Results in one race don't predict the other!

I had a conversation today with a friend who is a researcher, which put things in an interesting perspective.  The point he made was that just because Hillary out-performs Obama with certain constituencies when she is head to head with him, doesn't mean that she will outperform him vs. John McCain.  Indeed if there is a correlation, it is probably a relatively small one.

Look at it this way.  Let's say you take a population of people and offer them ice cream.  They have two choices - vanilla or chocolate.  Let's for the sake of argument say that more people pick vanilla.

Then, on another day, we offer the same population ice cream again, but this time the choice is vanilla or strawberry.  The fact that people chose vanilla over chocolate gives you almost zero information about whether people will pick vanilla over strawberry.

And... it will also give you no information for predicting whether the same people would pick chocolate over strawberry.

This entire effort on behalf of the Clinton campaign to show that  HRC's stronger performance in one contest is predictive of what her performance would be in another is completely illogical.  Its like saying people who choose vanilla ice cream over chocolate will also choose vanilla over strawberry.



Display:


Re: Results in one race don't predict the other! (none / 0)

Are you for real? If a political pundit used your analogy, they would be out of a job.


by soyousay on Fri May 09, 2008 at 05:37:50 PM EST

Thing is (none / 0)

Obama supporters have also used this analogy, pointing to his wins in red states. Someone yeseterday on this blog though he could win Alaska because of his primary win there.


by Mayor McCheese on Fri May 09, 2008 at 05:49:57 PM EST

Re: Results in one race don't predict the other! (none / 0)

OMG you convinced me. Too bad its far too late.


John McCain
by Mandoliniment on Fri May 09, 2008 at 05:58:37 PM EST

Re: Results in one race don't predict the other! (none / 0)

I resent you implying that McCain is like strawberry ice cream.

I LOVE STRAWBERRY ICE CREAM.  How dare you sir, how dare you denigrate strawberry ice cream.


by The Distillery on Fri May 09, 2008 at 06:18:37 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.