Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services for Bloggers

This week, there's been a raging conversation on kid oakland's Blogs United group about what can be done to support progressive bloggers.  The conversation was begun when I posted a quick email about Mike Lux's post about connecting bloggers and donors on OpenLeft; I think the conversation snowballed from there, partly because of Blogpac's infrastructure contest, and partly because of the excitement around YearlyKos.

In any case, this weekend I'd like to bring this conversation to a wider forum, and explore it in a bit more detail.  Over the course of three posts, I'll discuss the kinds of things that can be done to support the blogosphere.  This post will discuss the kinds of services and benefits that can be provided to progressive bloggers; the next post will discuss the services which bloggers can provide to third parties, in order to make money; and the last post will discuss the various types of organizational structures which can be used to deliver benefits and/or help bloggers sell their services.

Along the way, I'd certainly appreciate your thoughts; and if there are any bloggers in the house, I'd like to hear how realistic all of this is, and what can be done to make it happen.

Without further ado, I bring you Part 1: Services for Bloggers

The Costs of Blogging
Writing a blog, on the face of things, is not very difficult.  You fire up your web browser, log in, click "Write a new post", type an engaging and ground-breaking missive, click submit, and voila!  Reader appreciation in spades.

In fact, as any blogger who aspires even to a modest-sized readership knows, life is considerably more complicated.  To begin with, there are the technical choices (and associated costs) of which blogging platform to choose, and where and how to install it.  Then there are the strategic choices of audience targeting, and where and how to promote your blog (and the costs of promotion).  Furthermore, there are ongoing editorial choices - what to write about, how often, how to cover the topic, and on and on.

Added to these costs are hidden costs, which grow or shrink depending on the blogger's personal circumstances and chosen topic area.  If you don't already own a computer and have Internet access, you need to make some fairly heavy equipment purchases, and pay high Internet subscription costs.  If you tend to write about obscure topics, you may need access to Lexis/Nexis or a similar information service.  If you play a media watchdog role, you're probably buying a fair number of newspaper or magazine subscriptions, and maybe purchasing a bunch of books.  If you liveblog important political events, you're probably paying a cable subscription, travel costs, and/or conference registrations.  If you are blogging full-time, or your blogging precludes you from taking a job with benefits, then you're paying your own health insurance, and not receiving benefits like contributions to a pension or 401(k) fund.

Finally, there is the most important variable: time.  There's time you donate to your own blog and (if you're managing a group blog) the time of your associates, which may or may not be donated.  Writing time is the highest cost of writing a blog, and it frequently goes unreimbursed.

Blogger and Blogosphere Support
The easiest way to provide services for bloggers is to help bloggers pay for some or all of these costs, through direct reimbursement, bulk-purchase discounts, or some other avenue.

To give you an idea of how this would work, a very simple blogger support organization could work as follows: bloggers sign up for membership in the organization, and pay a small yearly membership fee.  The organization, in turn, purchases a lot of magazine subscriptions, and lets members choose to receive a fixed number of subscriptions.  The organization's main role is to be a bulk purchaser, which reduces per-subscription costs for bloggers.  A similar model could be used to purchase health insurance, Internet hosting provider services, and so on.  The model could be tweaked in various other ways: for example, with sufficient support from big donors, benefits could be provided to bloggers for free, if bloggers meet some criteria.

Another mechanism for supporting bloggers is to give them free or reduced-cost professional services, such as web development, graphic design, accounting, legal services, etc.  In additional to the usual payment models for professional services (dues from bloggers, donations from big donors), professional services could be provided on a volunteer basis.  For example, blog readers could volunteer to provide their professional talents to blog writers on an ad hoc basis.  Alternatively, bloggers could trade services with one another, using a barter model.  The cottage industry of open source blogging software, content management software, and blogging templates is another good example of an avenue in which professional services (web development or web design) are provided to bloggers on a volunteer basis.

Alongside goods and services, bloggers sometimes need advice or mentorship, and this need presents another possible kind of support.  A blogger support organization could provide bloggers assistance in making technical, strategic, or editorial choices.  A "blogger school", blogger resource guide, or a similar kind of service could help bloggers make technical decisions about their blogs; or it could help them focus on a topic or learn more about that topic, in order to write better posts; or it could help them maximize the revenue from their blogs.  

Leaving aside goods and services with monetary value, bloggers frequently need access to political events or personalities.  Most frequently, this is expressed in blogger circles as the need for press passes to some event or another; and fortunately, there is a slow but steady trend towards extending press passes to bloggers at conventions and other Democratic political events.  But access goes deeper than that too - it includes opportunities to interview candidates and officials, solicitations of feedback on strategic plans, etc.  It would be nice to think that left-leaning politicians and organizations will eventually come around to granting this kind of access to bloggers.  Realistically, though, bloggers will probably need an organization which can advocate for them, and steadily work on finding a seat at the table for bloggers.  In a way, this is what BlogPAC is doing, in certain targeted ways (especially with regards to net neutrality.)  YearlyKos, by soliciting visits from Democratic luminaries, is also working to give bloggers a seat at the table.  Access is a nebulous concept, and there's plenty of room for many different organizations to help bloggers gain it.

There is a final category of supporting organizations which would be better described as blogosphere support, rather than blogger support: organizations which work to strengthen the blogosphere as a whole, rather than individual bloggers.  Such organizations identify gaps in the progressive blogosphere, and work to fill them.  That includes locating individuals who have something to say and encouraging them to blog; finding issues, geographic areas, media institutions, or other niches which aren't well covered by the blogosphere, and recruiting someone to do so; identifying other blogospheres with which the progressive blogosphere should interact, and building bridges between the spheres; and so on.  There's tons of work which needs to be done along these lines; unfortunately, it is probably the most difficult work in this area, and the work which is least likely to be self-sustaining.

Coming up next...
This post has mostly focused on the kinds of things which need to be done to support bloggers and the blogosphere.  For the most part, I've intentionally avoided mentioning, from a mechanical/organizational point of view, how this would be done.  That discussion will have to wait for the third post in this series.  However, rest assured that there's plenty of work to go around; I imagine that there's room for a few dozen blogger/blogosphere support organizations, with a variety of organizational structures, revenue models, and benefit profiles.

In the next post, I'll discuss the different kinds of revenue available to bloggers, and the kinds of services bloggers can offer to make money.  This is very relevant to blogger support, because one way organizations can support bloggers is to help them find customers, and/or make earning revenue easier.

In the meantime, please chime in below and suggest other ways in which blogger/blogosphere support organizations could provide goods and services which would support bloggers.  If you are a blogger yourself, perhaps you can answer this question: what are your most pressing needs, and how could a support organization help you meet them?



Display:


Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

As a blogger for Blue Hampshire, my most pressing needs are:

1) Time (to get to the many primary events we have),

and

2) resources for effective oppo blogging.

I see (1) as a non-starter essentially, because I think it will take some years in this movement for bloggers at the state level to make enough to do it full-time and be able to, you know, have a family and pay the mortgage. But I would interested to hear about long-term planning for this possibility.

But (2) is something where a (relatively small) outlay could do a world of difference even for the 2008 cycle.  As you mention, access to news archival services like Lexis/Nexis, and the same for TV/vid, perhaps through some sort of shared license, could result in a tremendous return on the investment. One egregious hypocrisy found can have a serious impact on a race, e.g..  Likewise, access to a license for pics would be great too, because it would help to draw more eyeballs to a post and professionalize the feel of it.


Wonder if Sununu's fired now.
by Dean Barker on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 05:49:37 PM EST

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (3.00 / 1)

Thanks!

Lexis/Nexis access seems to be one of the most sought-after item on blogger wish lists, and I think you're right that it would be a pretty good investment.  By license to pictures, I assume you're talking about third party pictures, like photos in newspapers and things, right?  I don' know if there's a way to get a broad license to use a wide variety of different photos.  Probably, some project which helps bloggers license with the 3 - 5 papers they most frequently quote would be more viable.

As for supporting full-time bloggers, I think there's no silver bullet in the offing.  The best I've been able to come up with are new approaches to advertising - cost per action, venturing into local retail ads, etc.  Another approach, I suppose, would be to sell a popular and relatively expensive item on your website - say, newspaper subscriptions, or something - in a way which would allow you to garner commission.  If you've got other thoughts, I'd love to hear em.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:10:01 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

I've been pondering this from a different angle:  how to use my services to funnel money to both such as mutually agreed upon organizations such as, say, a candidate on Act Blue, and towards elements of the blogosphere.  

I'm a real estate agent and often give donations out of my commission to either the arts (local public high school orchestra, local ballet company) or  athletics (UCLA).  Minimum donation is $1,000.  

But it's one thing if I've met a client through such an affiliation and promise a donation if we do business, it's another to probe them on their political beliefs.

It's almost as if there should be an on-line list of "Blue Vendors & Service Providers," maybe organized like Craigslist by community, where people can check out who supports what causes.

Just mulling aloud here.  I've always been happy to put my money where my mouth is in terms of supporting the arts and I make my own donations in the political arena, I'd just like to broaden the notion.


by InigoMontoya on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 06:15:50 PM EST

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

Yeah, I think you're skating on thin ice a bit, unless you really know your customers well.  Supporting the arts is fairly non-controversial and unlikely to turn off customers, but politics is a whole 'nother game.  There is a middle ground, too: organizations which aren't political per se, but have a definite progressive flavor, like Oxfam, Children's Defense Fund, etc.  Most of those probably won't turn off any customers.

Of course, another thing you could try is branding some subset of your business in explicitly progressive terms, to progressive customers.  You could then do the commission-donating thing in support of an organization like Media Matters, or some other progressive 501c3.  That's probably very tricky to pull off, though, from a business point of view.

In any event, I'd be pretty careful before promising to donate a part of a commission to a candidate.  I don't know election law that well, but that sounds like the kind of thing which might be illegal.

Good luck!  Sounds like a very creative approach.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:17:17 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

I would be very interested in some kind of a 'blogger subscription organization' where you could buy a membership and get cheaper political books or magazines.

It could make what dollars I have for that go further.


Blue Hampshire, a progressive online community for the Granite State.
by nhcollegedem on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 07:34:21 PM EST

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

I was talking with a blogger about this on Friday, and my thoughts were that it's going to be much easier for us to get some sort of infrastructure/funding in place for the state blogs than it is for the national focused blogs. It's just a lot more ideologically clean to wrap the state blog infrastructure into the 50 state strategy, the online component, with the national blogs advocating for it to happen.


by Jerome Armstrong on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 08:07:21 PM EST

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

I hope you're right.  Maybe this is my own prejudice but I think State blogs fill a more desperate need.  Coverage of local politics is terrible most place.  There is a great need for projects like the 50 State Blog Network.


by Melissa Ryan on Sun Jul 29, 2007 at 12:04:45 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

This is a very interesting idea, and it makes a lot of sense.  On top of everything else, it's the kind of thing which plugs in well to our campaign-centric funding mechanisms; for example, a presidential candidate could easily justify subsidizing (whether through ads or other means) part of the Florida progressive blogosphere.  Alternatively, I could imagine the DSCC paying for a yearlong Lexis/Nexis subscription for all the bloggers in the 50 state network, hoping to nab some more Allens.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:22:24 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Supporting the Blogosphere, Part 1 - Services (none / 0)

how about shared subscription services to resources like Lexis Nexis or english translations of the Arabic media?


by azizhp on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 08:10:51 PM EST

Use Other Organizations as a Model (3.00 / 2)

Community organizers have some of the same needs and limitations as bloggers. They are often the single employee of a small, local non-profit oganization that is poorly funded and they move from job to job frequently. About 10 years ago, community organizers got together and formed the National Organizers Alliance (NOA) which provides connection with other organizers and a potable 401(k) pension fund. I think they are working on creating a healthcare plan.

I think freelance reporters and writers have also created similar kinds of organizations. It is possible that blogers could piggyback on these existing organizations or at least use them as a model.


by RandomNonviolence on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 08:45:51 PM EST

Re: Use Other Organizations as a Model (none / 0)

Interesting.. I have heard of NOA before, but it's been a little while.  there's also National Writer's Union, which I mention in the third post in this series, which provides similar kinds of benefits for freelance writers.

As a general rule, piggybacking is probably the way to go, for now.  But at some point, bloggers will need their own organizations, because there are problems bloggers face which don't really come up for freelance writers or community organizers (to take a simple example: how to integrate a blog with a social networking site.)


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:26:23 AM EST
[ Parent ]

This isn't really what we're talking about (none / 0)

..in the sense that we're looking for something a little more, I don't know, permanent and effective. But I think in the mean time, a good(?) idea might be having some kind of Kos/MyDD/Open Left/ect. community poll involving (how many ever) progressive bloggers/sites and then holding balls out cross-site fundraising drives for (again, how many ever) the most popular bloggers/sites.

In other words, it would be nice for, say, Digby, to be able to blog full time, while we're getting this whole thing worked out and perfected.


by Parker Lewis on Sun Jul 29, 2007 at 12:41:04 AM EST

Re: This isn't really what we're talking about (none / 0)

Yeah, it's funny.. we're much better at coordinating campaign fundraising drives than blogger fundraising drives.  I wonder why that is?  Selflessness?

I don't follow Crooks and Liars much, but I know they do PBS-style fundraising from time to time, and DailyKos sometimes front pages those.  That's a reasonable way to go, and it might even be able to support a handful of full-time bloggers in the short term.  In the long term, I'd love it if there was some way to recycle the money, so that we could create more and more sustainable full-time blogs.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:29:35 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Lexis/Nexis and Video Editing Training (none / 0)

Great series Shai!

My two biggest needs (and the two things that I think would make the biggest impact in the progressive blogosphere):

1.  Free access to Lexis/Nexis.  If the progressive blogosphere consistently has better links, better info, better research, and better writing it will attract more people and make a bigger impact.  But you gotta have Lexis/Nexis for the really nitty gritty work and it's freakin expensive.

2.  Training in video editing.  Everything is moving towards video and again, if the progressive blogosphere could expand its capabilities in video editing, messaging, lighting, distribution, it would further shift the national debate towards progressives.  

Again thanks for the great series.  


http://www.rfkactionfront.com
by RFK Action Front on Sun Jul 29, 2007 at 09:15:47 PM EST

Re: Lexis/Nexis and Video Editing Training (none / 0)

There's a YearlyKos workshop on video editing; if you're going to be there, check it out, but if not, I think you can get the video stream.  What kind of video are you editing, by the way?  In some cases, you might be able to get away with pretty easy edits.

L/N has come up three or four times in this one comment thread.  That's nuts.  I don't know much about this, but there's really gotta be some kind of creative way to make that happen.  License sharing with progressive media like the Nation?  Sneaking into college libraries?  Heck if I know, but I wonder if there's someway more clever than just plunking down the raw cash.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Wed Aug 01, 2007 at 05:34:01 AM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.