Will the HRC-Logo debate be a white queer public soliloquy?

(Originally posted on The Bilerico Project by the Reverend Irene Monroe. She referring to the "gay debate" - a Democratic presidential forum set up by the largest LGBT advocacy group in America, the HRC, which will air tomorrow night on Logo.)

There has been a lot of talk with enthusiasm and optimism concerning the upcoming historic televised HRC-Logo Forum on issues important to America's lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer voters. With a star-studded cast of 2008 Democratic presidential hopefuls like  frontrunning senators Hillary Clinton, and Barack Obama to the low-polling but queer-friendly former U.S. Senator Mike Gravel bringing up the rear, the excitement is palpable in many queer communities across the country.

There is, however, at least one LGBTQ community nationwide that knows very little about the HRC-Logo debate - the LGBTQ community of African descent.

"Why would I know about this debate?," LaShaun Williams of New Orleans told me. "Before Katrina the black and white gay communities was separated. Now after Katrina even moreso because only those who have money either stayed during the city's renovation or had money to return back. Our community is smaller and more invisible than ever and the gay paper down here doesn't now and never have circulated where black folks live."

But the complaints that the news about the HRC-Logo debate not reaching black queer communities via newspapers is not only endemic to New Orleans' queer community where many can understand its present-day fragmentation, but the news did not circulate well in big bustling cities with large and active LGBTQ communities like my hometown of Boston.

"I have yet to see Baywindows or even your paper Rev. [In Newsweekly] make an appearance here in Mattapan, [a predominately black enclave of Boston]." Rhonda MacLean stated.

While circulation of queer papers to black enclaves is a problem, so too is turning onto to the LOGO channel for many LGBTQ people of African descent to seek out entertainment or to find out what's happening in their communities. Logo is the nation's leading television and broadband network for LGBTQ people with more than 1,000 hours of content and approximately 27 million viewers across the country, yet many LGBTQ people of color feel excluded by its programming. Logo describes itself as providing "LGBT audiences with a place where they can see themselves and be themselves through a mix of original and acquired entertainment  programming that is authentic, smart and inclusive."

"Girl, it wasn't until Noah's Arc that I had a reason to watch anything on that channel," Anthony Reed of D.C. stated. "I see ourselves in too many coon acts and clown performances to really see a commitment by the channel."

But those in this community who do know of the debate have told me they were "underwhelmed" about the entire brouhaha.

"How is this debate  going to speak to the specific interests of same gender loving people when HRC doesn't, the Logo channel doesn't, and the papers never have," Joanne Strayhorn of Newark, New Jersey commented.

And much of the overwhelming disinterest in LGBTQ communities of African descent about this upcoming historic debate is the belief that issues pertinent to them will once again be left out of not only the public discourse but also  left out  of the overall interest of politicians wooing this  community as an important and vital voter bloc to have. The queer community is a decisive electoral force that politicians have learned over  the years, for their own campaign survival, that they must at least wink at.

But their winks have never cast eyes on this nation's black same gender loving communities.  And the issues concerning white queer communities are indeed vastly different from the black community.

"We got an entire community dying of AIDS and I know the first question that's going to come out of somebody's mouth will be that of gay marriage" Rita Johnson of Detroit told me.

Social research shows that African-American same-gender households have everything to gain in the struggle for marriage equality and more to lose when states pass amendments banning marriage equality and other forms of partner recognition. For example, in November 2005, Equality Maryland and the National Black Justice Coalition published "Jumping the Broom: a Black Perspective on Same-Gender Marriage." And the statistics revealed the following: Forty-five percent of black same-sex couples reported stable relationships of five years or longer. And 20 percent of black men and 24 percent of black women in same-sex households are denied health care benefits for their partners by the government.

While there is still overwhelming evidence that suggests marriage would be beneficial for same gender loving couples, many in the black queer community still argue that the community is not tied in a knot about same-sex marriage, as queer media present, many are just simply not kissing up to the issue, since the issue appears and presents itself as a white queer moral imperative and not the AIDS crisis in the black community.

There is another crisis in the black gay community - homelessness among its lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer youth. When 42 percent of the country's homeless youth identifies as LGBTQ, and approximately 90 percent within this group comprise of African American and Latino youth from urban enclaves like New York City, Boston, and Los Angeles,  many black LGBTQ voters argue that this issue is neither simply a black issue that the African American community should address nor a queer issue the LGBTQ community should address, but rather a problem this nation should address since it has reached epidemic proportions.

With many LGBTQ voters of African descent experiencing the downside of diversity by not being  fully included in the both African American and gay communities the HRC-Logo debate is viewed as a white queer public soliloquy giving the illusion of inclusion.

For more queer political and cultural commentary, visit The Bilerico Project.



Display:


Re: Will the HRC-Logo debate be a white queer publ (none / 0)

REP. TAMMY BALDWIN ENDORSES HILLARY, WILL CO-CHAIR LGBT STEERING COMMITTEE

Wisconsin Congresswoman Tammy Baldwin last week was named a Co-Chair of Hillary's Wisconsin campaign and a member of the campaign's Health Care Policy Task Force. Baldwin will also co-chair the campaign's LGBT steering committee.

   "Senator Clinton is supremely prepared and the candidate best able to ensure health care for all, reaffirm our commitment to the Constitution and rule of law, and re-establish our position of leadership in the world. She will be firm in protecting our national security and fair in addressing the aspirations and needs of all Americans. Hillary Clinton has been my friend and ally in the battle for health care for many years and I look forward to working with her to achieve our common goals when she becomes our next President," Baldwin said.

Baldwin was elected to the House of Representatives in 1998, becoming the first woman to represent Wisconsin in Congress. She is a forceful advocate for creating a universal healthcare system for all Americans, and has worked to expand stem cell research and prescription drug benefits for seniors. Because of her expertise, the campaign has asked Baldwin to serve on its Health Care Policy Task Force.


by DoIT on Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 08:31:06 PM EST

Re: Will the HRC-Logo debate be a white queer publ (none / 0)

You are spamming this diary.


by bruh21 on Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 11:33:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Good diary. ITA (none / 0)

Remember the Latin GLBTQ, too.  It's a similar situation, though admittedly not as pronounced as the black-white divide.


McCain is defining Obama, and Obama is neither defining himself, nor McCain. This is awful.
by jgarcia on Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 11:01:14 PM EST

Re: Will the HRC-Logo debate (none / 0)

Thanks for the post. The issues of race in the gay community didn't start with this debate. It's a complicated one too. Being a doublt minority its often hard to know quite where you fit.


by bruh21 on Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 11:34:04 PM EST

Re: Will the HRC- (none / 0)

They do have a point- I used to live in New Orleans and they had separate gay bars for blacks and whites- the black one was nowhere even near the white one.  But that's also the South- you certainly can't say the same thing about the Los Angeles black and white gay communities.  They are very integrated and I suspect many cities are like that- heading to the South, though, there is still that problem although I have not been down there in over ten years so it might be different now.


by reasonwarrior on Thu Aug 09, 2007 at 11:08:54 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.