Car-free consulting

A couple of weeks ago at Cambridge Drinking Liberally, my fellow drinkers and I chatted about peak oil, and the world of hurt we're all going to be in as oil prices start to climb irreversibly.  My co-host has been reading a bit too much of The Oil Drum, I guess.  We all had a good old fashioned freak-out about an impending environmental and humanitarian catastrophe.  Good times.

It's in the spirit of delaying environmental apocalypse that I'm posting this idea, hoping that somewhere, an enterprising liberal will pick it up, turn it into a serious business, make serious money, and save serious amounts of oil.  More than that, this post elaborates on the concept of liberal entrepreneurship, which I posted about back in March.  In particular, I'm exploring the notion of using consumer spending as a revenue stream for liberal entrepreneurship.  My larger point - outside the particulars of car-free consulting - is that progressive values can be woven into daily life in a way that's financially beneficial.  Helping consumers reap the financial benefits of a progressive lifestyle is not just a good way to make money, it's a great way to strengthen the progressive movement, by making our values real to people who may or may not be politically engaged.

But enough theory; let's get down to dollars and cents.

The goal of a car-free consultant is to help her clients go about their daily lives without having to own a car.  As I envision it, a car-free consultation would be a two- or three-week affair composed of three or four client meetings, during which the consultant and her client would work together to nail down the client's weekly schedule, and to find ways for the client to get through as much of the week as possible without using a car.  The consultant's work would involve helping her client puzzle through mass transit and commuter train schedules, apartment listings, bicycle regulations, ZipCar marketing literature, employers' child care policies, and any other information that might be helpful in achieving that goal.  Periodically, the consultant would check in with the client to make sure that the plan they had hammered out is still working.  For a premium, the consultant could offer to be available during real estate searches, to serve as a kind of car-free real estate agent.  If an absolutely car-free existence simply isn't possible, the consultant would help the client reduce her car usage considerably, or would help the client's family go from two cars to one.

There are a number of different possible payment models.  One that I particularly like is proportional payments: the consultant's payment is some percentage of the amount of money she helps the client save (with a minimum guaranteed payment, perhaps).  This model encourages the consultant to reduce car usage as much as possible.

Finding clients is a trickier problem.  My guess is that a consultant could get a lot of mileage (har-dee-har-har) out of traditional advertising; US consumers have responded to the rising cost of car maintenance, buying less SUVs and less oil overall at a time when oil prices are rising sharply.  I imagine that a marketing campaign which highlights how much many can be saved by going car-free would be very effective.  Other potential marketing tricks include partnerships with places like real-estate agencies and day care centers (where the real car-free decision is made), or mass transit agencies and other transportation alternative companies, like ZipCar and ReadySetGoose.  Incidentally, having poked around the ReadySetGoose site a bit, my guess is that the company is working on an idea somewhat similar to this one, but that's just speculation.

A potentially lucrative and effective service-delivery/marketing model is to offer car-free consulting services through an employer.  In this case, the consultant's services could be offered to employees as a benefit.  More and more businesses appear eager to encourage their employees to get to work without using a car, so I imagine there is some latent demand for this kind of service.  A car-free consultant with this kind of setup could help setup car-pool programs, programs to transport employees to mass transit from the job site, and other kinds of employer-sponsored programs to make car-free living more feasible.

A similar, and I think intriguing, idea is to lobby a city government to subsidize car-free consulting services for its residents.  That opens up a much larger potential pool of clients, and it opens up the potential for much more extensive and systematic municipal car-free reform.  The consultant's clients would be a natural source of data regarding the kinds of services which residents need to go car-free, and could be an active constituency lobbying for those programs.

My long-term hope for car-free consultants is that they could help bring together city governments, neighborhood citizens groups, mass transit agencies, local business coalitions, and developers in an overarching effort to shape their policies and practices around car-free living.  A car-free consultant has a lot to gain from such an effort; if a city and developer work together to plan dense commercial and residential real-estate clustered around mass transit stops, the car-free consultant will eventually garner many new clients.  I'm sure this is more or less pie-in-the-sky thinking, but it would be nice to see someone whose financial interests are best served by cohesive regional car-free planning.

Regardless, I think car-free consultants are the kind of glue which we need to bring together high energy prices, a renewed environmental consciousness, and growing enthusiasm to address global warming within business and government.  I'd certainly like to see some progressives run with this idea.



Display:


Re: Car-free consulting (2.00 / 1)

As both a consultant and a car free citizen, I can't imagine how much I would have to charge to deal with people so dumb that they can't figure out life without a car. But my guess is that if they could afford to pay the price, they'd be living on the tropical island they owned.


by Bob Brigham on Fri Jun 22, 2007 at 07:54:26 PM EST

Re: Car-free consulting (3.00 / 2)

"people so dumb that they can't figure out life without a car"

May I ask where you live?  I was ready to go Car-free in Madison, WI.

Moving to a small town in the deep south, 40 miles away from a large town, with no mass transit whatsoever, no bikelanes or even drivers who are used to seeing bicycles.  The town has been designed around the assumption that everyone has a car.  

There are larger factors at work regarding why people continue to own cars than sheer narcissism or incompetence.  That's why the proposal is appealing to me.  It recognizes that there are greater factors at work in obstructing peoples' ability to go car-free than their own force of will.


by Transmission on Fri Jun 22, 2007 at 09:06:58 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

that should say, "Then I moved to......"


by Transmission on Fri Jun 22, 2007 at 09:07:27 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

Yeah, you nailed it: my assumption is that it's not just a matter of people being bad, in some way, that makes them want to own a car.  I went car-free in Boston and Champaign, IL.  Each time, I had to learn bus schedules, find an apartment ideally located close to work and a supermarket, etc. (and I was a single guy back then, no family to worry about.)  I enjoyed the challenge, and it wasn't that difficult at the end of the day.  But then again, I was highly anti-car motivated, and I like futzing around with bus schedules and that kind of thing.  And moreover, I had a lot of factors going for me (like excellent mass transit systems in both cities.)  There's an awful lot of people who don't have those factors working for them, or don't have quite the same level of motivation, or minds that are good with numbers and schedules.  Those people could still go car-free, and that's who this idea is for.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 09:49:10 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

I don't have any trouble imaginging my fellow yuppies needing this sort of help.  Most of them have never been on a bus in their lives, and the fear of getting stuck somewhere is a powerful disincentive to try.

I would not want to do this sort of work on a percentage basis, though;  too many people will go through the counseling but not really want to follow through with it, and you don't want someone to be penalized because the client wasn't really serious.  The same problem would apply to judging the effectiveness of a service like this.  You can lead a horse to water....


by janiner on Fri Jun 22, 2007 at 08:24:40 PM EST

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

Well, I think you've got a very good point about the payment model.  Minimum guaranteed payments would help with that, but I think at the end of the day there'd still be plenty of people who wouldn't want to go through with the changes.  At the same time, I think the numbers will work out: you can charge one person who gets rid of her car enough to cover the losses from two or three others who don't.  Moreover, I think that saving money can be a very powerful incentive, and people will sometimes surprise you.

Finally, the service isn't just intended for yuppies.  I can imagine any number of working class people who can't really afford their car, but feel that they need it, so they sacrifice something else.  For those people, giving up their car wouldn't just be some kind of politically correct statement, it would be simple kitchen table economics.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 10:08:24 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

I lived without a car until I became a parent with children.  My wife joined in for a while.  At the time, I was working full-time and she was homeschooling two children and not working outside the home.  

Going to work without a car is easy.  Ferrying small children is not.  This was in Seattle which has one of the better bus systems in the nation.  We eventually gave it up because there were some events the kids went to that would require two buses and take an hour or more to get to that took only 10-15 minutes in a car.

The solution, IMHO, is to raise the price of driving to make it really high, use some of the money to seriously improve public transportation, and use some of it to increase tax rebates, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit, to low-income people so that they do not lose in the process.  

In Norway, they are paying more than $7 a gallon for gas.  Norway exports oil so it is not because of a shortage in the country.  Most of the difference  is taxes.  People would drive a lot less if they had to look at paying that much at the pump.

However, it is hard to imagine the political situation that would allow that to happen here.  AL Gore has said that the solutions to global warming are beyond what can be even politically imagined at this time in this country.


by chrisdarling on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 09:40:51 AM EST

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

I think you've very quickly narrowed in on the key problem: raising children without a car.  It's really very difficult, and the truth is, I'm not sure it'd be possible for a lot of families.  I think some families could get away with one car instead of two, especially if they could set up ride-sharing arrangements with other families, or things like that.

But then again, getting one single person to get rid of her car has essentially the same effect as getting one family with kids to get rid of one of their cars.  There's a lot of low-hanging fruit out there, and I think we should grab it first.

I think raising the price of driving would be good, but I think the solution to helping out the low-income folks inevitably stung by that move would have to be much deeper than just good public transit.  It's that, and it's also good zoning and development practice; good community policing; good retail siting practices; and all sorts of other things besides.  These problems are probably best solved at the municipal or maybe regional level, where a lot of these kinds of problems can be hashed out on a relatively small scale and with sensitivity to existing communities.

With cars eating up about 17% of our income as it is (not to mention a big chunk of our governmental budgets), I think there is a latent motivation to get rid of them to the degree possible.  I think we just need a few relatively minor factors to be in place, to tip that motivation into action.


Strengthening the progressive movement through liberal entrepreneurship http://www.plantingliberally.org
by Shai Sachs on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 10:19:41 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Car-free consulting (none / 0)

Thanks for that link to The Oil Drum.  I hadn't seen that site before, looks pretty interesting.

I especially enjoyed "Can We Be Happy Using Less Energy? Uhhh.... YES!" on the World Values Survey data and such (the "poor" are happier than the wealthy, etc.).  Good stuff:

http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2671


by schloopy on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 10:36:11 AM EST

Could Help People with Disabilities (none / 0)

This is a very interesting idea.  As has been noted, it can be easy to go carless if you live in a big city with good transportation.  One area a consultant could help with a lot is ferry people with disabilities which can be very hard on public transportation.  My father suffers from Parkinsons and lives in NYC.  Unfortunately, the NY subway is old and many stations are not handicapped accessible so we end up driving or taking cabs places because it is easier for him to get places.  The bus tends to be very, very slow and does not always stop in convenient places and the Access A Ride program is unreliable.

I am all for reducing car usage but there are a lot of challenges for people, even those in cities with good public transportation.  I think there could be a good business model here.


by John Mills on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 01:17:48 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.