The debate continues about the legitimacy of Clinton's current position that the DNC-imposed penalty on Florida and Michigan is "disenfranchisement" akin to barring women and African-Americans from voting.
Clinton, of course, did not publicly oppose the penalty until long after the decision was made. Indeed, other than some mild and frankly vague comments in a New Hampshire radio interview (right after she famously said the Michigan contest "would not count"), I am unaware of any public statement by Clinton or her campaign against the penalty until after the Iowa contest. As the Florida journalist asked her the other day, "Where were you when we needed you"? (She had no answer).
One possible explanation for this is that Clinton believed that the problem would be solved by a revote. Some have even suggested that this has happened in the past (though I haven't seen evidence of that). This explanation, however, faces a serious problem: Clinton opposed revotes until at least mid March, about 2 month after Michigan and Florida's contests.
Take, for example, these two quotes:
"And I don't think that there should be any do-over or any kind of a second run in Florida. I think Florida should be seated." (Hillary Clinton 3/6/08)
"Our position is that the voters of Michigan and Florida have spoken." (Clinton spokesman Howard Wolfson 3/6/08)
If she believed that the penalty was disenfranchisement, was a serious moral issue, opposing revotes that would let the voters in FL and MI have their say would have simply been wrong. But that's what she did.
Let me be perfectly clear here. I am afraid that Clinton's overheated rhetoric on this issue is not based on genuine concern, but rather political calculation. Moreover, I am concerned that her rhetoric is poisoning voters in ways far more severe than the DNC's penalty alone ever could -- and thus sabotaging the party in November. And I hope that her supporters will see that this is happening and tone it down.
|
|
|
Permalink :: 45 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.