Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself

I have read a number of blog posts, diaries, etc. recently that ask: what has Obama/Clinton actually accomplished? So I decided to make it easier for people to answer that question for themselves, and to compare the legislative records of the two. Other people have compared their voting histories -- see, for instance, here -- so I thought it would be interesting to ask: what legislation have each of the candidates actually gotten passed? I thought this would be worth knowing for two reasons: first, it's an indication of their priorities, and second, it helps us to assess their effectiveness as legislators.

So I went through and compiled a list, in three parts. Bills and amendments the two candidates sponsored that became law are here; bills and amendments they co-sponsored that became law are here, except for amendments they co-sponsored in the 109th Congress, which are here.

Except in the 'sponsored bills' part, I excluded legislation that: (a) simply states policy, expresses the sense of the Senate, or requires a report; (b) is purely ceremonial (e.g., naming post offices); (c) is of purely local interest (counting bills Clinton passed about NYC and 9/11 as being of more than local interest); or (d) appropriates less than $50 million and does nothing else that's not covered in a-c above. I did this because legislation in any of the above categories seemed to me relatively easy to get passed, and so less worth focussing on.

I did this to make it easier for people who wonder what Clinton and Obama have actually accomplished during their time in the Senate to find out the answer for themselves. Personally, I support Obama, for reasons I explain here and here. But I'm more committed to the idea that everyone should decide, one way or the other, on the basis of facts and information. And that's why I did this.

I hope it's useful.



Display:


Re: Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself (none / 0)

man that's hard work to read that stuff.


by vivelosdiablosdelsol on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 01:29:57 PM EST

Re: Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself (none / 0)

Hah -- not as hard as compiling it. Trust me. Also, not as hard as reading it before someone has pruned away the bills that never made it out of committee, the ones that merely instruct the mint to strike a coin commending X for X's service to our nation, etc.


by hilzoy on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 01:54:17 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself (none / 0)

Thanks Hilzoy. I read this over on your site. I'm not sure it will get the same viewing here unfortunately.


by illlaw1 on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 01:44:02 PM EST

Re: Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself (none / 0)

not to worry--I appreciate the effort that went into it.


by vivelosdiablosdelsol on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 02:14:23 PM EST

Re: Obama and Clinton: Compare For Yourself (none / 0)

Ya did you look at who has played a big role in making peace?

Hillary in Ireland

Did you look at who can stand up to China?

Hillary at the women's convention in China was the strongest voice against Chinese sexism.

When it come to hard ball real stakes Politics Hillary has been there done that and Obama has just talked talked talked...


I believe in Hillary
by sonofdonkeykong on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 03:24:50 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.