Questions for the Presidential Candidates

This coverage is sponsored by SEIU, the Service Employees International Union, the fastest-growing union in North America, with 1.8 million members in the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico.

I'm just in the Portland International Airport ready to get on a plane for Las Vegas for the SEIU/CAP presidential forum on healthcare. The Service Employees International Union, which is playing a huge role in politics today not only through its efforts to organize American workers but also through its Americans for Healthcare effort and its Walk a Day in My Shoes 2008 campaign that enables presidential candidates to learn firsthand what it means to be a hardworking member of a union, has graciously agreed to sponsor my coverage of tomorrow's forum.

The event will be streamed live on the internet, for those interested, and I will be liveblogging the event here beginning at about 9:00 AM Pacific/12:00 PM Eastern. I will also (hopefully) be speaking with one or more of the presidential candidates on a one-on-one basis and I'd like to know what you want to hear from them. What would you like asked of the presidential candidates tomorrow?



Display:


Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Does it have to be a health care question, or can it be something important?

I kid, but serious question, at least the first half.


by skintigh on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 03:30:01 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (3.00 / 1)

According to a study of US health costs and service by the Bloomberg School of Public Health at Johns Hopkins:

The United States..

1) has fewer per capita hospital beds, physicians, nurses, and CT scanners than the OECD median.

2) spends twice as much (US $5,267 vs. OECD $2,696) as other OECD nations without rationing

3) spends 53% more money per capita then the next highest country, Switzerland, but has lower life expectancy (77.5 vs. 80.6) and higher infant mortality (6.9 per 1000 vs 4.3)

4) spends only $16 per capita on malpractice claims vs. $12 per capita in the UK - $4 per capita hardly accounts for the $2,600 per capita difference between the US and aveage OECD country

5) the US has about 15% uninsured vs. 1-2% for the vast majority for OECD countries (save Turkey and Mexico)

http://www.cmwf.org/publications/publica tions_show.htm?doc_id=283969
- - -
In short why should the US continue to pay more for less?

Louisiana is roughly the same population as Ireland and spends as much on Medicare and Medicaid alone as Ireland spends on all health care costs. So Ireland covers all of their people for the same cost as LA covering those on public programs before they even get to working adults and their children.

In a world with free trade how can there be such an imbalance in the cost of a commodity - health care?


"Nothing seems to embarrass the political class today." - Bill Moyers
by joejoejoe on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 03:56:49 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Roger Hickey, co-director of Campaign for America's Future (where I now blog), has a post previewing the debate and laying out five key health care questions for all the candidates:

1. Will the candidate's plan really cover everyone--with a decent guaranteed level of coverage--at an affordable cost?

2. Does the candidate offer a public plan, like Medicare, that has a predictable, guaranteed level of benefits that "cannot be taken away?"

3. Has the candidate thought through how his or her plan will be financed?

4. Will the candidate's health plan control spiraling health care costs?

5. Is the candidate's health plan simple and clear enough that they can explain it--and get us to describe it to someone else?

Hopefully, that's helpful. Have fun in Vegas!


by BillScherForOurFuture on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 03:57:55 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Has the candidate thought through how his or her plan will be financed?

The mechanism is up for debate but US health care costs more because of a host of middlemen making a profit off the illnesses of Americans. The US needs to spend LESS, not MORE on health care.


"Nothing seems to embarrass the political class today." - Bill Moyers
by joejoejoe on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 04:51:58 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Just EXACTLY why can't Bush be impeached?


by texex on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 04:04:20 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

For John Edwards:

Medical research priorities.  Not just for Elizabeth, or breast cancer patients, but for people everywhere.  Increasing research funding is critical, what sort of growth rate do you envision or whom do you see guiding your science/research policy?

-Zen Blade


by Zen Blade on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 04:27:04 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Will it be single payer and universal?


by joyful alternative on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 04:34:18 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

More specifically, since some (Edwards) have discussed some details of their plans:
Why not single payer?
Is there one good reason, if you're going to universal coverage, not to make it single payer?
Are they worried about the insurance industry eliminating too many jobs? Or are they worried about the insurance industry's money talking in Washington?
Why would their non-single payer plan be different from Hillary's '93 non-single payer plan, which seemed to die in large part b/c of the complexity that was necessary to maintain an insurance industry?

Seriously I think all the talk about Universal coverage is nice, but by not talking about single payer, all of the candidates sound meek and typical. Except of course, unelectable Kucinich.


by jujube on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 11:06:34 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

1. I want them to give clear answers on whether they will support Medicare for all.

2. If Bush refuses to allow Rove, Miers et. al. testify about the USA controversy in response to subpoenas, would they support impeachment?


by chrisdarling on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 05:02:34 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Ask Hillary when she is going to pull her head out of her ass and admit that thousands of Americans have died because she supported the biggest foreign policy disaster is a generation.


by Bob Brigham on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 05:13:03 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (3.00 / 3)

It was Bush who decided to invade Iraq and he had enough GOP senators to pass the AUMF even if every Democrat had voted against it.

But I'm sure the Bush and Blair administrations, and the Republican Party, are HAPPY to agree with your point of view, blogswarm.  Cast the net of responsibility as widely as possible. That's the way to let the truly guilty parties off the hook.


Keep it short. DemocraticShortList.com
by Rob in Vermont on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 05:48:09 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

She still should apologize... she was wrong to vote for it and wrong to support it publically as long as she did.


by yitbos96bb on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 06:09:01 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (3.00 / 1)

What will they do to expand workers' rights to form unions?


by domma on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 05:52:10 PM EST

Hillary could start by firing her pollster/strateg (none / 0)

For Hillary in particular:

Why has she hired, as one of her main political advisors, someone whose firm's website advertises itself as an expert in helping corporations "protect themselves" against union organizing campaigns?

"Companies cannot be caught unprepared by Organized Labor's coordinated campaigns whether they are in conjunction with organizing or contract negotiating. Gathering accurate information and having the ability to adeptly communicate messages to multiple audiences are the keys to success. That is why we have developed a comprehensive communications approach for clients when they face any type of labor situation.

Burson-Marsteller maintains strong ties with law firms, associations, think tanks and other organizations that influence labor policy and address labor issues. We work closely with Professor Jarol Manheim of George Washington University, who wrote The Death of a Thousand Cuts: Corporate Campaigns and the Attack on the Corporation, which stands as the authority on corporate campaigns.

Burson-Marsteller can be your partner in developing and implementing a comprehensive communications/public affairs program to achieve your business goals."

(h/t Mark Schmitt.)


by hilzoy on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 11:41:21 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

John Edwards:
1)  Why did you wait until November of 2005 to apologize for your war vote instead of doing it earlier?

2)  If you are sick, do you think about Ann Coulter naked on a cold day to induce vomiting?  (Kidding)

Barack Obama:  
1)Your past record shows strong support for progressive values, yet during the campaign many have commented that you have been mute on pushing these values versus John Edwards who has talked about them during pratically every campaign stop.  How would you answer your critics who are calling for you to tell us more of where you stand on various progressive issues?

2)  Why are you so wonderful?  (Kidding.. Kidding... Just joking)

Hillary Clinton:
1)  Why won't you apologize for being wrong on your war vote?  Why can't you say those two simple words...I'm Sorry?

2)  Are you or have you ever been the anti-christ?  (Kidding)


by yitbos96bb on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 06:06:54 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Good questions.  I'd add for Hillary, isn't admitting a mistake a sign of strength?  If you can't admit a mistake, how can we trust that you or anyone else have learned from those mistakes.

My question would be this:  What would you do to make the government more responsive to the people.  How can we get government back to being for the people, instead of for for the corporations or big donors.


John McCain: Bush right to veto kids health insurance expansion
by Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 07:30:12 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

I'd love to ask all, but Hillary Clinton in particular, why did you fail to reform health care when you had an historic chance to do it? and why will next time be different?

I'll support her if the is the nominee but I remember 1993 & 1994 and take it seriously that the administration failed.  They had the Congress.  They had the White House.  They failed.


by howardpark on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 06:37:02 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

http://www.yesmagazine.org/article.asp?I D=1498

Pick a solution - make it happen - no excuses asap!


by dearreader on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 06:53:18 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

A FOUR year old , that's (4) who was diagnosed with being a CHILD, I mean having ADD and Manic Bi-Polar Disorder. (FOUR) years old now. She dies because she was so drugged up, the meds killed her.

I would like to ask the Panel to address the fact that an entire generation of NORMAL CHILDREN are being diagnosed with serious Mental Health problems in an effort to get the child out of their parents hair. Instead of raising their child, they would rather have them drugged up on meds. It is unfortunate that this is being allowed to go on. I would like their thoughts on this growing epidemic of doctors helping ignorant parents dope their children in an effort to make life easier for the parent who doesn't have the time or patience to teach a child as they grow.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17758170/


"I don't believe in this can't do, won't do, won't even try style of politics. Yes We Can!" ~ Barack Obama
by ObamaEdwards2008 on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 07:08:24 PM EST

Obama's Promise (none / 0)

As I V-Logged HERE, in Oakland last weekend, Senator Obama said:

We can...make sure that every single American has basic healthcare in fact I want to be held accountable for that! We can have universal healthcare by the end of the next president's first term. By the end of MY FIRST TERM!

Watch video HERE

But, hey, it was a rally, he didn't get into specifics. So I wanna know, how does he intend to keep that promise?


by Todd Beeton on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 07:30:05 PM EST

Re: Obama's Promise (none / 0)

And that is a very fair question.  I'd like to hear his plan as well.


by yitbos96bb on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 09:15:15 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

is the candidate willing to sign on to support the "american freedom agenda"?
  • Restore habeas corpus to prevent the illegal imprisonment of American citizens;
  • Prohibit torture and extraordinary rendition;
  • Prohibit unconstitutional wiretaps, email and mail openings via warrantless searches;
  • Protect journalists from prosecution under the Espionage Act for reporting on stories on national significance that do not reveal troop locations;
  • Prohibit Presidential Signing Statements that allow the President to sign into law legislation passed by Congress while rejecting line-item aspects of that same law;
  • Reform the ability of the federal government to win dismissal of constitutional grievances by private parties by claiming state secrets;

by selise on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 08:27:02 PM EST

I would ask all candidates this: (none / 0)

Could they pledge that they would place special emphasis on making a universal healthcare plan more beneficial to people rather than to insurance companies? In other words, would it be important to them for the bill not to be influenced by the corporate 'needs' of the insurance industry?

To me, that would be just as important as getting the program completed. I'd hate to see a 'compromise' plan that turned into a major tax giveaway to the insurance industry.


by mihan on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 08:32:04 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Politicians running for Congress and President are always talking about "fixing Social Security." Why is it that these same office holders have set-upan entirely separate insurance programs for retirement that basically lets them rest assured that the solvency of Social Security will never affect them directly? How do you justify this exemption from "sharing the pain"? Why do we have this aristocratic class in the U.S.?

Do you view housing as an American "right"?

In a capitalist society, should all Amerucans have the right to work a 40 hour work weeks that computes to ABOVE the poverty rate per annum?  

Have you ever studied the repeal of corporate licenses? Do you support any repeals in light of Enron, Adelphia, etc.? Do you believe a corporation deserves or should be granted rights equal to an individual?


by BrooklynRider on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 09:35:26 PM EST

A Question for Hillary, a question for all (none / 0)

A question for Hillary:We are in a genuine crisis in this country. Why has she stated that she is not going to go forward with a universal health care plan for America until a second term as president?

A question for all candidates: A good share of our health care dollar goes to support the profit, marketing, and administration of service delivery in corporate insurance, pharmaceuticals, and health care institutions, higher than any other country by far. Since the greatest efficiencies are to be found in the direct Medicare public system, why not create a Medicare coverage for everyone as a base coverage, and people can purchase those add-ons they so desire through non-profits like Kaiser or insurance pools.


by cmpnwtr on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 10:12:37 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

How would you make social security sustainable indefinitely?

Are there any existing systems, either in the U.S., in the states, or in other countries that you would use as a model for your health care plan?

Do you think that income from investment should be taxed at the same rate as income from work?

With half the world living on $2 a day or less, what would you do to raise the standard of living around the world?


"And so in the place of the palace of privilege, we seek to build a temple out of faith and hope and charity."-FDR
by jallen on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 10:22:01 PM EST

Wow what a groovy open thread (none / 0)

this is a very nice open thread. the chances of our questions ever making it to the candidates, are just about zero. be it as it may - here are mine

1. What, in your view, is the solution to the Iraq problem (ie, partitioning, etc.) ?

2. Will you decrease the power of the presidency, as it has been expanded by Cheney and Rumsfeld and the Patriot act? Will you restore it to its proper constitutional role?

3. If elected, will you start your own blog and write the entries yourself, and allow comments?

Thanks in advance!


.. and when I win the lottery, gonna donate half my money to the city so they have to name a school or a park after me - camper van beethoven
by heyAnita on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 10:57:32 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Assuming you've already got enough about health care.

1. What should be done about the pension guarantee program, and it's critical underfunding, and the way it is abused by corporations breaking contracts with their longterm employees?

2. Aside from magically solving the Iraq problem, how would you rebuild America's image/respect in the world?

3. Would you support a significant increase in the gas tax? If not, how would you effectively reduce carbon emissions and stimulate new technology? If so, how would you protect the working class who will be hit the hardest, by this regressive tax?

4. What do you think is the appropriate top tax rate?

5. Is there a problem with intellectual property law in this country, and if so, what things could be done to address it?

6. Do you support agricultural subsidies, and if so, how do you suggest changing them to avoid impoverishing developing world farmers while enriching ADM?

7. Do you support fast track?

8. What is a president's most important job? (shaping policy, inspiring the nation, negotiating with other countries, appointing judges?)

9. How much should a public school teacher be paid? Is there anyway the president can affect that?

10. What are the major problems with our electoral system, how would/could you change them as president?

Sorry, i got a little carried away. these are more the debate questions I might like to hear, but don't ever expect to.


by jujube on Fri Mar 23, 2007 at 11:26:44 PM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Why do we have a separate, broken medical care system for veterans?  What is so different about trauma care and post-treatment follow-up for combat injuries from auto accidents, shootings, stabbings and industrial accidents? Why shouldn't veterans just have the same  universal, single-payer health insurance as nonveterans?  Co-payments could be waived for treatment for injuries due to active military duty.


by bdungan on Sat Mar 24, 2007 at 12:12:48 AM EST

Question For Any Or All Of The Candidates (none / 0)


QUESTION: During the Anthrax scare Canada temporarily bypassed patent laws and ordered production of a generic version of Cipro because of a public emergency. With much of the U.S. population lacking access to affordable prescription medicines would it be possible for the President of the United States to do something similar for those who are in life and death health situations such as cancer patients?    
BlueSunbelt.Com Netroots for the Sunbelt states robwire.com My personal blog
by robliberal on Sat Mar 24, 2007 at 02:27:10 AM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Why should Hillary apologize?  Because a handful of people who despise her are demanding it?

She is fully aware of the trap the netroots are trying to lay for her.  Give it up.  It didn't work.  You didn't "get her" and 90 percent of the dems across the country don't care anyway.  They want the war to end as soon as possible in the best way possible.

Case closed.


by marasaud on Sat Mar 24, 2007 at 05:12:58 AM EST

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

What trap?  Are we witnessing another episode of "Everyone's Out to Get Us?"  starring Hillary and Bill?  By time the next President takes office, we will have lived through 8 years of BUSH HELL... and one of the biggest irritants of Bush is the fact HE WON'T ADMIT WHEN HE IS WRONG and WON'T APOLOGIZE FOR HIS FUCKUPS...  And I see the same irritable stubborness in HRC... If I remember correctly Stephanopolis's book talks about how her stubborness sometimes made the situation worse for Bill (because she would convince him to deny instead of coming out and just being straight forward).  While her policies aren't the same as Bush's, I don't want to live another 4 years with a President who refuses to take responsibility for their actions, with a President who is willing to get us into a war despite the fact that most of the other countries in the world thought it was wrong AND said the intelligence wasn't convincing enough.  

She needs to apologize; that is a moral value issue to me.  And you are right, she leads now... but there is still 9 months and she is not way ahead while all other rivals are in single digits... There are two candidates within strinking distance who can raise as much or just less than she can.  Her candidacy isn't inevitable as you like to pretend it is... but keep thinking it is... the less her supporters work to get her elected the less chance she will.


by yitbos96bb on Sat Mar 24, 2007 at 09:30:07 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Questions for the Presidential Candidates (none / 0)

Q: Do you see Bush history repeating itself (Iraq)
now Iran: what are you doing to stop the Iran war?

http://www.stopiranwar.com

http://bellaciao.org/en/article.php3?id_ article=14589
Excerpt

March 23, 2007

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has canceled a planned visit to the United Nations, and Tehran's U.N. ambassador, Javad Zarif, on Friday blamed a delay in U.S. visas being issued to the crew of his airplane.

Ahmadinejad wanted to speak to the U.N. Security Council before a vote, scheduled for Saturday, on sanctions against Iran.

Iran, which contends the proposed sanctions are politically motivated, says it will still try to get high-level representation to the U.N. -- most likely the foreign minister.


by dearreader on Sat Mar 24, 2007 at 04:14:20 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.