Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney Win In Michigan

Just as the daily tracking polls in New Hampshire leading up to Tuesday's primary provided some clues to the fading of Obama's post-Iowa bounce and a resurgent Clinton on Monday, a similar dynamic appears to be at play in Michigan among the Republicans. In the wake of McCain's New Hampshire win, Mitchell Interactive released a poll that found McCain with a 6 point lead over Romney. Since then, Mitchell has released 2 daily tracking polls, both of which confirm that Romney has the momentum leading into tomorrow's primary.

Candidate1/10, 1/12-131/9-10, 1/121/9-10
Romney292117
McCain272223
Huckabee121211

As you can see from the first two polls, adding January 12th to the polling time range netted Romney 5 points. By the time Jan. 9th (the day after McCain's win) was dropped from the rolling average and repaced by the 13th, Romney was up by 2%, an 8 point swing in a matter of 5 days. While this change could be attributed to the difference between weekday and weekend polling (the 12th is a Saturday,) Steve Mitchell of Mitchell Interactive believes the movement is real, as he explains:

"As the undecided voters make up their minds, more are turning to Mitt Romney than to John McCain. We have also seen the participation among Republicans increase from 62% last night to 75% at the end of phoning tonight. That means that 75% of the voters taking part in the GOP Primary identify themselves as Republicans."

This final point is key. As Race42008 points out, there's a fairly consistent correlation between the % of Republicans pollsters find intend to take part in tomorrow's primary and how Romney and McCain perform.

Zogby: McCain +3 (50% Republican voters)
Rasmussen: Romney +1 (70% Republican voters)
Mitchell: Romney +2 (75% Republican voters)
Detroit Freep: Romney +5 (83% Republican voters)
MSNBC/Mason-Dixon: Romney +8 (70% Republican voters)

McCain's 2000 win was propelled in part by Democrats and Independents crossing over and voting in large numbers in the Republican primary (Republicans made up just 48% of the vote that year.) This was a result of a concerted effort to deliver McCain a win to embarrass then-Governor Engler who was supporting Bush as well as the fact that the Democratic primary was uncontested. Neither is technically the case this year. Race42008 predicts the % of Republicans that participate in tomorrow's GOP primary is likely to be higher than 63%, which was the percentage that turned out in 1996 when there was an uncontested Democratic primary but no cross-over effort. If there's any mobilization effort among Democrats this year, it's to turn out in the Dem primary for 'Uncommitted' against Hillary Clinton.

Another factor in the decreased turnout for John McCain on the part of Independents and Democrats this year has got to be his embrace of Bush's war policy and his overall attempt to run more as a conservative than as the maverick he became known as in 2000. Remember, as well as McCain did among Independents in New Hampshire, he beat Romney among registered Republicans by a small margin, a group that he lost to Bush in 2000. But even when McCain has tried to rekindle his straight talk reputation on the stump in Michigan these past few days, it's been fairly disastrous.

Paul Krugman recalls a recent moment of brutal honesty:

Take, for example, John McCain's admission that economics isn't his thing. "The issue of economics is not something I've understood as well as I should," he says. "I've got Greenspan's book."

And then there was this unfortunate recent episode, from The Boston Globe:

Romney talked about reviving the auto industry, but McCain said some Michigan industries cannot be resurrected.

"I've got to give you some straight talk: Some of the jobs that have left the state of Michigan are not coming back," he said. "They are not. And I am sorry to tell you that."

McCain seems to have realized that in 2008 Michigan, "straight talk" on the economy is probably not a winning strategy.

"We can restore Detroit's supremacy in the automotive world," McCain said at the Andiamo Celebrity Showroom. "I'm optimistic."

For McCain, this may prove to be too little damage control too late. The net result of the Republican candidates' intense focus on the economy, the auto industry in particular, is that John McCain is suddenly behind on the one count he always thought he had sewn up: experience.

"Voters since the New Hampshire Primary have all talked about change. However, when asked which is more important to voters in their presidential choice, `experience' or `being an agent of change,' almost seven in ten (69%) say experience while 20% say being an agent of change. Romney leads by 2% with those saying experience and he leads by more than 2:1 among those who say being an agent of change is most important in their presidential choice," Mitchell concluded.

Update [2008-1-14 20:32:12 by Todd Beeton]:Oh yeah, and yet another factor that may reduce the number of Indies and Dems voting in the GOP primary tomorrow: the weather forecast calls for snow throughout the state.



Display:


The GOP race is painful to watch (none / 0)

Everytime I see McCain on TV, I literally expect him to shrivel up like the Nazi character on Indiana Jones III when he picks the wrong chalice.


by highgrade on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 07:54:30 PM EST

Re: The GOP race is painful to watch (none / 0)

You know, someone I know here in NH said that exact same thing.


Ever heard of a Blue Moose Democrat?
by Nathan Empsall on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:21:55 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: The GOP race is painful to watch (none / 0)

You sure tha wasn't Raiders of the Lost Ark? (or is Raiders Indiana Jones III now?).


by spirowasright on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:34:36 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Is this (none / 0)

A Dkos bounce for romney?   ;)


Washington Woman

Progressive Blue

by kevin22262 on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 08:02:15 PM EST

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney Win In Mich (2.00 / 1)

I know Progressives want Romney to be nominated, but be careful what you wish for.


Restore America's Strength.
by RJEvans on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 08:05:07 PM EST

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney Win In Mich (none / 0)

Amen to that.  But if McCain wins here it's pretty much a done deal.  If Romney wins the whole thing is still up in the air.  I think that's better overall for the Dems.


by the mollusk on Tue Jan 15, 2008 at 10:41:50 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney (none / 0)

One can only hope that Obama's brand of ugly and divisive Jesse Jackson brand of politics is defeated at the polls. I used to be very anti-Hillary, but the Obama folks' insistence on running like it's 1984 have truly disappointed me and convinced me that an ugly paranoid racial campaign attacking anything real or imagined is going to cost us the White House big time--and should McCain be nominated, even more so. So yeah, let's hope for a Romney victory because if Obama is the nominee it is our only chance.


by need some wood on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 08:22:14 PM EST

Your concern troll view has been duly noted (2.00 / 1)


by lestatdelc on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 08:49:28 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Your concern troll view has been duly noted (none / 0)

get a new shtick. Or you need orders from central cult command?


by need some wood on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:04:55 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney (none / 0)

When exactly did Obama himself say anything divisive?


Ever heard of a Blue Moose Democrat?
by Nathan Empsall on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:23:35 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney (none / 0)

I meant to say his campaign as a whole and many of his fanatical supporters who are all to eager to play the race card where no controversy exists and hell bent on using it to exploit voters---the problem is that it is a LOSING strategy for the general and only divides people and is dividing the Democratic Party.

I am not excusing some of the comments made by Clinton's surrogates...I think some were reprehensible, but they were not racial in any sense. Injecting race into it is something his campaign has been doing and it is the WORST possible thing for a black presidential candidate to do unless they want to get clobbered.


by need some wood on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:57:24 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Tracking Poll Pointing To A Romney Win In Mich (none / 0)

My parents and grandparents voted absentee earlier today.  Snow is not an unknown phenomenon in Michigan, as it turns out.


"Another problem we have...is that in election years we behave somewhat as primitive peoples do at the time of the full moon." --Harry Truman
by Steve M on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 09:19:49 PM EST

Waiting for Zogby (none / 0)

At 11pm Pacific (2am eastern) Zogby's final Michigan poll will be out.

IMO, this all comes down to How many Democrats cross over, and how many independents will turn out in the snow.  Another factor is that the polls
are open until 9pm Eastern, so we'll have to see how that plays out.

Go Mitt!


by mikelow1885 on Mon Jan 14, 2008 at 10:03:28 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.