Cook: 12 GOP Senators Potentially Vulnerable, Just 6 Dems

The earliest Senate 2010 race rankings are now out from the Cook Political Report, and as I've said before, the map looks remarkably good for the Democrats.

According to Cook, 12 Republican Senate seats are potentially competitive, six of which are already in the competitive category -- and three of those are currently rated as "tossups." In comparison, just six Democratic seats are viewed as potentially competitive, none of which are already competitive.

The top targets for the Democrats, per Cook, are Mel Martinez of Florida, Jim Bunning of Kentucky (who might retire), and David Vitter of Louisiana, the seats of each of which are viewed as tossups. I might quibble with the latter, making it more like "leans Republican." Even though Vitter has a prostitution problem, Democrats haven't fared too well in statewide elections in Louisiana in recent years, with Barack Obama earning just 40 percent of the vote in the state and even two-term Democratic incumbent Senator Mary Landrieu getting only 52 percent of the vote.

After that, Cook puts the seats of Sam Brownback of Kansas (who might retire), Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, and Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania (who might retire) in the "leans Republican" category. I'm a bit skeptical about the Democrats' chances in Oklahoma, as the last two several Senate elections in the state haven't been great for the party, but otherwise the list seems sensible.

Within the potentially competitive "likely Republican" category Cook lists Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Kit Bond of Missouri, Judd Gregg of New Hampshire, Richard Burr of North Carolina, George Voinovich of Ohio and John Thune of South Dakota. I don't see Alaska or South Dakota coming together for the Democrats, but if they do, great.

A couple of wildcards to look out for that Cook currently rates as safe are Iowa, where Chuck Grassley may retire, and Georgia, which appears to be becoming more competitive and where Johnny Isakson is only in his first term.

Again, as I've noted before, the pickings for the Republicans are significantly thinner. Cook rates six seats as likely Democratic, or potentially but not yet competitive. These seats are those of Barbara Boxer in California, Ken Salazar in Colorado, Harry Reid in Nevada, Byron Dorgan in North Dakota, Patty Murray in Washington, and Russ Feingold in Wisconsin. I might keep an eye on Obama's seat in Illinois, which Cook calls safe, but otherwise the Democrats shouldn't have to play too much defense this coming cycle.

But, of course, before then it's important to finish off this cycle -- so contribute now to Jim Martin's effort in Georgia.



Display:


Depending on retirements (none / 0)

the number could be small or large.

Here's what I see:
FL, NC, KY, and LA will be competitive regardless.

PA- If Specter retires, Dems will pick it up.  If he doesn't retire, Specter will face primary challenge.

NH- Probably competitive regardless.  But Gregg retirement would give it to the Dems.

IA- Dems pick up if Grassley retires, not competitive otherwise.

KS- Competitive only if Brownback retires (likely) AND Sebelius runs.

OK- Competitive if Brad Henry runs.

SD- Competitive only if Thune runs for Gov. and Sandlin is the Dem candidate.

AZ- Competitive if McCain retires.  A pick up if Napolitano is the Dem nominee.

MO- Competitive if Robin Carnahan is the Dem nominee.  She'd be the favorite if Bond retires.

OH- Competitive if Voinovich retires, possibly competitive if he does not.

AL- Possibly competitive if Shelby retires and Ron Sparks runs.

GA- Possibly competitive if Isakson runs for Gov.


Corporatism and Islamism are the greatest threats to civilizations' future.
by ClintoniteNoLonger4McCain on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 08:51:04 PM EST

Re: Depending on retirements (none / 0)

Isakson has said he won't run.  


Follow the 2010 election cycle in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.
by TheUnknown285 on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 09:09:44 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Depending on retirements (none / 0)

For governor, I mean.


Follow the 2010 election cycle in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.
by TheUnknown285 on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 09:09:54 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Depending on retirements (2.00 / 1)

KS- Competitive only if Brownback retires (likely) AND Sebelius runs.

Brownback's already said he isn't running again.  Unfortunately, I think that's because he has unannounced plans to make a gubernatorial run.

I may have been wrong about the R field clearing for Jerry Moran (KS-1).  Apparently, Todd Tiahrt (KS-4) and others are looking into the seat as well.  If there's one thing the Rs could do to muck this up for themselves, it would be an extra-bloody primary battle.

The question, then, is whether the Governor will still be in Kansas to run for the Senate.  Since she's term limited, she might take a job in the administration.


The Kansas GOP under Kris Kobach
by Shocker Jim on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 11:42:01 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Depending on retirements (2.00 / 1)

Ages as of Nov. 2010:

Arlen Specter, 80
Jim Bunning, 79
Chuck Grassley, 77
Richard Shelby,76
George Voinovich,74
John McCain,74
Johnny Isakson,65
Mel Martinez, 64
Judd Gregg, 63
Tom Coburn, 62
Mike Crapo,59
Jim DeMint, 59
Richard Burr, 55
John Thune, 49

Vitter, I guess, can only be classified as juvenile. Ha.


by David Kowalski on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 02:21:40 AM EST
[ Parent ]

no one expects Grassley to retire (2.00 / 1)

Barring some major health problem, I see little chance that Grassley would retire.


Join the Iowa progressive community at Bleeding Heartland.
by desmoinesdem on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 09:29:08 PM EST

Re: no one expects Grassley to retire (none / 0)

I agree. Unfortunately, he's a formidable candidate as he has otten a lot of goodies for Iowa in the past.  His photo otoh makes him look damned old.  That neck's the key.  Maybe he should wear a lot of high neck sweaters to hide that look.


by David Kowalski on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 02:24:24 AM EST
[ Parent ]

CA is only competitive if Arnold runs nt (none / 0)


by mo on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 09:43:45 PM EST

Here is my list (none / 0)

Vulnerable GOP seats:

Ohio
Pennsylvania
Louisiana
Florida
Missouri
Arizona
New Hampshire
Kentucky

We need to go after them as aggressively as possible. I do not think we will lose seats in 2010 but we will play a lot of defense in 2012.


by RandyMI on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 09:54:43 PM EST

Just 6 Dems (2.00 / 1)

Arizona "safe" Republican?

I mean seriously?  McCain carried his home state by an unimpressive margin.  McCain currently trails the Democratic governor in a hypothetical race.  But it's "safe" for him?


The sharpest criticism often goes hand in hand with the deepest idealism and love of country. ~RFK
by Vox Populi on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:03:48 PM EST

Re: Just 6 Dems (none / 0)

Janet is more popular.


by RandyMI on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:06:23 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Just 6 Dems (2.00 / 1)

I think Arizona will be won.  I think McCain is likely to retire and even if Napolitano opts not to run, someone like Gabrielle Giffords would stand a good shot winning.


The sharpest criticism often goes hand in hand with the deepest idealism and love of country. ~RFK
by Vox Populi on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:15:00 PM EST
[ Parent ]

BUR Cook: 12 GOP Senators Potentially Vulnerable, (none / 0)

If Mike Easely or even Richard Moore decide to run, Burr is toast, especially if Obama engages himself on their behalf. With Easely it wouldn't even be a fair fight,  a 56-44 victory. Let's hope he jumps in.


by bear2000 on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:19:30 PM EST

We need Easley (none / 0)

that would make NC an easy pickup.  


by Kent on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:33:53 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: We need Easley (none / 0)

Forget it.  Easley has no more interest in politics.  The man to nominate is Roy Cooper. I bet he gets 57% against Burr.

Cook may be a "guru", but if he thinks Burr is likely Republican, he's nuts.  Burr is toast.  There is absolutely no way he's reelected.  He's way less well liked here than Liddy Dole, and top Democrats have been salivating to run against him.  They see him as easy pickings.  Cooper is our best candidate, but there are many others here that would mop the floor with  Burr.  Don't believe anyone who says  Burr has a chance - they're wrong.

Hagan was the best possible candidate to run against Dole, but there are plenty of top Democrats here who will easily take out Burr.


by LanceS on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 10:46:17 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: We need Easley (none / 0)

I have no idea how Charlie Cook can slot North Carolina as two-categories less favorable for Democrats than trying to evict an incumbent in post-Katrina Louisiana.


by Gary Kilbride on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 11:53:41 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Cook must think LA voters (none / 0)

will be tougher on their criminal senator than Alaska has been on Stephens.  Personally, I think Vitter is much safer than Burr, Voinovich, or Gregg.


Enough is enough!
by Bear83 on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 12:04:13 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Roy Cooper (none / 0)

You're right - didn't think of Cooper. He'd crush Burr and it'd be fun to watch, because Cooper is a take-no-prisoners type.


by bear2000 on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 06:15:14 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Burr should be gone (none / 0)

This is a revolving door seat.  It has traded back and forth between the parties every election since 1974 - Burr has done little to endear himself to NC voters:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Uni ted_States_Senators_from_North_Carolina

Robert B. Morgan, Democratic 1975-1981 lost to East in general election

John P. East, Republican 1981-1986 death

James T. Broyhill, Republican 1986 Appointed to remainder of term, lost general election, served until successor qualified

Terry Sanford, Democratic 1986-1993 lost to Faircloth in general election

Lauch Faircloth, Republican 1993-1999 lost to Edwards in general election

John Edwards, Democratic 1999-2005 retired; ran for President

Richard Burr, Republican 2005 -- incumbent


Enough is enough!
by Bear83 on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 11:48:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Blue Hampshire (2.00 / 1)

Given our recent successes here in New Hampshire and that the extraordinarly popular Governor John Lynch is likely to be the Democratic nominee for Senate, I'd say Gregg is more of a leans Republican than a likely Republican.


Ever heard of a Blue Moose Democrat?
by Nathan Empsall on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 11:11:14 PM EST

It is funny that the GOP has 19 seats up (2.00 / 1)

to defend - out of their total of 40 or so. Almost half their delegation will be on the ballot, vs. just over a quarter of the DEMs.

Advantage, Good Guys.


Enough is enough!
by Bear83 on Thu Nov 13, 2008 at 11:57:19 PM EST

Re: Cook: 12 GOP Senators Potentially Vulnerable, (2.00 / 1)

I appreciate your enthusiasm about the improved look in Georgia, but Johnny Isakson is prob the single most popular Republican in the state. I know many Democrats in Georgia who will vote for him.


by brimur42 on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 12:00:10 AM EST

Re: Cook: 12 GOP Senators Potentially Vulnerable, (2.00 / 1)

I'd move Missouri, North Carolina, and New Hampshire into Leans Republican. And possibly Ohio.


by brimur42 on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 12:02:57 AM EST

Re: Cook: 12 GOP Senators Potentially Vulnerable, (2.00 / 1)

Burr is toast.  If they couldn't save Dole from a state senator, they won't keep Burr.  Martinez is in serious trouble too.  Bunning is toast as long as Rep. Chandler runs, which everyone expects him to do.

After those three, it gets a little tricker.  I'm not as optimistic as Cook about Louisiana, everyone seems to have forgotten about Diaper Vitter's problems and we're losing strength there rapidly.  Landrieu's 52% was NOT encouraging.  Oklahoma is a lost cause, we ran the most clean-cut, moderate, well-liked possible candidate in 2004 and he lost by ten points to a lunatic.

The rest seriously depend on retirements and/or star candidate recruitment.  Inouye, Dorgan, and Boxer may be vulnerable depending if the GOP governors run against them (and if they retire), otherwise safe.  Specter, Bond, Gregg, Voinovich, Grassley, Murkowski, and Thune as well could be in danger if things break our way.

Salazar is 100% safe though.  Republicans love him.  And who exactly do they have lined up to challenge Reid, Murray, or Feingold?


by Skaje on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 07:35:01 AM EST

states up ranked by percent for Obama (none / 0)

Dems on defense
Hawaii-71.9
Vermont-67.0
New York-62.2
Delaware-61.9
Illinois-61.8
Maryland-61.7
California-60.8
Connecticut-60.7
Washington-57.5
Oregon-56.7
Wisconsin-56.3
Nevada-55.1
Colorado-53.5
Indiana-49.9
North Dakota-44.7
Arkansas-39.3

GOP on defense
Iowa-53.8
Florida-51.0
Georgia-47.0
Arizona-45.0
Kansas-41.4
Kentucky 41.2
Louisiana-39.9
Alabama-38.8
Alaska-37.5
Idaho-36.1

gotta finish later


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 11:06:31 AM EST

Re: states up ranked by percent for Obama (none / 0)

GOP on defense
Pennsylvania-54.6
New Hampshire-54.1
Iowa-53.8
Ohio-51.1
Florida-51.0
North Carolina-49.7
Missouri-49.3
Georgia-47.0
Arizona-45.0
South Carolina-44.9
South Dakota-44.8
Kansas-41.4
Kentucky 41.2
Louisiana-39.9
Alabama-38.8
Alaska-37.5
Idaho-36.1
Oklahoma-34.4
Utah-34.2
Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 11:52:07 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Again with NC as "Solid Republican"? (2.00 / 1)

Has the nation as a whole learned nothing about North Carolina from this last election. Let me give it to you pictorially. This is how Kay Hagan beat Elizabeth Dole:
Kay Hagan for Senate
But, THIS, is how our most popular Democrat and hopefully our candidate against Dick burr won law week:
Attorney General Roy Cooper
Roy Cooper is our most popular Democrat in North Carolina, possibly the most popular in decades. He is viewed as a 'Law and Order" Democrat, tough on crime. He's young, he's photogenic, he's popular.

I don't know if he is particularly progressive, but neither was/is Kay Hagan and yet everyone is pretty happy that she got elected and sent Liddy Dole home. So, the question you have to ask yourself is this, are you willing to send another Bob Casey, Jr. Democrat to the Senate if it means sending a Republican home?

Either way, NC went for Obama, we went from 7R-6D Congressional delegation in 2004 to 8D-5R in 2008, we sent Liddy Dole back to Kansas, and we elected our first female Governor.

Hello, anyone?


BlueNC - Progressive NC Politics
by Robert P on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 11:15:05 AM EST

Hopefully Salazar is vulnerable in a primary (none / 0)

DINO, DINO, DINO


by magster on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 11:30:40 AM EST

Re: Hopefully Salazar is vulnerable in a primary (none / 0)

DINO Dems: Lieberman,Blanche Lincoln, Nelson of NEB., and Salazar.


by olawakandi on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 12:55:12 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Cook: 12 GOP Senators (none / 0)

If Dan Seals or Jesse Jackson Jr. take the seat or another minority candidate like Gary Chico, the minority base latinos and hispanics will be energized, I don't think Tammy Duckworth will energize the minority vote to the extent as those two, but Rod Blagojevich is connected to the Daley machine are those minorities really part of the Daley machine? Quite frankly no, but I hope Rod has his own mind.


by olawakandi on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 12:26:43 PM EST

Patty Murray? (none / 0)

Who is Cook trying to fool? She's pretty much Senator for life in Washington at this point.

She's VERY popular here (at least among dems, independents, and vets), she's a good campaigner as well. Nethercutt was the Republican's best chance to defeat her in a Republican year and he went down in flames.

The other problem is who the heck is the GOP going to get to run against her?

My take on the GOP bench here:

Dino Rossi - has said he's not planning on running for elected office again any time soon, also has repeatedly said he isn't interested in serving in DC. He may change his mind, but given his performance against the much less popular Gregiore who runs tepid campaigns I don't see him having much of a chance against Murray.

Rob McKenna - Probably the most popular republican in the state. Most think he's waiting his turn for a run at the Governor's mansion. He's smart enough to not attempt a quixotic run against a popular Senator.

Dave Reichart - Probably the best known Congressional Republican in the state. However he has a weak record in Congress and has had 3 close elections in his district. While better known he would be a weaker candidate than Nethercutt was in 2004.

Cathy McMorris Rogers - From what little I know of her, she seems quite charming. However she's not been in Congress long. She also suffers from not being well known in the Western side of the state where most of the voters are. Seems like she might be a bit too socially conservative to do well in the Seattle suburbs.

Anyone else - would likely not be seen as a credible candidate against Murray. The biggest danger would be a business type who could self-fund.


by ces on Fri Nov 14, 2008 at 05:42:07 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.