LA Times: GOP Estate Tax/Minimum Wage Bill will Die in Senate

Last night, the Republican House passed legislation giving Paris Hilton and other wealthy heirs a massive tax cut while also increasing the minimum wage, a move that, according to The Hotline, has caused deep resentment among some Senate Republicans including finance chair Chuck Grassley, who felt "stabbed in the back." And as a result of this bad blood -- as well as, of course, the fact that the bill was poorly written and the two measures have no business being tied together -- the tax cut/minimum wage legislation passed by the House is likely to falter in the Senate, report Joel Havemann and Noam N. Levey for the Los Angeles Times.

The hastily crafted measure almost certainly will die in the Senate, a prospect that several Republican lawmakers acknowledged even as they prepared to cast votes.

[...]

"These are wonderful accomplishments: House Republicans showing results for the American people," said Rep. Deborah Pryce (R-Ohio), the fourth-ranking Republican in the House. "We didn't want to leave for August without accomplishing both of these."

I'm not quite sure if Deborah Pryce's definition of "accomplishments" and "results" are the same as mine or those of the American people. When Americans say that they want something to get done, as they have on the minimum wage with 85 percent favoring a more than $2 per hour increase, they want it done, not just symbolically passed during the dead of night by legislators who know that their proposal will never actually be enacted into law. Short of actually increasing the minimum wage, this is just a hollow jesture that should not buttress Republicans from the attack that they do not care one lick about working class Americans, particularly those who have to live on the minimum wage.

Americans want to see Congress actually do its job rather than waste time posturing for elections. And given the Republican propensity to put electoral politics above the business of this country (trying to pass a flag burning amendment instead of balancing the budget, trying to ban gay marriage instead of dealing with the situation in Iraq, etc.), playing political games with the minimum wage instead of actually increasing it isn't going to go far in convincing voters that they need to fire the Do Nothing Republican Congress.



Display:


Re: LA Times: GOP Crooks (none / 0)

That's what i'm talking about. I think to these men, the "group who lives on minimum wage" is imaginary. They don't really exist! These "working poor" that Bush has claimed he "just doesn't understand" are nothing but a device invented by the Devious Left. So why truly consider their lives and what it's like to wish you had money to buy your children the things they long for and need?

Disgusting.

"Representatives."


Dust in the wind. All we are is dust in the divine, flatulent wind.
by Nezua Limon Xoloquinta Jonez on Sat Jul 29, 2006 at 02:05:54 PM EST

This is such a gift for the campaign (none / 0)

"Republicans would only agree to give working people a tiny raise if they also could give multi-millionaires' kids more millions."


John Edwards 2008
by MeanBoneII on Sat Jul 29, 2006 at 03:12:07 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: This is such a gift for the campaign (3.00 / 1)

Yes, that part will endear the GOP to the Working Poor. It just shows that they really do care about children, you know?


Dust in the wind. All we are is dust in the divine, flatulent wind.
by Nezua Limon Xoloquinta Jonez on Sat Jul 29, 2006 at 03:51:23 PM EST
[ Parent ]

It's just politics as usual (none / 0)

Golly Moses, naturally they're punks!

When Jonathan writes

this is just a hollow jesture that should not buttress Republicans from the attack that they do not care one lick about working class Americans, particularly those who have to live on the minimum wage.

the GOP reply is, What's your point?

(And, perhaps, There really ought to be a word 'jesture'.

Kidding.)

With all the experience we have of pols in general, and the current Congressional majority in particular, last night's shenanigans can surely come as a surprise to no one around here.

Dem should be rejoicing at what looks like a nasty knife-fight between the House and Senate GOP, with more to come.

And at the prospect that the monstrous estate tax giveaway won't be happening this Congress.

As for the minimum wage hike - no one was expecting that to be enacted, were they?

Plus - we still, at last count, have the Hoyer Amendment in the text of the Labor appropriations bill. Not much hope there, but some.

I wonder at times whether some lefties have altogether too short a planning horizon: failing a 1994-scale earthquake, nothing very much is going to happen for a long time.

Not in 07, or 09, or 11; perhaps after the 2010 Census redistricting - providing that the Dems' prep (including necessary victories in lege and gov races) has been first class - perhaps not even then.

My understanding of American political history is that reform comes in spurts after disasters; between times, things are pretty much fallow.

Which is paradoxical: if things are going OK (as they have been under Clinton and, for many, even under Bush), there's just not the pressure on pols to take the risks which radical reform entails.

If the shit hits the fan (with a deep recession, say), the folks that liberals want to help with reforms are the ones who get it in the neck first and most.

Politics, like life, is something of a bitch.


by skeptic06 on Sat Jul 29, 2006 at 02:49:56 PM EST

Clowning Around (none / 0)

this is just a hollow jesture
I think you mean it's a hollow gesture from a hall of jesters, right?


by Paul Rosenberg on Sun Jul 30, 2006 at 12:51:08 AM EST

Re: Clowning Around (none / 0)

George W. Bush: I call upon all Congressmen to do everything they can to stop these corporate exploiters. Thank you.

[George W. Bush brandishes a golf club]

George W. Bush: Now, watch this jesture.


by billybob on Sun Jul 30, 2006 at 06:15:56 PM EST
[ Parent ]

LA Times: GOP Estate Tax/Minimum Wage Bill (none / 0)

I think that one of the few positive outcomes of having today's GOP in control of government for so long (and of course so egregiously)--in addition to almost singlehandedly causing the rebirth of the progressive movement (and by extension the Democratic party)--is that it is slowly forcing everyday Americans to finally wake up out of their 25+ year political apathy (and simultaneous retreat into their own sheltered little Reageanesque worlds), and actually start paying attention to, thinking and caring about politics--because, duh, it actually affects their lives in serious and profound ways. This is still very much a process in the making--Americans are still far from being as politically engaged as they once were or need to be again. But I think that it's finally happening, and that we have today's GOP to thank for it. You can only trust someone blindly or be oblivious to them for so long before you finally realize that they've been robbing you blind all these years.

American is finally getting its wakeup call. It's called today's GOP.


by kovie on Sun Jul 30, 2006 at 03:50:57 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.