A Request for the Doomsayers

Just a request for those on this site who like to spread gloom and doom about Sen. Obama's chances in the general against Sen. McCain, should Obama win the nomination.

Could you tag your dire pronouncements of the end of the Democratic party, Obama's surefire crushing loss, and the inevitably barn-red electoral map come November with a little disclaimer as to whether this is something you desire?

It's easy:

"McCain is going to crush Obama this fall, no contest, the Democratic party is toast for the next quarter century, you'll never get the Clinton coalition back." (^)

(^) I do not wish for this to happen.

Or:

"McCain is going to slice through Obama's weak-ass coalition like a hot knife through butter, the Democratic party has been irredeemably destroyed." (^)

(^) I do wish for this to happen.

It would make it easier to know who to respond to.

For those who don't want McCain to beat Obama--and I must give props to Alegre here, passionate Clinton supporter, who has declared she will support the eventual nominee--I feel you!  Let's make sure it doesn't happen.  It sucks when your candidate loses--or is currently losing--and especially when your candidate is as skilled, passionate, and intelligent as Sen. Clinton.  It's hard to switch gears, and I don't expect many will unless/until Clinton concedes.  (Which she really has no reason to do until PR has voted.)  So, I'm glad to know we'll be on the same side soon enough.  Some of your pessimism may be warranted.  It will be a tough GE, no doubt.  Let's get on it.

For those who claim to choose McCain over Obama: could you briefly summarize Clinton's agenda, and then explain to me how a McCain election will help further that agenda?  

Because it seems to me that Clinton's agenda presumably includes withdrawing troops from Iraq (something I don't support, by the way), her health care program (which I do), SCOTUS appointees to counteract the originalist coup and preserve Roe v. Wade, and (gas tax holiday aside) reasonable and progressive economic policies.  

I find John McCain an admirable man in many respects, and I'm not looking forward to the prospect of Democratic sites using the same bullshit tactics on him that they decry when used against their own candidate.  (If it's bad when they do it then it's bad when we do it, and don't even get me started on nicknames like "McSame" . . . weak fucking sauce.)  But a McCain administration would actively defeat and/or set back every single aspect of the agenda Clinton is running to implement.  Can you explain how helping elect McCain will, in any way, help the things Clinton's running for?

Cynical Koan wants to believe that, for many Clinton supporters wailing about a McCain landslide, it's not about getting a Democratic agenda enacted.  It's about some sort of personal validation.  Reasonable Koan would like to be persuaded otherwise.



Display:


Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (2.00 / 2)

Longtime lurker and commenter, first diary.


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Tue May 13, 2008 at 04:51:05 PM EST

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

I think a lot of them have invested a lot of time and energy towards Hillary's campaign and in heated times things will be said.  I am certain the majority will follow Obama's campaign once McCain's policies and issues are at the helm.  There will be those who hate Obama that they will not vote for him, it is what it is.   We need to focus on the millions of voters that did not vote in 2004 and attract them into the party.  We have a great candidate and we need to spread the message.  


I would say at this point we're starting to see a little desperation on the part of the woman who I support... NY Governor Paterson
by obamaovermccain on Tue May 13, 2008 at 04:55:43 PM EST

Clinton needs a Democratic president. (none / 0)

Eventually her hardened supporters will realize that she will actually be able to enact her legislation to secure her legacy with a Democratic president, no matter who it is, because McCain will veto her more far-reaching stuff like health care issues.

Of course there are plenty here who want McCain because they're actually partisan Republicans or simply hate Obama for somewhat far-out reasons.


In this avalanche, the pebbles get to vote.
by Dracomicron on Tue May 13, 2008 at 05:05:18 PM EST

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (1.00 / 0)

(First of all, I voted for Obama for Senate.)  
I don't think Barack is ready for President.  I think Hillary is ready.  I think McCain is ready.  
I don't see the EC map that gets Barack the presidency.  I do see the EC map for a Hilary win.  
I think a lot of his support is a response to Hillary's "authorization" vote.
I think only the Dems can snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
I fear if he does win the presidency, he will be another Carter; we will have an international crisis.  I think our "enemies" will test him and something will go awry.
However, I do think Dems will control both Houses, and as such, if he is president, we will get a lot of Dem domestic programs passed.
I'm just being honest.
 
Have you seen my site, 777craprepublicanblog? No? Try 777smear.
by ChitownDenny on Tue May 13, 2008 at 06:17:44 PM EST

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

Fair enough, I guess.  But which of Clinton's domestic programs do you think a President McCain is likely to pass?  

"I don't see the EC map that gets Barack the presidency.  I do see the EC map for a Hilary win.  
I think a lot of his support is a response to Hillary's "authorization" vote.
I think only the Dems can snatch defeat from the jaws of victory."

As to these points, this is your assessment of Obama's likely success in the fall, or lack thereof.  I disagree, but whatever.  My question is, do you want the Dems to lose?  Or do you just think they will and there's nothing you can do about it?

And what will you do if and when Clinton asks her supporters to support the Dem nominee?


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Tue May 13, 2008 at 07:15:32 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (1.00 / 0)

I haven't decided.  I do think if Obama is the president, and, in fact has a Carter presidency, which I find more probable than less, Dems will wait another 3 or 4 terms to get the presidency back.  
If McCain is the president (not that I support his agenda), I think the Dems will control Congress, making a McCain presidency impotent.
Have you seen my site, 777craprepublicanblog? No? Try 777smear.
by ChitownDenny on Tue May 13, 2008 at 07:55:57 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

Er, see my reply below.


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Tue May 13, 2008 at 08:07:10 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

Again, fair enough, and I appreciate your willingness to engage.  I guess I just don't see how you can support Clinton's candidacy but would be willing to basically sacrifice it to keep Obama out of office.  

Clinton's running for a reason: to enact her vision of a progressive agenda.  She's fought hard for it.  By voting for McCain this fall, you'd be undermining every single thing she's fought for.

Your choice, I guess.  I think most Democrats understand the threat McCain poses to a progressive America.


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Tue May 13, 2008 at 08:06:20 PM EST

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (1.00 / 0)

It's a long view, not just then next 4 years.  


Have you seen my site, 777craprepublicanblog? No? Try 777smear.
by ChitownDenny on Tue May 13, 2008 at 08:10:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

If a Bradley supporter had said that in 2000 about voting for Bush over Gore, what would your response have been?


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Tue May 13, 2008 at 08:13:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (1.00 / 0)

I found Gore to be more qualified than Bradley.  I still find him to be one of the eminently qualified people to be president.  Just as I do Clinton.  Bradley is not in this equation.


Have you seen my site, 777craprepublicanblog? No? Try 777smear.
by ChitownDenny on Tue May 13, 2008 at 08:20:33 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: A Request for the Doomsayers (none / 0)

What I mean is, people for whom Gore wasn't their first choice could have argued that they would vote for Bush in the fall because they were looking at the long term, not just "the next four years."

Would it have been worth it?


What is The October Protocol?
by Koan on Wed May 14, 2008 at 03:58:30 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.