2008: What's in a logo?

(cross-posted at Daily Kos)

Over at Daily Kos' Diary Rescue last night, a rescued diary about each individual candidate's website made me think about the Internet aspect of each Democratic campaign. Tonight, I'd just like to get everyone's thoughts on what they think of each campaign's logo to date. Below the fold, I'll post each individual campaign's logo, and I'd like to solicit everyone's thoughts as to what they think about them. This is usually an aspect of any political campaign that tends to be overlooked, but in 2008, I think there's one candidate who takes full advantage of a logo's simplicity to create a powerful symbol.

Senator Joe Biden

Senator Hillary Clinton

Senator Chris Dodd

Former Senator John Edwards

Former Senator Mike Gravel

Representative Dennis Kucinich

Senator Barack Obama

Governor Bill Richardson

Former Governor Tom Vilsack

As usual, the logos are colored in red, white, in blue; only John Edwards deviates, adding a green trail to the shooting star beneath his name. Aside from that, though, many of the campaign logos aren't particularly eye-catching. Dennis Kucinich's logo, to me, is by far the worst. Chris Dodd employs a simple blue-and-white scheme. It looks a bit stately, perhaps a reflection on his 26 years of service in the Senate. Hillary Clinton's logo seems like the prototypical image that is projected by presidential campaigns, with the notable exception being that she refers to herself by her first name.

The one logo that stands out, though, is Barack Obama's. The rest aren't that special; they integrate the traditional colors of the American flag, oftentimes employing the flag itself as a backdrop, into the logo. Obama, though, has found a new way of bringing to life the most visual aspect of any political campaign outside of the candidate themselves. The red-and-white stripes in the bottom half of the 'O' come from the American flag, but transposing it above a clear blue sky and a rising sun evokes the kind of imagery that jibes well with Obama's theme of beginning anew. The symbolism is difficult to miss, and it gives people an easy, positive mental association by which they can remember the senator. If anything, Obama's campaign will probably change the kinds of designs that we will see in future presidential campaigns due to his team's fresh, sleek, sophisticated logo.

In all, this is a rather trivial matter. People should base their decisions for who to vote for on other issues of far greater importance than a campaign logo. Nevertheless, political campaigns are essentially the marketing of a person to the American public, and a simple visual reminder, when utilized properly, can serve a small but important purpose.


Poll
Which 2008 Democratic candidate has the best logo?
Joe Biden
Hillary Clinton
Chris Dodd
John Edwards
Mike Gravel
Dennis Kucinich
Barack Obama
Bill Richardson
Tom Vilsack

Votes: 28
Results : Vote Link : Polls

Display:


Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

For some reason, Vilsack's logo scares me. Otherwise, they all have good logos. Obama's logo is really cool.


by jfoster on Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 10:22:38 PM EST

Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

Obama definitely has the coolest logo. Most of them are pretty professional though.


by PhillyGuy on Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 11:02:47 PM EST

Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

I like Edwards logo the best. Obamas is smooth also.


by puresmoke on Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 12:34:43 AM EST

The Logo Question (none / 0)

I think these are pretty interesting.  Thanks for posting them.

The surprising one, I think, is Hillary Clinton's.  Her campaign has made a decision, I guess, understandably, to soften her image by simply putting her first name, Hillary, on the bumperstickers and logo. This may have been a long, contentious decision by the campaign (though, probably, it had a lot of polling behind it).  

I had been under the impression for some time now, that the Clinton campaign wanted her to be known as "Senator Clinton."  (This makes some sense:  arguably, she is entitled to this title of respect that comes from being elected a United States Senator.)  So for example, supporters of hers have been known to criticize others for being sexist when they simply refer to her as "Hillary" and not Senator Clinton.

But...with this logo decision by her campaign to explicitly refer to her as simply "Hillary," well, no one can really be faulted for thereafter, referring to her as simply "Hillary."  Hillary Clinton's campaign wants her to be known as "Hillary."  Okay. Maybe the idea is to remind everyone that there is a female name running...and...maybe, she wants female voters to be reminded of that on a daily basis (with bumperstickers).  I wonder...did Carol Mosely Braun simply have "Carol for President in 2004?"  

As for Obama, I think his orb is definitely original, and potentially ground-breaking.  But, as much as I am intrigued by it, I do wonder if it is just a tad bit too mysterious and intimidating, particularly to older voters.  It looks cool and hip, but do all the voters in America want to be cool and hip?  Not really. If he is going to win the nomination, he needs more than just the cool and the hip voters.  He needs more than the IPOD vote.  He needs to be careful with this.

Vilsack's seems strangely frightening.  Dodd's is too plain.  Kucinich's is awful.  Biden's is passable.  And Richardson's just looks like something out of Texas, or perhaps the general Southwest. He needs to communicate "national" if he wants to have a chance of winning...unless...of course, he is running for the VP spot.

Edwards' logo directly suggests that his candidacy is akin to a magical shooting star (an organic shooting star?)  Only time will tell if Edwards' logo is apt, or merely a wish upon a star.


by Demo37 on Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 01:21:39 AM EST

Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

Interesting to note Senator Obama's is the only one with an URL.


by Shaun Appleby on Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 07:14:58 AM EST

Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

Obama's logo reminds me of the Bank of America logo.


by johnny longtorso on Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 08:18:17 AM EST

Re: 2008: What's in a logo? (none / 0)

Happy President's Day. Today I am rolling out critiques of the various 2008 presidential contenders. Starting off with Obama `08 on my blog.
<http://drawmark.squarespace.com/journal/2007/2/19/the-logo-campaign.html>
Drawmark http://www.drawmark.com http://drawmark.squarespace.com
by Drawmark on Mon Feb 19, 2007 at 09:15:57 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.