Republicans Hemorrhaging Support... in Utah?

By almost any mark, Republicans are at record low levels of support in recent memory. A Hotline/Diageo poll (.pdf) released this month showed that voters generally support a Democrat for the White House in 2008 over a Republican by a stunning 47 percent to 29 percent margin and that voters support the current crop of Democrats running over the Republicans now in the race by a similarly overwhelming 40 percent to 22 percent margin. And the current Republican morass is not limited to the upcoming presidential race. Polling from The Pew Research Center finds that Republican self-identification within the electorate is at a two-decade low, with Democrats holding a 15-point advantage when partisans and leaners are included. But might the situation be even worse than these nationwide numbers indicate? Check out this data relayed by The New York Times' Martin Stolz from what has long been one of the most -- if not the most -- Republican states in the country.

Currently, 49 percent of voters in Utah are Republican and 18 percent Democrats, with the rest independents or divided among minor parties. That represents a six-percentage-point decline for Republicans since January, based on telephone surveys conducted by Dan Jones, a political science professor at the University of Utah and president of a polling firm that began measuring public opinion in Utah in 1960. [emphasis added]

To set out a few caveats about these numbers, one should not read too much into the mere description of polling in an article without seeing the actual results and methodology. One should not read too much into the results of one poll or even necessarily on set of polls from a single pollster. One should not read too much into the results of polling where margins of error are not listed -- particularly when the changes likely fall in or near to those margins of error.

This all said, it is stunning to see an indication that the Republicans may have lost more than 10 percent of their supporters in some of the reddest country in America -- and just since the beginning of the year. True, the poll does not indicate that these Republicans are becoming Democrats (though it's also not clear from The Times article that they are not becoming Democrats, either). What's more, with a 49 percent to 18 percent edge in voter registration Republicans would still likely be strong enough to dominate most elections in Utah. Yet this trend cannot make Republicans nationally confident about the loyalty of their base going into the 2008 election. If so many voters in a traditional GOP stronghold like Utah are shredding their ties to the Republican Party -- or even if they are not willing to admit to a pollster that they are Republicans -- GOP strategists and activists will have their work cut out for them trying to turn out their base for the general election.

The 2008 presidential election might not be decided just on the basis of which side's base turns out (or, at the least, Republicans won't likely be able to swamp the Democrats merely by turning out their base). But if the Republicans are unable to activate their core supporters -- and those who in recent cycles have voted for them regularly -- it is going to be awfully difficult for whomever the GOP nominates for the presidency is to even come close to getting the support necessary to be elected next November.



Display:


Well... (none / 0)

"GOP strategists and activists will have their work cut out for them trying to turn out their base for the general election."

If Hillary wins the Democratic primaries they can relax.


The history of the left is a history of purists betraying the progressive movement so that they can feel good about their righteous selves.
by Populism2008 on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:05:43 PM EST

Re: Republicans Hemorrhaging Support... in Utah? (none / 0)

Perhaps the knowledge that the Surthern Fundamentalist base of the GOP won't support Romney becsue of this religion is starting to hit home in Utah.

Dems candiates need to visit Utah and take our case to this historically Republican group.

We won't necessarily win Utah but large Morman populations in swing states like NV, AX, CO and VA should be on our list of voters to court.


by Sam I Am on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:16:42 PM EST

Re: Republicans Hemorrhaging Support... in Utah? (none / 0)

Well the GOP is great at making Democrats into the boogeyman, so I think regardless of who are candidate is (but especially Hillary), anyone we throw out there will cause the Republican base to circle the wagons and rally together. Also, it seems to me that the GOP brand is weakening but the Democratic brand has necessarily strengthened much, so its hard to convert these people long term.
All that being said, I think what we're seeing here is the continued realization that the GOP is so far out of touch with reality that the moderate wing of the GOP is becoming more and more disillusioned and are open to change.
by AC4508 on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 05:17:22 PM EST

Re: Republicans Hemorrhaging Support... in Utah? (none / 0)

I hope this is not considered off-topic, but someone please show me what would be wrong with this proposal:  Blocs of regular readers of this site, Kos, The Left Coaster, FDL, etc. etc. go out and change your party affiliation to Republican.  Continue to vote Progressive in general elections, but in primaries at all possible levels, vote for the WEAKEST Repug candidate possible.  Trust that your local Dems will choose their strongest candidate, and just do all you can to see that Repugs nominate their WEAKEST.  Give all the "wrong" answers to the Repug-sourced surveys you will receive.  Who knows?  Maybe even get invited to a Repug-only event featuring someone like a Repug Senator or Rep, Cheney, or the mother lode - The Smirk himself.  Then YOU can be the one who makes the national news by jumping up and inviting the Repug of honor to piss up a rope!

Some might say this isn't playing fair.  I'm TIRED of playing fair.  It's time to do whatever it takes.


by FishtownTom on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 07:37:58 PM EST

Re: Republicans Hemorrhaging Support... in Utah? (none / 0)

67, My Man, 67!


by Andre on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 11:14:38 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.