While Illinois', and the Nation's, Veterans Suffer, Obama Campaigns [UPDATED]

Illinois' disabled veterans are at "rock bottom" -- "dead last" -- in benefits and claims processing of applications for disability. But Illinois' veterans take a back seat because their junior senator is running for president.  And that senator, Barack Obama, has missed an astonishing number of hearings and meetings of the Senate Veterans committee.

Obama is nothing if not audacious in touting his veterans committee membership as contributing to his "foreign policy" experience for the presidency, while his own state's veterans suffer.  The Chicago Sun-Times ran a devastating investigative series in 2004-2005 (see Truthout) that showed that Illinois' veterans rank last, or near-last (depends on the graph) in disability awards of the 50 states and Puerto Rico (Illinois average:  $6,961; New Mexico average: $12,004). The New York Times's 2007 article shows Illinois' disabled soldiers are still waiting over two years later: "Illinois, which has deployed the sixth-highest number of soldiers of any state, has the second-largest backlog."

Sen. Obama admitted he didn't know anything about problems at Walter Reed before the WaPo's shattering series. And Sen. Obama has missed KEY votes for disabled veterans -- including a measure that would create "common disability ratings."

Obama claimed that veterans committee was "one of my first priorities." He said, "One of my first priorities was obtaining a seat on the Veterans Committee...And the thing that I pledged when I was sworn in as the Senator was that if nothing else in the first couple of years in the Senate, I could make absolutely certain that there would have been a strong advocate in the United States Senate," at a Veterans Town Hall Meeting, May 23, 2005.

But Obama has skipped 19 of 37 VA committee meetings in the 109th congress. Obama's attendance record was the second worst of all Democrats on the committee. He attended just 18 of the committee's 37 meetings in Washington D.C.

On the campaign trail, Obama stresses the importance of providing "the best care" for veterans and their families: "Providing the best care for our service members, veterans and their families is one thing about this war we can still get right."

  • But Sen. Obama has continually skipped hearings on the veterans budget. Chairman Craig opened a hearing Obama missed and said, "we will consider today ... legislation touching on veterans insurance, housing, burial, compensation, and employee benefits." Obama also missed all four committee hearings in a series that focused on the President's proposed 2007 budget for the Department of Veterans Affairs. Ranking Senator Akaka noted during the hearings that "we must learn a lesson from last year's budget crisis and do everything we can to ensure that veterans and their family members have access to health care and benefits they have earned."   (From the GPO on 6/23/05, 2/28/06, 3/2/06, 3/7/06, March 9, 2006.)

Obama stresses the importance of veterans health care:  "Long as there are wounded service members receiving substandard medical care, we have failed in our duty to honor the commitment of the brave men and women who chose to serve. We must provide our returning heroes and their families with every resource they need to rebuild their lives," Obama said in a press release on April 10, 2007.

  • But Obama skipped a hearing about expanding veterans' health services. Craig opened, "We also have legislation before us to specifically address the demand for long-term care. As the veteran population ages, the demand for long-term care has increased accordingly." Akaka added that the committee would consider legislation that would encourage "creative ways to help alleviate the burden on caregivers while expanding services to veterans." (From the GPO, May 11, 2006.)
  • Obama also skipped a hearing to create insurance benefits for veterans in rehabilitation. Craig announced that the committee would "hear testimony about the traumatically injured protection under service members' group life insurance benefit." Akaka declared that "this insurance program helps ease the financial burden" on a hospitalized service member's family. (From the GPO on September 7, 2006.)

In another press release, in May 2007, Obama pledged to provide the "best treatment for our service members": He said, "Providing the best treatment for our service members is one thing about this war we can still get right."

  • But Obama skipped the hearing on improving veterans' health care access. "In many cases, VA's facilities are located where veterans used to live, not where they now live," noted Chairman Craig. The legislation under consideration was "designed in part to address the changes in the demographics of our veterans' population and follows America's medicine's transformation from hospital-centric to patient-centric delivery of care."  (From the GPO on April 6, 2006.)
  • Sen. Obama also missed an "exceedingly important" nomination hearing for the VA's Undersecretary for Health. "Dr. Perlin [has been nominated] to serve as VA's Under Secretary for Health," announced Chairman Craig. "This is an exceedingly important position. The Under Secretary, in effect, serves as CEO of the VA's entire health care system, the largest integrated health care system in the United States. Dr. Perlin, this is a big, big, big job." (From the GPO on April 7, 2005.)

Sen. Obama Has Skipped Important Votes For Veterans in the U.S. Senate

  • Sen. Obama missed the vote to eliminate requirement that severance pay be deducted from disability compensation: Obama did not vote for the Levin, D-Mich., amendment No. 2019 to the Levin substitute amendment No. 2011.

    (The Levin amendment would establish a Defense Department and Veterans Affairs Interagency Program Office to implement a joint electronic health record system and eliminate the current requirement that severance pay be deducted from disability compensation for disabilities incurred in a combat zone. It would authorize $50 million for the treatment and rehabilitation of service members with traumatic brain injury or post-traumatic stress disorder and create common disability ratings to determine those eligible for care. The substitute would authorize $648.3 billion for defense programs in fiscal 2008, including $127.5 billion for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. It also would authorize $143.5 billion for operations and maintenance; $109.9 billion for procurement; $122.9 billion for military personnel and $74.7 billion for research development, testing and evaluation.

    (The Senate vote results:  #246, Amdt. 2019 to HR 1585, Passed 94-0: R 48-0; D 44-0 (ND 39-0, SD 5-0); I 2-0; 7/12/07; HRC voted yea while Obama did not vote.)

  • Obama missed a vote to provide $109.3 billion in fiscal 2008 for the Department of Veterans Affairs: Obama did not vote for passage of the bill that would provide $109.3 billion in fiscal 2008 for the Department of Veterans Affairs, military construction and military housing. The bill would provide $87.5 billion for the Department of Veterans Affairs, including $37.2 billion for veterans health programs. It would provide $41.2 billion in mandatory spending for veterans' service-connected compensation benefits and pensions. The bill would provide $9.8 billion for military construction, $2.9 billion for military family housing and $8.5 billion for the latest round of base closures. As amended, the bill would provide $100 million in emergency funding for the Homeland Security Department to reimburse state and local law enforcement entities for security and related costs associated with the 2008 presidential candidate nominating conventions. (From Vote 316, HR 2642 (Fiscal 2008 Military Construction-VA Appropriations), Passed 92-1: R 47-1; D 43-0 (ND 39-0, SD 4-0); I 2-0, 9/6/07; HRC voted yea while Obama did not vote.

Walter Reed

  • Obama admitted he did not know of problems at Walter Reed hospital before story was published in Washington Post: "But when asked if he knew, as a member of the Veterans Affairs Committee, about the problems at Walter Reed Hospital before the story was published in the Washington Post, Obama admitted he didn't. He tried to explain: 'People will acknowledge that the medical facility at Walter Reed does great work. Unfortunately, what it turned out was the outpatient facilities were disastrous.'"  -- in the Chicago Sun-Times, June 4, 2007
  • From Washington Times editorial (Yes, it's the Washington Times, but remember that this is exactly what the GOP would say about Obama in a general election):

    Obama's Walter Reed bill is 'classic scandal legislation which makes the sponsor look good but does little to solve the issue' "The remedies much discussed this week, courtesy of Democratic Sens. Claire McCaskill and Barack Obama, are laughable if they are intended to solve the systemic problems. They are a bandaid on a gaping wound. The senators' call for simplifying paperwork, hiring more caseworkers and improving their training, requiring more oversight from inspectors general, improved reporting to Congress, establishing facility-repair timelines and increasing psychological counseling. It pains us to cry cynical politics because these measures would be worthy and welcome, but they are too small-bore and reactive to make a significant difference. This is classic scandal legislation which makes the sponsor look good but does little to solve the issue."

By the way: What happened to that "laughable" legislation?  Its useful provisions were incorporated by the Armed Services Committee, on which Sen. Hillary Clinton is a highly proactive member and works with her Republican colleagues, into better legislation that passed the Senate.

From The Buffalo News, October 29, 2007:

Besides, throughout the year, Clinton has chosen to be in Washington for big moments far more often than her rival candidates.

On July 12, for example, she cut short a trip to Detroit to return to D.C. to vote on an amendment boosting aid for wounded veterans -- a vote all the other presidential candidates missed.

Sen. Obama hung around at the NAACP convention in Detroit.

However, Sen. Clinton rushed back to Washington, D.C. to vote on the "landmark legislation to improve care for wounded troops and veterans when they return home from battle." (From Sen. Patty Murray's press release, "Murray Lauds Passage Of Senate Wounded Warrior Bill.")

See also: "Obama Talks the Talk, But Where's the Walk?," which reveals that Obama, as chairman of the Subcommittee on European Affairs for the Senate Foreign Relations committee, has not held a single hearing.

There are people who do the work.  Then there are people who just talk.

Screw "hope."  Give me the one who gets it done.



Display:


Re: While Illinois', and the Nation's, Veterans Su (2.00 / 1)

What a bunch of lies. If you go to his website, hit Issues Honoring Our Veterans is listed.  Hit that and this is what you'll see:

As a member of the Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee, Senator Obama is committed to helping the heroes who defend our nation today and the veterans who fought in years past. A grandson of a World War II veteran who went to college on the G.I. Bill, Senator Obama has reached out to Republicans and Democrats in order to honor our commitment to America's veterans.

"We extend our deep gratitude to Senator Barack Obama (D-IL) for catapulting homeless veteran issues onto the Senate agenda by introducing this comprehensive measure."

-National Coalition for Homeless Veterans, Congressional Testimony, March 16, 2006

Sheltering and Rehabilitating Homeless Veterans.

The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) estimates that one in three homeless adult males is a veteran. A total of 400,000 vets experience homelessness over the course of the year. Senator Obama authored legislation to extend and expand critically important programs to stop homelessness among American veterans. Working with Senators Daniel Akaka (D-HI) and Larry Craig (R-ID), he passed legislation to provide comprehensive services and affordable housing options to veterans through the Department of Veterans Affairs, Department of Housing and Urban Development and community organizations.

Fighting for Illinois Veterans' Fair Share of Disability Benefits.

Following reports that veterans in Illinois were receiving less in disability benefits than those nearly anywhere else in the country, Senator Obama led efforts to correct the problems that created these disparities. As a result of his efforts, VA opened an investigation into the matter, agreed to hire more disability claims specialists for the Chicago regional office, and agreed to re-examine the claims of Illinois veterans who felt they had been treated unfairly. Senator Obama worked with Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) to force the VA to notify veterans in Illinois and other states traditionally underserved about their right to seek a review of their past claims. The resulting outreach led to significant numbers of Illinois veterans getting the benefits they deserve.

"After prodding from the Chicago Sun-Times, veterans and Illinois' two U.S. senators, the Veterans Affairs Department is sending out letters to Illinois vets to address the state's 20-year history of ranking at the bottom of the nation for disability benefits. . . . The massive VA outreach -- a total of 326,000 letters -- affects Illinois and five other states with low benefits: Connecticut, Indiana, Michigan, New Jersey and Ohio."

-Chicago Sun-Times, May 9, 2006

"Sen. Barack Obama and Sen. Dick Durbin have been in the forefront, once this problem was exposed by the Sun-Times. . . . What better advocates could vets hope for than Durbin and Obama? Dick Durbin is the Democratic whip, an energetic senator who has done much for the state. Barack Obama is a rising star whose future is limitless. . . . It's about fairness to 1 million Illinois vets, fairness which they have earned and is long overdue."

-Chicago Sun-Times, Editorial, May 30, 2005

Feeding Recovering Wounded Veterans.

Senator Obama introduced an amendment that became law providing food services to wounded service members receiving physical therapy or rehabilitation services at military hospitals. Previously, service members recovering in a military hospital for more than 90 days were required to pay for their own meals.

"Thanks to some hungry G.I.'s and a U.S. senator, some wounded soldiers will no longer have to dig into their own pockets to pay for their meals at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, D.C."

-Mark Benjamin, Salon.com, May 13, 2005

"Particularly for those young men and women who have been severely wounded or disabled in the war on terrorism, it is only fitting, proper and fair that they should not have to pay for inpatient or outpatient meals at military facilities."

-Mike Duggan, Deputy Director for National Security, The American Legion

Treating Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)

In 2005, the Department of Veterans Affairs announced it would contact veterans with severe PTSD and ask them to prove that they deserved their disability payments. This review of disability claims was highly disruptive to veterans still suffering serious health effects from their military service. Senator Obama fought this review. He and Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) passed legislation to limit it and helped publicly pressure the agency to finally abandon the effort in November of 2005.

Senator Obama also worked with Senator Bill Frist (R-TN) to pass an amendment ensuring that all service members returning from Iraq are properly screened for Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI). TBI is being called the signature injury of the Iraq war. The blast from improvised explosive devices can jar the brain, causing bruising or permanent damage. Concussions can have huge health effects including slowed thinking, headaches, memory loss, sleep disturbance, attention and concentration deficits, and irritability.

"We are very concerned about the injuries caused by improvised explosive devices, especially the Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI). TBI is fast becoming a major problem for many veterans. We urge the Senate to adopt an amendment sponsored by Senator Barack Obama and Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist to add TBI to the list of post-deployment physical and mental health screenings for soldiers returning home from the Iraq and Afghanistan wars."

-Bobby Muller, Director of Veterans for America

Easing the Transition of New Veterans into Society

In September 2006, Senator Obama introduced the Lane Evans Veterans Health and Benefits Improvement Act, which would help veterans transition from the Pentagon health system to the VA system by extending the window in which new veterans can get mental health care from two years to five years. The Lane Evans bill would improve transition services for members of the National Guard and Reserves. It also would require the VA and the Department of Defense to work together to track new veterans entering the VA for better budget planning and monitoring of emerging health trends.

Senator Obama passed an amendment that became law requiring the Defense Department to report to Congress on the delayed development of an electronic medical records system compatible with the VA's electronic medical records system. DOD's delay in developing such a system has created obstacles for service members transitioning into the VA health care system.

"(The electronic health records) amendment is a first step in easing the transition of a service member's medical records from DoD to the VA when a service member is discharged."

-Veterans for America


by Piuma on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:24:32 PM EST

Re: While Illinois', and the Nation's, Veterans Su (2.00 / 2)

You are reinforcing the point that Obama is a show-horse on veterans issues. Yes, as you can see from his website Obama leaps into action when a newspaper points out how he has let his state down, but once the paper loses interest so does Obama. Two years "after prodding from the Chicago Sun-Times" Illinois is still at the bottom on disability benefits, according to the NY Times piece linked in the diary.

If Obama bothered to show up for votes, or his committee assignments, or bothered to convene his subcommittee, maybe he would have accomplished something.


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:37:13 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Veterans (2.00 / 2)

That's it in a nutshell.  

And, by the way, I found this research depressing.  Because I like Obama.  Who can't like him?  But he needs EIGHT more years in the Senate, during which time he can prove his work ethic and learn the Senate rules (which his Senate colleagues criticize him for not doing yet), and pass some heavy-duty legislation.  He is young enough to run again -- and will have more experience when he does.


by susanhu on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:41:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

That is NEW since last night (2.00 / 2)

None of that on disabled veterans was on his page last night.  Freaky.  I looked through the page carefully last night.  It just got added.


by susanhu on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:43:36 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: That is NEW since last night (none / 0)

Bullshit.  And he talked about Veterans and the problem in Illinois is specific in his town hall speech at Ames this weekend which is probably still on the CSPAN site if you really are so concerned.


by Piuma on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:46:24 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: That is NEW since last night (none / 0)

No, this has been on the website for months.


by Obama08 on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 03:49:06 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: That is NEW since last night (none / 0)

I looked hard last night.  However, I've updated the diary to indicate he does have the information on his site, but that I did not see it, which I maintain.


by susanhu on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:02:02 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: That is NEW since last night (none / 0)

Since I cannot verify that I am correct, I am removing that paragraph.  The rest stands.


by susanhu on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:05:09 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I couldn't agree more (2.00 / 1)

I never understood the "politics of hope" nonsense.  Give me someone who gets the job done.  That makes perfect sense.


ABO... Anybody but Obama. I LIKE the democratic party.

by MollieBradford on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:11:29 PM EST

Re: While Illinois', and the Nation's, Veterans Su (none / 0)

I'm an Illinois resident, a veteran and I hang with activists on veterans issues.

The VA was screwing Illinois veterans back when Obama was a state legislator, and probably before that.

The extent to which the VA has been rejecting claims based on bad-faith rulings has only been revealed recently, since Obama has been in office, IIRC.

I'm not going to give Obama more credit than he deserves. The Iraq War probably caused the media and politicians to scrutinize this longstanding problem.

But blaming the problem on Obama is goofy.


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:12:39 PM EST

Re: While Illinois', and the Nation's, Veterans Su (2.00 / 2)

The diary doesn't claim that the situation is Obama's fault, just that he has been singularly ineffective at rectifying it even while in a position to do so. And despite having claimed "One of my first priorities was obtaining a seat on the Veterans Committee."


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:29:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

have accomplished even less in the Senate than Obama, who has accomplished more (than Edwards and HRC) in less time.

If voters were looking for candidates who got shit done, Biden and Richardson would be leading the pack.


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:42:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (2.00 / 1)

You really don't know Clinton's record in the Senate, do you? Her colleagues call her a work horse for a reason, and believe me she takes care of NY.


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:53:32 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (1.00 / 1)

And her big accomplishments are...?

Having colleagues say nice words about her is kinda different than accomplishing anything of note.


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 05:29:35 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

Funding for 9/11 recovery, addressed health issues of 9/11 first responders, SCHIP expansion, IDEA, EFCA, etc. etc.

Look at Alegre's diaries from a few months ago for chapter and verse.


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 06:25:46 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

Are you talking about the S-CHIP expanstion the Democrats quit trying to pass while HRC was on the campaign trail?


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 08:03:19 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

Clinton has been working, with some success, to expand SCHIP since she arrived in the Senate. The issue in this congress is reauthorization, and Clinton has been pushing a number of changes that further expand SCHIP as part of the reauthorization.


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 09:27:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

Does "with some success" mean legislation was passed into law?


Rrrinnggg... Time to change the government.
by Carl Nyberg on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 09:39:17 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Edwards and Clinton (none / 0)

Yes, largely covering interaction with Medicaid, catching more children who slip through the cracks. Not the large expansion envisioned in the 2007 reauthorization.


by souvarine on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 10:12:07 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Maybe if they donated money to Obama (2.00 / 1)

... he'd see that they got taken care of.

Big coal donates to him and he helps take care of them.


by dpANDREWS on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:12:44 PM EST

Re: Maybe if they donated money to Obama (none / 0)

Tell me more about the coal lobby, or give me a link.  Thanks.


by susanhu on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 04:36:25 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Absolute trash. (2.00 / 1)

This shows Obama's voting record when it comes to the well-being of America's military personnel. And he earns a perfect score on the list of Senators who vote in line with progressive positions on that same issue. This diary is a sham.
by PD1769 on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 05:09:04 PM EST

Love it! (2.00 / 1)

Another wonderfully written diary susanhu. Love it!


by lonnette33 on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 05:17:27 PM EST

overheard in an iowan cafe... (none / 0)

female: it's just like hillary to try to ruin the christmas season.

male: yeah, she's a b**.

i have no idea if they are democrats...


"This is the time for resolve and steady leadership" -- Barack Obama
by bored now on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 07:26:25 PM EST

Typical (none / 0)

Obama: oh there is a national emergency - Ok I vote "present."


by moi moi on Thu Dec 20, 2007 at 09:58:02 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.