NRSC Recruiting and Democratic Senate Incumbents

No, it's not Sunday.  And this isn't the Senate 2008 Guru's Week in the Senate Races.  It's been over nine months since Election Day 2006; and it's less than fifteen months until Election Day 2008.  In other words, the 2008 election cycle is more than one-third over already.  With all of the discussion about vulnerable Republican-held Senate seats taking place, I thought it might be useful to take a look at how the races are shaping up for the twelve Democratic-held Senate seats in 2008.  Soak it in:

StateIncumbentGOP's Ostensible 1st Choice1st Choice Running?Current GOP Opponent(s)Possible GOP Opponent(s)Announced Not Running or Expressed No Interest
ARMark PryorFormer Gov. Mike HuckabeNoNone?Huckabee
DEJoe BidenRep. Mike CastleNoNone?Castle
ILRichard DurbinYour guess is as good as mine.NoSteve SauerbergWho knows? A return from Alan Keyes?Steve Greenberg
IATom HarkinRep. Tom LathamNot Yet (Rumored Possibility)Steve Rathje,
Troy Cook,
Bob McDowell
Latham, Rep. Steve King-
LAMary LandrieuRep. Bobby JindalNoNone*Sec. of State Jay Dardenne,
Treasurer John N. Kennedy,
'02 Sen. candidate Suzanne Haik Terrell
'96 Sen. candidate Woody Jenkins
Rep. Richard Baker,
Rep. Jim McCrery,
Rep. Charles Boustany;
Jindal running for Governor
MAJohn KerryYour guess is as good as mine.NoJeffrey BeattieState Senator Scott BrownFormer Govs. Mitt Romney, Bill Weld, and Paul Cellucci,
Former Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey, Former Bush Chief of Staff Andy Card,
Businessman Charles Baker, Red Sox pitcher Curt Schilling
MICarl LevinRep. Candice MillerNoNoneSecretary of State Terri Lynn Land,
2002 Candidate Rocky Raczkowski
Miller, Rep. Mike Rogers
MTMax BaucusRep. Denny Rehberg NoState Rep. Mike Lange?Rehberg
NJFrank LautenbergFormer Gov. Christie Whitman,
U.S. Attorney Chris Christie
No, NoBusinesswoman Anne Evans EstabrookState Assemblyman Joe Pennacchio,
State Assemblyman Jon Bramnick
Whitman, Christie,
Tom Kean Sr. & Jr.,
Assemblyman Mike Doherty
RIJack ReedFormer Sen. Lincoln ChafeeNoNoneJon ScottChafee, '06 Sen. candidate Steve Laffey, Gov. Don Carcieri
SDTim Johnson*Gov. Mike RoundsNoState Rep. Joel Dykstra,
Businessman Sam Kephart
?Rounds
WVJay RockefellerRep. Shelley Moore CapitoNoNoneSecretary of State Betty Ireland,
Businessman John Raese
Capito

So what do we see here?

First and foremost, we see that (unless Tom Latham challenges Tom Harkin or Bobby Jindal unexpectedly loses the LA-Gov race and opts for a Senate bid) Republicans don't have a single top choice challenging a Democratic incumbent.  Keep in mind, this is not a comparison to Democrats, who have had ups and downs with recruiting (though, with 22 Republican-held seats up compared with only 12 Democratic seats up, that is to be expected).  Simply put, I don't know how much time NRSC Chair John Ensign spends recruiting, but if it's more than zero, it may be wasted time.  Certainly, there is still plenty of time for candidates to enter a Senate race, as Senators Claire McCaskill, Sherrod Brown, and Jim Webb will tell you (all officially entered their races after August 2005), but, after this point in the 2006, only one single Republican entered a Senate race: Michigan loser Mike Bouchard.  If 2006 is at all indicative, the NRSC should be just about done recruiting by now, not just starting.

You'll also note two asterisks, in Louisiana and South Dakota.  In Louisiana, statewide elections occur later this year.  While several Republican Congressmen have announced that they will be opting against a 2008 Senate challenge to Mary Landrieu, it is not unreasonable that other potential candidates would wait until after the 2007 state election before making any decisions, particularly in the case of statewide officeholders Secretary of State Jay Dardenne and currently-Democratic Treasurer John N. Kennedy.  In South Dakota, Senator Tim Johnson is, of course, still recuperating from illness.  If he feels able to run for re-election, it is reasonable to assume that he will, and that Gov. Mike Rounds is unlikely to challenge him.  However, if Johnson opts against a re-election bid, that changes the entire dynamic, which could lead to a top-tier battle between Gov. Rounds and possibly Congresswoman Stephanie Herseth.

We also see a lot of previously unheard-of names.  Jeffrey Beattie in Massachusetts and Jon Scott in Rhode Island are both Congressional race losers, I suppose looking for a promotion to losing Senate races.  The announced challengers in Illinois and Iowa are all unknown political entities, charitably considered third-tier opponents.  As it currently stands, Montana, New Jersey, and South Dakota feature a smattering of second- and third-tier opposition.  Assuming both that Joe Biden drops his Presidential bid and runs for re-election and that Iowa's Republican Congressional delegation all opt to take a pass on a 2008 Senate bid, it is not unreasonable to expect (barring out-of-the blue surprises) that incumbent Democratic Senators will face no more than token opposition in Arkansas, Delaware, Illinois, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Rhode Island, and West Virginia.  (At the same time, it wouldn't be wildly shocking if: Tom Latham did enter the race in Iowa; Secretary of State Terri Lynn Land did enter the race in Michigan; Joe Biden did retire from the Senate; and the AR-GOP did find somebody to offer Mark Pryor at least minimal opposition.)

Further, assuming that Senator Tim Johnson is up for a re-election campaign, it is not unreasonable to expect that incumbent Democratic Senators will face no more than second-tier opposition (and thus be strong favorites) in Montana, New Jersey, and South Dakota.  Now, I recognize that I'm suggesting that, given a few reasonable caveats, eleven of twelve Democratic Senate seats are fairly to very safe (though it is also, in part, due to the hurting Democrats took in the Senate in 2002, losing close races in Colorado, Georgia, Minnesota, New Hampshire, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee, which in turn thinned out Democratic vulnerabilities and created pick-up opportunities for 2008).  That is pretty close to a "best case scenario."  But it is also a fairly reasonable scenario.  The catch is that Republicans, wanting to avoid a repeat of 2006 when they failed to turn a single Democratic-held Senate seat (or House seat or Governor's office) Republican, may pour relatively large sums of money into Louisiana once they have a candidate.  With the DSCC trouncing the NRSC in fundraising, Democrats can counteract that, but it could be very expensive.

What do you think?

For daily news and updates on the U.S. Senate races around the country in 2008, check out Senate 2008 Guru: Following the Races.



Display:


mark kirk in illinois... (none / 0)

was the gop's first choice.  he said no in january or february...


"Anyone who voted for me or caucused for me has so much more in common with Senator Obama than Senator McCain." -- Hillary Clinton
by bored now on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 04:56:41 PM EST

Let's make sure Kirk loses his House race too (none / 0)

http://www.dansealsforcongress.com/contr ibute.php

And for those who can make it out here on the 26th:

Dan Seals for Congress Petition Drive Kick-Off

Please join us for our Petition Drive Kick-Off on Sunday, August 26th at 1:30 p.m. at the Ryerson Woods 21850 N. Riverwoods Road, in Riverwoods.  Dan and our invited guests will rev up the crowd and you'll have an opportunity to pick up petitions to get Dan's name on the ballot, learn about opportunities to volunteer, and meet other supporters.  It's a great opportunity to invite your friends and neighbors who have yet to meet Dan. We'll hold the event inside the Brushwood Residence if it rains.  We have rented the facility for the afternoon and the Lake County Forest Preserve does not endorse any candidate for office.

Ryerson Woods is located near Deerfield in southeastern Lake County.  Its entrance is on Riverwoods Road, one and one-half miles south of Half Day Road (Route 22) and two miles north of Deerfield Road, just west of the I-94 Tollway. The event is free. RSVP to info@dansealsforcongress.com


"We are building a political movement - not one that wields the power of lobbyists and corporate interests, but the power of millions... who seek change." -Dean
by Jim in Chicago on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 06:04:01 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NRSC Recruiting and Democratic Senate Incumben (none / 0)

This is a great post. Unfortunately my browser (FF) has trouble displaying these charts. Am I the only one?


by thesleepthief on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 05:20:27 PM EST

Re: NRSC Recruiting and Democratic Senate Incumben (none / 0)

Chart is fine for me. This looks like a terrific opportunity to not lose a single Senate seat in '08. I imagine their base of hardcore partisans are not looking at a very pretty landscape right now.


by Jerome Armstrong on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 05:25:11 PM EST

Senator Lautenberg (none / 0)

Given the Senator's age, we ought to consider now who should run in his place if his health takes a sudden turn for the worse.


by palamedes on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 05:26:06 PM EST

Re: Senator Lautenberg (none / 0)

Frank Pallone or Rush Holt would be top choices.


by johnny longtorso on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 06:50:47 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Senator Lautenberg (none / 0)

OK - I know nothing about either them though, being on the west coast.  Details, please?


by palamedes on Fri Aug 17, 2007 at 12:54:19 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NRSC Recruiting and Democratic Senate Incumben (none / 0)

Terri Lynn Land is not going to give up her Secretary of State position for a no-hope run against Senator Levin in Michigan. He'd have to have a George Allen-style meltdown before any top tier candidates would consider running.

In the meantime.. maybe the return of Rocky! Also rumored at one point was MI GOP co-chair (and wife of former Senator) Jane Abraham. And another rumor was of Michelle Engler (wife of former Governor). But there hasn't been any talk recently of anybody.


by lpackard on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 05:32:35 PM EST

Louisiana (3.00 / 1)

I wouldn't protect Landrieu at the expense of 4 or 5 potential/likely pickups. She's not exactly the most progressive Senator, and the changed demographics of the state (thaks to Katrina) makes holding the seat especially difficult if the Republicans present and fully fund a strong challenger.

In "Being Right Is Not Enough" Paul Waldman argues that we should consign the Republicans to being the Party of the right-wing deep South and run against them as such rather than expend inordinate resources trying to hold those seats....


"We are building a political movement - not one that wields the power of lobbyists and corporate interests, but the power of millions... who seek change." -Dean
by Jim in Chicago on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 05:59:42 PM EST

Tom Latham (none / 0)

I would guess that he is not going to run, since he cannot raise the money needed and is not that popular here.  Also, his district includes some of the fastest growing suburbs of Waukee, West Des Moines, and Indianola.  This area (particularly Dallas county) has been bluing very fast over the past 4 years, because of the influence of 4000 Wells Fargo jobs from San Fransisco.  I would think he would opt to try and keep his seat, which is already going to be hard.

I think the people to challenge Harkin would rather challenge the two freshman representatives.  I could see someone from the State House or Senate run against him. Or maybe someone with more visibility, but all those people endorsed project DESTINY, which was a huge failure (because it was a tax giveaway not for improving culture).


http://ibrokemyrightwing.blogspot.com
by fakes seizures on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 07:04:32 PM EST

Re: NRSC Recruiting and Democratic Senate (none / 0)

Seems about right.  I think Johnson and Landrieu are the only genuine potential D losses.


by killjoy on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 07:04:36 PM EST

A few missing (none / 0)

Arkansas: '06 Lt. Gov. candidate Chuck Banks, Delta Trust & Banking CEO J. French Hill.

Iowa: Terry Branstad (unlikely to run), Jim Nussle

Massachusetts: Patrick Guerriero

Montana: Former State Sen. Majority Leader Bob Keenan is considering a bid. Keenan gave a late primary challenge to Conrad Burns in 2006, and in only a month and no fundraising, managed to win a fifth of the vote against a four-term incumbent. Former Governor Marc Racicot hasn't ruled out a bid, but he's unlikely.

South Dakota: Where did you have Rounds ruling out a bid? He's only said he has no plans, which is what any sitting Governor would say about a sick Senator. Anyways, other candidates include former LG Steve Kirby, Public Utilities Commish Dusty Johnson, former State Sen. Majority Leader Barb Everist, and attorney Jim Steward.

WV: '06 Senate candidate Hiram Lewis, State Sen. Mike Hall.


by Unabridged on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 07:56:44 PM EST

Nussle is out (none / 0)

He got a job with OMB, which I think he will try and keep, that is if he is confirmed by the senate.


http://ibrokemyrightwing.blogspot.com
by fakes seizures on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 08:07:02 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Nussle is out (none / 0)

Thanks for the update.


by Unabridged on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 08:09:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

WV SS Ireland is OUT! (none / 0)

She announced a couple of months back, some family members health issues, she may not even continue as WV SS for the same reasons!


by politics64 on Wed Aug 15, 2007 at 08:18:35 PM EST

WV situation (none / 0)

Absolutely right. The situation in WV is even more dire for Republicans. Ireland has announced that she's sitting out the '08 election altogether. She's not running for re-election, she's not running for Senate and she's not even running for the State Senate seat that the state GOP had hoped she'd fill.

FWIW. She never actually said there were family member health issues... she mentioned her parents are in their 90's. For all we know they are quite healthy.

Raese did a bunch of polling for his Metronews service and found out that, well... basically... no one likes him. He's not going to waste millions of his own money running again.

Rockefeller is still quite well liked in the state. Also, he's doing all the right things (make more in-state appearences, taking nothing for granted) to make sure he wins.


by WVaBlue on Thu Aug 16, 2007 at 05:10:00 AM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.