McConnell Gets Worried, Commissions Loaded Poll to Bolster Position

Fresh off of reports of DSCC polling showing Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell running just neck-and-neck with Democratic Rep. Ben Chandler in a potential 2008 matchup in Kentucky (McConnell 45, Chandler 44), McConnell has apparently turned to a GOP pollster to concoct numbers that show him comfortable in his reelection bid. But take a look at the questions required to push voters out of the camp of one of his possible Democratic challengers:

Mitch McConnell is only the 2nd person in Kentucky history to lead his party in the US Senate. On this, who do you agree with more (ROTATE)

  • 70% People who feel that having someone from Kentucky lead his party in the Senate is a point of pride to them and will help get more done for the state
  • 18% People who say having someone from Kentucky in a leadership position does not matter to them
  • 5% Neither / other (DNR)
  • 7% Don't know (DNR)
A point raised by critics is that Charlie Owen has no prior experience in public office and if elected he would be 70 years old on the day he was sworn in, one of the oldest freshman Senators in US history. In view of his age and lack of experience, do you have a very positive, somewhat positive, somewhat negative or very negative reaction to Charlie Owen running for Senate?
  • 9% Very positive
  • 22% Somewhat positive
  • 32% Somewhat negative
  • 21% Very negative
  • 13% Don't know (DNR)
And based on their positions who are you most likely to vote for for US Senator? (ROTATE)
Charlie Owen who says he won't be politics as usual, that as minority leader Mitch McConnell is too caught up in Washington politics and isn't taking the time to get things done for the people of Kentucky
/OR/
Mitch McConnell who says that as Republican leader in the Senate he has proven to be effective in getting things done for Kentucky, that at age 70 Charlie Owen has no experience and will never build up the seniority to be effective for the state
  • 29% Charlie Owen
  • 55% Mitch McConnell
  • Both of these equally (DNR) *
  • 4% Neither of these / other (DNR)
  • 10% Don't know (DNR)

As you can see the pollster, Jan R. van Lohuizen, uses a couple of tricks to achieve his desired results. First, the actual head-to-head question is phrased in such a way that there are positive and negative statements about both candidates, and so on the surface it would appear to be a balanced informed ballot question (or at least as balanced as these things come when commissioned by a particular candidate). Yet what does he do in the two questions preceding the informed ballot question? He loads the respondents with very unbalanced information -- positive information about McConnell and not one but two pieces of negative information about Owen. With this in mind, it's no wonder McConnell came out ahead in the final question.

But McConnell's performace in this rather unbalanced informed ballot question is less than one might have expected. For a sitting Senator to only receive 55 percent in a head-to-head match-up against someone portrayed as an old man with no political experience is actually somewhat underwhelming and is, in fact, somewhat telling about McConnell's weakness among Kentuckians. And as Mark Hebert, who posted the poll on his blog for WHAS News, notes, McConnell has been unable to crack the 50 percent approval mark in recent non-partisan polling from the state, yet more indication that the Senator is potentially vulnerable as he gears up for his reelection bid.

For more coverage of the effort to hold McConnell accountable and put him through the gauntlet this cycle, check out the Ditch Mitch blog.



Display:


A Nightmare on MyDD Street (3.00 / 2)

Oh geez, Jonathan. A Nightmare on MyDD Street for me on this one. Jan Van Lohuizen is a blast from my past, before I was an independent pollster. I worked for another polling outfit that worked with people that just loooooved good old Jan. My view is they loved him because he has no principles, ethics nor values other than whoring right-wing numbers, which enabled proto-rovian campaigns in the late '80's from these guys. (I quit that polling outfit PDQ, as you can imagine.) I hadn't heard of Jannie ("Yanni") in a long time and thought maybe, just maybe, he retired to Transylvania. Or The Green Zone.

Needless to say, you are beyond right on in pointing out the total crapola this "poll" represents. Good job, amigo. Thanks for showing the folks how those scumbags do their thing.

Maybe I'll watch A Nightmare on Elm Street tonight to soothe my Jan-mare just induced.


by Sun Tzu on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 05:18:47 PM EST

Re: McConnell Gets Worried, Commissions Loaded Pol (none / 0)

The problem here is that Chandler, in my opinion, is clearly waiting for 2010 to run for the Senate. He COULD have run for Governor this year and been the front runner, and the fact that polls show him in a dead heat with the Senate Minority Leader without him even being in the race testifies to his electoral strength and popularity in Kentucky.
However, if you were Chandler, why not wait until next cycle when you would have a MUCH MUCH weaker incumbent in Bunning who almost lost to a no-name in the GOP-tilted 2004 election, or- and this is more likely I think- run in an open seat.
by AC4508 on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 06:05:13 PM EST

Re: McConnell Gets Worried, Commissions Loaded Pol (none / 0)

You're exactly right about Chandler -- he has much more reason to wait out this cycle and run in the next. That said, the fact that he is running even with McConnell is both a tribute to him but also a testament to the fact that McConnell is indeed vulnerable.


Blogging here @ MyDD.com. Twittering @jonathanhsinger.
by Jonathan Singer on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 06:12:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: McConnell Gets Worried (none / 0)

I don't know if I understand this reasoning.  If he runs now and even if he loses a squeaker to the minority leader in the Senate, wouldn't he then be in a better position to mop up the weaker seat in 2010 after going through one race already?  Or is it just that he doesn't want to go through all of the effort when he has a softer target in 2 years?


NJ Hussein Independent
by NJIndependent on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 09:11:20 PM EST
[ Parent ]

i'm confused (none / 0)

If the poll that got McConnell scared (and the DSCC happy) was him vs Chandler, why is the poll he commissioned him vs. Owen?


http://www.actblue.com/page/asaslist
by asahopkins on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 06:25:51 PM EST

Re: i'm confused (none / 0)

Because he wants to show he can beat a Democrat but he would likely have trouble beating Chandler in a poll.


Blogging here @ MyDD.com. Twittering @jonathanhsinger.
by Jonathan Singer on Tue Apr 24, 2007 at 06:54:10 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I'm shocked and amazed (none / 0)

that McConnell only gets 55% in a poll so obviously loaded, against an opponent who isn't particularly strong to begin with.

McConnell is in serious trouble.

Let's Daschle him.


by brownsox on Wed Apr 25, 2007 at 11:09:02 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.