Buddha weeps in Jadugoda

This diary is about the nuclear trade deal that President Bush is trying to negotiate with India.  Most progressives, and most democrats oppose it.  

I support it!

For 2 reasons: (a) first, providing India with nuclear fuel may be a critical component in averting global warming.  I will skip that reason for now  (although it is a very important reason by itself). (b)  Instead, this diary will concentrate on the 2nd reason.

First some background on me:

I was born and raised in a part of India that happens to have most of India's known reserves of Uranium.  This region also happens to be one of the most backward regions in India ~ it is struggling to enter the 19th century, and is far removed from the gleaming metropolises of Bangalore and Gurgaon that Americans now associate with India.  The population of the district I was raised in has decreased in the last 25 years ~ people move out in search of better opportunities.

My direct proximity to those regions gave me a direct exposure to the affects of the Uranium mines.  Simply put, mine safety in India is atrocious ~ mine safety tends to be atrocious in all parts of the world where human labor is cheap and expendable.  But mine safety is even more tragic when you are dealing with Uranium.

The region around my hometown is the equivalent of America's Navajo Nation (those who are familiar with Uranium mining in the Navajo Nation will know what I am talking about).  

India's  Navajo Nation


Since 1967, when UCIL first started uranium mining in Jadugoda, the lives of people have been inflicted with unknown diseases, deaths and poisoned environment. The foundation of these mines has been laid on lies and misinformation by UCIL about the impact of uranium mining, radiation and toxicity in Jadugoda. Till the '90s the tailing ponds (where uranium mine liquid waste is stored to evaporate) was in close vicinity of areas in the villages used as children's playground, open grazing area and other public use. The radiation levels and related sickness were never revealed by UCIL, even though for years the local population has suffered from the extensive environmental degradation caused by the mining operations which are also responsible for the high frequency of radiation-related sicknesses and developmental disorders found in the area. Even though India's Atomic Energy Act states that there should be no habitation within five kilometers of a waste site or uranium-tailing pond and even though Jadugoda has been in operation for more than 30 years, seven villages stand within one and a half kilometers of the danger zone. One of them, Dungardihi, begins just 40 meters away.


It was only in 1996 when a group of people working in the mines and living in close vicinity started questioning the legitimacy UCIL's free rein to pollute the environment and lives of indigenous people. This led to the formation of a local anti-uranium mining group called Jharkhandis Organization Against Radiation whose mission is to resist further nuclear development, and to educate the local Adivasis about the dangers of radioactivity. JOAR is also a winner of the 2004 Nuclear-Free Future Resistance Award. Even after the documentation of severe damage caused by uranium mining in Jadugoda in a documentary titled "Buddha Weeps In Jadugoda" by Shri Prakash, UCIL still admits to no wrongdoing, claiming that none of the prevalent congenital diseases in the area are due to the radiation from their uranium mines and milling operations.

The name of the documentary "Buddha Weeps in Jadugoda" is somewhat ironic.  My hometown is not very far (200 km or so) from where Buddha sat under a Bodhi tree, meditated and attained salvation.  It is doubly ironic because India's first nuclear test (which occurred in 1975, and not in 1998...contrary to popular opinion in the US) was codenamed "The Smiling Buddha"... because it was a "peaceful nuclear test" meant to harness nuclear energy for miscellaneous peaceful purposes, including the rapid construction of dams by blowing up whole mountains.

And here is that documentary.  Bewarned:  if you have a heart, you will not be able to watch without shedding a few tears !





The part about women having spontaneous abortions was very painful for me: my parents had 7 children, but 3 were either stillborn or died minutes after birth.  I will never know why: I have not had a single conversation about those stillbirths with anyone in my whole life (other than when my father acknowledged it, and then declared that he did not wish to discuss it).  

Under current Indian law, it is very difficult to hold UCIL (the Uranium Corp of India, which is owned by the Indian Government) responsible.  For one thing, the court system is dysfunctional ~ it can take decades to dispose of cases.  Secondly, current law sides with the mining company ~ in order to hold them liable (or to force them to make improvements), it is necessary to prove that their actions are responsible for the skeletal deformities, the cancer, and the stillbirths.  But how does one "prove" such a thing ?  Cancer, and skeletal deformities, and stillbirths occur even amongst those who are not exposed to any radiation.  The mere fact that cancer etc occurs more often when one is exposed to radiation does not "prove" that the two are linked... as per current Indian law.

And that brings me to the real reason I support the US-India trade deal:   under the terms of that deal, all civilian Indian nuclear facilities (and this would include the mines at Jadudoga) would be subject to IAEA safeguards.

Those IAEA safeguards would mean that Buddha would, finally, stop weeping in Jadugoda.

I hope you will support it too... or at least be less vehement in your opposition to it !!
   

Update [2008-6-22 18:1:19 by SevenStrings]: Thank you semiquaver, louisprandtl, Canadian Gal and alyssa chaos. 4 recs puts this on the rec list (must be another slow MyDD day =)

Display:


I have never asked for a rec before... (2.00 / 7)

but I would very much appreciate a rec for this diary.  I want more people to see it.

Thank you, and I will answer as many questions as I can !


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 04:35:25 PM EST

This was a very touching diary..extremely sad (2.00 / 2)

to see all of the clips that you provided. Is there a way for NGOs to use some international forum to put pressure on the Indian Government?


by louisprandtl on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 04:50:47 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I dont think so (none / 0)

The NGOs (and the Catholic church too) are very active in educating the people, and so on... and that helps quite a lot

but there is not much an NGO can do against the mighty Indian government...

there is a budding communist rebllion in those parts... that is applying more pressure.


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 04:57:46 PM EST
[ Parent ]

India already has nuclear weaponry (2.00 / 2)

So what's the potential downside in helping them out with reactor technology?  I know many people stand against the idea of nuclear power in general, but I gather that many areas of India would benefit greatly from more inexpensive, clean power.  They could use our help, and most other members of the 'nuclear club' have access to American nuclear fuel and technology, so why not India?

Unlike most nuclear countries in the world, India is not a signatory to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.  Consequently, they are barred from trading nuclear technology with other countries, so they have developed most of their reactor technology 'in-house', without benefit of the international community's repertoire of safer, more efficient designs.  This makes no sense to me.

Besides the very sad issues SevenStrings brings up above, It seems to me that a three-mile-island type scenario is much more likely to occur in India if they continue to go it alone and use outdated reactor technology.  There is no risk to anyone if we help them, but doing so has the potential to save or at least improve many millions of lives.


by semiquaver on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 05:04:48 PM EST

Re: India already has nuclear weaponry (none / 0)

Thank you !

And yes, you provided an excellent background to India's nuclear program.  For the reasons you mentioned, India may yet no sign that Nuclear trade deal ~ they believe that they have an in-house solution (in thorium) and would rather not have any strategic deals with the US if they can avoid it.


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 05:14:37 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

Thank you so much for the diary and the links. I love all of the stuff I learn here.


"And I scream at the top of my lungs, what's going on?"
by Hollede on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 07:05:51 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

sevenstrings, this is such an important diary, I learned a lot, althought it was painful. thank you wholeheartedly. I spent some time in calcutta a decade or so ago and I thought those conditions were brutal--not for all of course--for for so many. Please keep posting.


by linfar on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 08:18:32 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (none / 0)

what were you doing in Calcutta ?


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:16:00 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 2)

even if all progressives tomorrow magically decide to support the treaty it will still fail because it is opposed by the communist party of India which is a member of the ruling coalition. In effect the communists are keeping India in poverty and if anything hampering growth and progress unless they have something to gain from it. Unfortunately the treaty is not going forward because of local politics.


by tarheel74 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 08:28:38 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (none / 0)

The communists in India may yet come around to the nuclear deal... the stronger opposition is from the scientists themselves.

Communism in India has served a very important role in implementing land reforms, and other measures that reduced the disparities between the have-mores and the have-nothings.

Electoral success has been their reward

In West Bengal, for instance, the communists have been elected into power continuously since 1977.


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:42:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 2)

I don't think scientists oppose the deal as much. The entire reason for the current government including Manmohan Singh who staked his personal credibility to back down was the communist party which is the second largest bloc in the coalition threatened to remove support and even did.

As far as land reform goes, whatever they did in 1977 and since then died off in the 90s. Since then they have been a bunch of avaricious power hungry motherfuckers who are ruling the state (West Bengal) by means of terror. They would have been booted out long ago had not the opposition parties been so weak (Congress, BJP and Trinamul Congress). That is the only reason they can commit atrocities like they did at Nandigram and still face no repercussions.


by tarheel74 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:53:30 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (none / 0)

You may be right.  I have been too far removed since the 80s to know what CPI-M has been upto recently.  And power does tend to corrupt... noone is immune to that !!


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:56:13 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

search Nandigram and Singur either on google or wikipedia. You will soon get a token picture of their villainy.


by tarheel74 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 11:01:34 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

Communist in west Bengal have very little seats in the parliament to hurt the deal. and just because they have been wining in west Bengal since 1977. its has  been a slim majority...

west Bengal also happens to vote communist because of their pro labor standards and then of course west bengal's biggest freedom fighter/hero against the British happened to believe the communist principles. I forget his name was " subash  something"


Rise / Repeat / But for god's sake don't spin!
by aliveandkickin on Wed Jun 25, 2008 at 08:09:53 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

Thanks for this well thought out diary.  It's important to remember that the world of human interaction is rarely one of absolutes, and that the black/white comparison we wish to find in every issue is rarely as common in the real world as in our imaginations.


No way. No how. No McCain.
by freedom78 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:21:47 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

Update [2008-6-22 18:1:19 by SevenStrings]: Thank you semiquaver, louisprandtl, Canadian Gal and alyssa chaos. 4 recs puts this on the rec list (must be another slow MyDD day =)

Maybe we can all come together around something...


Proud member of the Wikipedia Generation of American politics
by BishopRook on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:35:45 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

I just noticed the series of comments you left on an earlier diary.  I am sorry for not having noticed it earlier, and I must say...I do not know the full answer right now.  

So, I will go digging up the answer, and post a reply in the next few days !!


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:51:53 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (none / 0)

Thanks.


Proud member of the Wikipedia Generation of American politics
by BishopRook on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 11:29:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 2)

Great diary. I personally support nuclear deal that was jointly agreed. I think communist party is holding the bill hostage. However, given the necessity and importance of communist party in the coalition government, I guess its the bill is a losing cause. Nevertheless, I hope day will come when third world countries like india are more energy independent, and in that perspective, I whole heartedly support going nuclear.


by gladiatorsback on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:43:23 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (2.00 / 1)

--- i liked the different view of the whole situation that you provided. being born in India, you gave a hugely different angle of the story that i haven't heard before---

[glad to see your diary on the rec list;]


by alyssa chaos on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:51:49 PM EST

Re: Buddha weeps in Jadugoda (none / 0)

Thank you!

Most of my liberal friends oppose the deal, and most of my conservative friends support it (for reasons that I do not support).  I find that somewhat frustrating !


If you follow history with a long enough arc, things always get better, and the truth always prevails...Gandhi
by SevenStrings on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 10:53:25 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.