GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter

This news was relayed by Muzzlewatch this morning. The Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported that:

Two Republican congressmen introduced legislation that would deny the Carter Center federal dollars.

U.S. Reps. Joe Knollenberg (R-Mich.) and Bill Shuster (R-Pa.) introduced the Coordinated American Response to Extreme Radicals Act, or CARTER Act, last week in the wake of former President Jimmy Carter's recent outreach to Hamas.

"America must speak with one voice against our terrorist enemies," Knollenberg said in a statement. "It sends a fundamentally troubling message when an American dignitary is engaged in dialogue with terrorists. My legislation will make sure that taxpayer dollars are not being used to support discussions or negotiations with terrorist groups."

Only the simple minded, deceived, or dishonest do not know that this line of thinking has its roots in official Israeli hasbara (propaganda) intended to characterize Israel as the victim of terrorism, in spite of its continuing military occupation and colonization of Palestinian lands in the West Bank.

Hamas, however, is not a terrorist organization. The PLO in its early days was. As Jimmy Carter correctly informed a few nights ago on the Charlie Rose Show, Hamas became a terrorist organization only after it won the Palestinian elections. Furthermore, if you have to label Hamas' resistance to military occupation terrorism, then you must also see Israel's military occupation as a terrorist project. Indeed, looking at the death tolls since 2000, depending on the year, the Israelis have killed five to thirteen times more Palestinian civilians including children who count for 20% of those killed, and began those killings first after Ariel Sharon instigated the second Intifada.

The "terrorist" labeling of Palestinians, of course, is merely intended to cover up the ongoing military occupation, colonialism, ethnic cleansing, and further killing and maiming of innocent Palestinian civilians and resisters of occupation. Truth is that, according to international law, a military occupied people have the full right to resist that occupation.

The documentary, Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land (Part I and Part II) has been telling this story for the past two years (Click to see).

The Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) praised the legislation against Carter. Since ZOA is probably the most leading right wing Zionist or Likudnik (meaning, no state for the Palestinians) organization in the US, only its sympathizers would agree with their praise.

But the most disturbing aspect of this proposed legislation is that it is just a symptom of what is wrong with American foreign policy in the Middle East: it merely follows the dictates of official Israeli government propaganda, which, as stated, is solely intended to justify its continuing military occupation and colonization of the West Bank, to essentially blame the occupation of the Palestinians on the Palestinians themselves. Pretty slick.

But Americans, if not some of their politicians, are slowly waking up. This legislation against one of America's greatest humanitarians is going nowhere.



Display:


Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

I called each of their congressional offices to complain.
It is the worst example of GOP congressional small-mindedness.
by johnnygunn on Thu May 01, 2008 at 10:37:51 AM EST

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (2.00 / 1)

Thanks Johnnygunn.

GOP congressional small-mindedness is well-known. We've had more than eight years of it, going back to the Gingrich House. I would be more interested in seeing if Democratic congressmen and women fall for this tripe, and eat their own. From Hillary and McCain I would expect similar actions or sentiments, but even Obama fell in line and criticized.


Click on Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land and learn the truth about the I/P conflict.
by shergald on Thu May 01, 2008 at 12:14:55 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Pretty horrible (2.00 / 1)

I was annoyed with Obama when he criticized Carter for using the strategy that he himself has championed, talking to our "enemies," because he was most likely getting pressure from high profile Jewish folks.

The fact that Carter actually walked away with the potential for progress makes the GOP attack that much dumber.


In this avalanche, the pebbles get to vote.

That One/Another Fella '08

by Dracomicron on Thu May 01, 2008 at 10:47:36 AM EST

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (2.00 / 1)

Hamas is a terrorist organization!  It's been classified as such by many governments.


The Kentucky Democrat
by kydem on Thu May 01, 2008 at 12:21:27 PM EST

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

And Benjamin Franklin said,
"We must all hang together or we shall, most certainly, all hang separately."

Obviously, the British considered American revolutionaries to be traitors and, yes, terrorists.  They had levied war against the agents of the crown - not to mention that the colonial tactics were viewed by the British as barbaric.  When power is highly asymmetric the weaker party believes itself justified to use whatever tactics necessary.

Are the tactics used by Hamas deplorable?  Yes.  
Are the tactics used by Israel horrible?  Yes.
But realistically, any settlement in the Middle East will have to include Hamas.


by johnnygunn on Thu May 01, 2008 at 12:58:40 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

What governments do for the sake of political expediency, like the US and its State Department, hardly qualifies as reason to classify anyone anything. It is all about propaganda. Prior to the Palestinian election, where were these condemnations of Hamas as a terrorist organization. When Hamas inadvertently won, the terrorist meme was introduced as a means to nullify a perfectly democratic process.

It is your choice to remain naive about the propaganda ploys used by Israel to avoid peace initiatives. But that is all that it is. What people living under military occupation have ever been considered terrorist? The French Resistence? The Italian Resistance?

Want to tell us just how Hamas qualifies as a terrorist organization by common definition?

Wikipedia

Terrorism is a term used to describe violence or other harmful acts committed (or threatened) against civilians by groups or persons for political, nationalist, or religious goals. As a type of unconventional warfare, terrorism means to weaken or supplant existing political landscapes through capitulation, acquiescence, or radicalization, as opposed to subversion or direct military action.

Free Dictionary

terrorism - the calculated use of violence (or threat of violence) against civilians in order to attain goals that are political or religious or ideological in nature; this is done through intimidation or coercion or instilling fear

Proposed Definitions of Terrorism

1. League of Nations Convention (1937):
"All criminal acts directed against a State and intended or calculated to create a state of terror in the minds of particular persons or a group of persons or the general public".

2. UN Resolution language (1999): criminal acts intended or calculated to provoke a state of terror in the general public, a group of persons or particular persons for political purposes are in any circumstance unjustifiable, whatever the considerations of a political, philosophical, ideological, racial, ethnic, religious or other nature that may be invoked to justify them". (GA Res. 51/210 Measures to eliminate international terrorism)


Click on Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land and learn the truth about the I/P conflict.
by shergald on Thu May 01, 2008 at 01:30:17 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

Is it the suicide bombings during the second Intifada? Well are some facts you might want to digest. You might actually decide that Israel was and is conducting state terrorism against a people that it militarily occupies.

Discussing just the killings of children,

The first suicide bombing in the second intifadah was on Dec. 22 (no Israelis died in it). By that time, 86 Palestinian children (<18 years of age) had been killed by Israelis http://www.rememberthesechildren.org/rem ember2000.html

The first Israeli child was killed on Jan. 17, 2001 http://www.rememberthesechildren.org/rem ember2001.html
By that time, at least 90 Palestinian children had been killed by Israelis.

Alison Weir, in her documentary Off the Charts, noted the following about 27 of these children:

Before a single suicide bomber had entered Israel after the start of the Second Intifada, sometimes called, after Sharon's provocative visit to the Temple Mount, the al Aqsa Intifada, during its first month, 27 Palestinian children had been killed by Israeli Defense Forces in the West Bank and Gaza, the youngest only four months of age, and the majority due to gunshots to the head. Numerous children were also wounded. In the first three months alone, 159 children lost an eye presumably to rubber bullets shot from IDF rifles. Clearly the IDF were intentionally targeting these children, aiming at their heads with either rubber bullets or real bullets in the case of the child kills. We are talking here about a trained, mechanized army versus civilians, children participating in the intifada, the nonviolent resistance instituted by child and teenage Palestinian boys and girls. Oh, yes. Let's be fair. We did hear that an Israeli soldier lost his eye from a rock thrown by a Palestinian boy from a pretty IDF spokeswoman, but it was the only such incident reported in three years.

In addition to these children, many more innocent adult civilians were killed, in the month before suicide bombings commenced. If terrorism is the intentional killing of civilians, then clearly, Israel's armed forces were deep into terrorism, state sponsored terrorism, long before the Palestinians engaged in it to any degree. As a people fighting a military occupation, it would seem that the ultimate cause of all of these horrors on both sides rests with Israel and the purpose for which it continued its long occupation, the stealing of Palestinian lands.  

See Alison Weir's short documentary, Off The Charts: Media Bias and Censorship in America for the names, ages, places, and dates of these child killings.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid= -5600677940569035557&q=Alternate+Foc us

To be accurate, there were sporadic bombing incidents engineered by Hamas extremists in Israel during the Oslo period. None at all occurred between 1998 and 2000. But the strong resumption of attacks after 2000, over fifty in the first year, was directly related to civilian and child killings by IDF, and it was not just Hamas, but Islamic Jihad and other Fatah associated organizations that were involved.

This Time.com article apprises of what motivated them, and it was not terrorism:

"Until recently most Palestinians believed they had alternatives to the kind of militancy practiced by Hamas. For years after the 1993 Oslo peace accord, which brought limited self-rule to the Palestinians and the prospect of an independent state, polls showed a strong majority of Palestinians supporting the peace process with Israel and only a minority endorsing suicide bombings. Thus, in their headhunting, the fundamentalists were limited to stalwart followers of their doctrine, which holds that any kind of peace with Israel is anathema. Even then, Hamas and Islamic Jihad had to cajole--some might say brainwash--young men into believing that the rewards of paradise outweighed the prospects of life on earth.

But with the breakdown of the peace process in the summer of 2000 and the start of the latest intifadeh that September, the martyr wannabes started coming to Hamas--and they didn't require persuading. "We don't need to make a big effort, as we used to do in the past," Abdel Aziz Rantisi, one of Hamas' senior leaders, told TIME last week. The TV news does that work for them. "When you see the funerals, the killing of Palestinian civilians, the feelings inside the Palestinians become very strong," he explained."

From the mouth of Rantisi, but it also motivated Fatah supporters, to exact revenge for the killing of Palestinian civilians. Revenge is not a formal use of terrorism.(read, Why Suicide Bombing Is Now All The Rage)
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/articl e/0,9171,1101020415-227546,00.html

This commentary is from an article by Rami Khouri, editor of the Beirut newspaper, The Daily Star, which cynically denounced Olmert's statements professing concern for the well-being of Palestinian children:

(Ehud Olmert's Profound Ethics and Deep Lies)
http://www.ramikhouri.com/

"For anyone interested in the facts about the impact of Israeli policies on Palestinian children, a good place to start is the carefully checked data disseminated by the Palestinian Nongovernmental Organization Network (www.palestinemonitor.org). Their data is compiled and verified on the ground by the Ramallah-based Health Development Information and Policy Institute, which has been honored by the World Health Organization for its work in promoting Palestinian health needs. So these people know what they are talking about when it comes to health conditions on the ground in Israeli-occupied Palestine. Some of the facts they provide are as follows.

In just the first two years of the second intifada, from September 2000 to November 2002:

* 383 Palestinian children (under the age of 18) were killed by the Israeli army and Israeli settlers, i.e. almost 19% of the total Palestinians killed; those figures have increased since then.

* Approximately 36% of total Palestinians injured (estimated at more than 41,000) are children; 86 of these children were under the age of ten; 21 infants under the age of 12 months have been killed.

* 245 Palestinian students and school children have been killed; 2,610 pupils have been wounded on their way to or from school.

* The Israeli policy of widespread closure has paralyzed the Palestinian health system, with children particularly vulnerable to this policy of collective punishment. Internal closures have severely disrupted health plans which affect over 500,000 children, including vaccination programs, dental examinations and early diagnosis for children when starting schools.

* During the first two months of the intifada, the rate of upper respiratory infections in children increased from 20% to 40%. Almost 60% of children in Gaza suffer parasitic infections.

* An overwhelming number of Palestinian children show symptoms of trauma such as sleep disorders, nervousness, decrease in appetite and weight, feelings of hopelessness and frustration, and abnormal thoughts of death.

* There have been 36 cases of Palestinian women in labor delayed at checkpoints and refused permission to reach medical facilities or for ambulances to reach them. At least 14 of these women gave birth at the checkpoint with eight of the births resulting in the death of the newborn infants.

The Israeli army killing of Palestinian children continues apace. In its annual report May 16, the respected global human rights organization Amnesty International accused the Israeli army of killing 190 Palestinians, including 50 children, last year (2005)."

Here is some commentary from Jonathan Cook on a grandmother suicide bomber. Ask yourself: was this grandmother a terrorist?

"If one thing offers a terrifying glimpse of where the experiment in human despair that is Gaza under Israeli siege is leading, it is the news that a Palestinian woman in her sixties -- a grandmother -- chose last week to strap on a suicide belt and explode herself next to a group of Israeli soldiers invading her refugee camp.

Despite the "Man bites dog" news value of the story, most of the Israeli media played down the incident. Not surprisingly -- it is difficult to portray Fatma al-Najar as a crazed fanatic bent only the destruction of Israel.

It is equally difficult not to pause and wonder at the reasons for her suicide mission; according to her family, one of her grandsons was killed by the Israeli army, another is in a wheelchair after his leg had to be amputated, and her house had been demolished.

Or not to think of the years of trauma she and her family have suffered living in a open-air prison under brutal occupation, and now, since the "disengagement", the agonising months of grinding poverty, slow starvation, repeated aerial bombardments, and the loss of essentials like water and electricity.

Or not to ponder at what it must have been like for her to spend every day under a cloud of fear, to be powerless against a largely unseen and malign force, and to never know when death and mutilation might strike her or her loved ones.

Or not to imagine that she had been longing for the moment when the soldiers who have been destroying her family's lives might show themselves briefly, coming close enough that she could see and touch them, and wreak her revenge.

Yet Western observers, and the organizations that should represent the very best of their Enlightenment values, seem incapable of understanding what might drive a grandmother to become a suicide bomber. Their empathy fails them, and so does their humanity.

Just at the moment Fatma was choosing death and resistance over powerlessness and victimhood -- and at a time when Gaza is struggling through one of the most oppressive and ugly periods of Israeli occupation in nearly four decades -- Human Rights Watch published its latest statement on the conflict. It is document that shames the organization, complacent Western societies and Fatma's memory."

The terrorist meme against Hamas is just Israel's latest propaganda ploy. Stop being so naive.


Click on Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land and learn the truth about the I/P conflict.
by shergald on Thu May 01, 2008 at 01:39:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

That's bull and you know it.  You are so fervent in your anti-Israel postings that it is a complete waste of my time to even bother replying to you.

You post these articles daily and it serves you no help at all.


The Kentucky Democrat
by kydem on Thu May 01, 2008 at 04:25:15 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: GOP lawmakers target Jimmy Carter (none / 0)

Facts are sometimes difficult to take when they contradict your preconceptions.

I gave out the links for the documentary, Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land above. Take a look at what you say is bull. Half the participants are Israelis, by the way. There seems to be another Israel out there unknown to you, which makes the notion of being anti-Israel absurd.


Click on Peace, Propaganda, & The Promised Land and learn the truth about the I/P conflict.
by shergald on Thu May 01, 2008 at 07:25:28 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.