A Moment of Silence - new law in Illinois

Journal Gazette: A "moment" is about as nonspecific a term for measuring time as, say, a "smidgen" is for delineating distance or a "tad" for calculating volume.

But, that didn't stop the Illinois legislature from passing a measure earlier this month requiring all public schools to observe a daily "moment of silence," without defining exactly how long these so-called moments should last.

Such ambiguities in the modified Silent Reflection and Student Prayer Act -- which previously permitted such periods of quiet on a voluntary basis.

Praying is usually done within one's own thoughts.  Rarely, unless you are in a church or by your bedside or in a prayer group, do you speak your prayer out loud.  Asking for `special' individual time during the school day sounds a bit ridiculous to me.

I'm sure I'm going to get a lot of complaints for saying that; but seriously folks, how many times do you remember sitting at your desk in school, day dreaming, thinking about your boy/girl friend, thinking about going on recess to play or going to lunch, or simply just caught yourself starring at the wall?  How many times have you been caught writing notes to friends or drawing pictures on the back of your notepad or text messaging your friends?

At any given "moment" a person can say a pray to themselves.  A person doesn't need a `special' time of day to do this.  That's like saying you can only day dream at 10:20 A.M. every day, for one minute.

One day soon, I'm sure we'll hear about the Illinois legislature designating that a student can have this "moment" anytime during the day in which they "need" one.  I can see the students now.  They're bored with class so they interrupt the instructor to say something like, "I've a need to pray".

Give me a break.

The real reason for this special "moment" is to slowly bring back open prayer to schools.  Do I think this is wrong?  No.  But at least be honest about your intentions.

Coonsey's View
Political Blog and Forum
http://www.freewebs.com/coonsey/

Currently looking for amateur writers willing to write, for free, columns/posts for our site. Preferably Conservative or Moderates.



Display:


Re: A Moment of Silence - new law in Illinois (none / 0)

At least this is  one thing that can't be blamed on Blagojevich. He vetoed it, and the state legislature passed it over his veto.


by Baltimore on Sat Oct 27, 2007 at 02:34:49 PM EST

Re: A Moment of Silence - new law in Illinois (none / 0)

You need not worry about the legislature either expanding the moment of silence to other parts of the day or doing any actual post-enactment evaluation.  Probably, no legislators ever bothered to visit any classrooms across a spectrum of grade levels and socioeconomic backgrounds to see how their moment of silence would be actually implemented.

In Texas public schools, each day starts with the US pledge, the Texas pledge (to which the legislature added "God" effective this school year), and the moment of silence.  The pledges are broadcast over a p.a. system or a c.c. TV system with either adults or kids leading the pledges.  Regardless of the format, kids know they basically have a free pass during the pledges to not participate, to yell, and to race through the pledges and to diddle during the moment of silence by doing things like shuffling papers at their desks.  This is just another part of the day when disrespectful behavior by students is tolerated.

So-called "reforms" like NCLB don't address why one of the main purposes of school is to warehouse young people or what will be the consequences for children and parents who don't behave in a civil manner.


by bdungan on Sat Oct 27, 2007 at 06:05:24 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.