure out how effective each volunteer can be.  There are roughly 100 days left until the election.  Let's say that on average, a dedicated volunteer is one that can get a +1 for Obama every other day.  (Most likely in bursts.)  That means registering one new Obama voter who will actually show up on election day, every other day.

2. Total 2008 turnout = 150,000,000.  There were 121 million voters in 2004, which was 20 million more than in 2000.  Let's say there'll be 150 million voters this year, give or take.

3. Total new Obama volunteers needed = 198,000.  We need to bump Obama by 6.6% of 150,000,000, which means we need 9,900,000 new Obama votes.  If each volunteer gets us 50 votes, we need 198,000 new volunteers.

Summary

The takeaway from this diary should be threefold:

1. Everyone, and I mean everyone needs to volunteer.  Go read how to do voter registration and get started today.  Also check out the Obama campaign's action guide.  The 198,000 new volunteers we need are ones in addition to the volunteers the Obama campaign already has.  We need to not just donate or blog - we need to get on the ground, knock on doors in communities that have never seen the attention of a presidential campaign, and register voters.

2. We need to be smart about where to target voters.  Target areas of town where the population is in flux more - where folks may not have registered yet.  (For example, in apartment buildings.)  Some states have high population turnover (Nevada) and are ripe for voter registration efforts.  Show up at naturalization ceremonies, where there will be thousands of new eager citizens who I'd bet would be excited to vote for the first son of an immigrant for president.  You can find your nearest Citizenship and Immigration office here and ask them for a list of naturalization ceremonies.

3. We need to do more than fight fire with fire.  Pushing back directly or complaining about media bias, about 527s, and about bad voting machines might be cathartic, but it doesn't overcome the impact of those forces to ensure a win.  We need to do an end run around these negative forces by appealing directly to the voters.

Also cross-posted at Daily Kos.


Poll
What's the best place to do voter registration?
County fairs
Apartment buildings
Naturalization ceremonies
High schools
Colleges and universities
Other (describe below)

Votes: 4
Results : Vote Link : Polls

Display:


Let's get some voters registered! (2.00 / 2)

We have 100 days to register at least 50 voters each.


by barath on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 06:13:52 PM EST

Re (2.00 / 2)

i wholeheartedly agree that it will be ground game efforts that will actually win this thing.  i also appreciate your attempt to quantify and counteract our barriers to success.

i strongly urge everyone to check out the events on mybo in their area.  there were 39 events within 50 miles of my home just this weekend.  here in KCMO, there are voter registration events at fourth of july parades, free friday night movies, saturday nights in the bar district, jill scott concert, chris rock, foo fighters, the commodores, and bruce springsteen. and this is just stuff going on in the next month or so...

it is so easy to find an event to attend and get involved.  i went to a voter registration training on wednesday and now im going to be volunteering at the obama speech in independence tomorrow!


by elie on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 06:26:02 PM EST

Re: The Math: overcoming media bias, 527s, and vot (2.00 / 2)

good job with your analysis. it helps to have things laid out in numbers-

[naturalization ceremonies are definitely a great place to register voters]


by alyssa chaos on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 06:38:42 PM EST

Re: The Math: overcoming media bias (none / 0)

With all due respect and I'm a democrat the media DOES NOT have a media bias against Obama. They were completely in the tank for him during the primaries and apart from the conservative ones who were dissing Hillary all the time until Obama was confirmed as the nominee (I wonder why they did that?) and have now switched of course to dissing him I don't see much has changed. If anything most of the media are giving McCain a harder time. I'm pleased about it but spare us the victimology. He's getting kid glove treatment still.  


by ottovbvs on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 07:16:08 PM EST

Re: The Math: overcoming media bias (2.00 / 1)

Notice that I don't claim that there is definitely media bias - I'm estimating a conservative number assuming that there will be media bias on the level that there was against Kerry.


by barath on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 07:52:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: The Math: overcoming media bias, 527s, and vot (2.00 / 1)

Very good job. I know David Plouffe will be mindful of this he is the wizard at this. Consider this too. If Obama were to increase AA turnout by 20% he gets a baseline EV of 293. Incredible isn't it?

It all there in 538.com turnout porjections models.


by Makey on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 08:44:17 PM EST

all of the above! (2.00 / 1)


Washington Woman

Progressive Blue

by kevin22262 on Sun Jun 29, 2008 at 10:09:21 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.