Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political Dissenters

Arnold Schwarzenegger likes to fashion himself as a moderate, but there's nothing much moderate about spying on political dissenters. But according to Peter Nicholas of the Los Angeles Times, this is exactly what the state of California has been doing under Schwarzenegger's Republican administration.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's office in charge of protecting California against terrorism has tracked demonstrations staged by political and antiwar groups, a practice that senior law enforcement officials say is an abuse of civil liberties.

The Times obtained reports prepared for the state Office of Homeland Security in recent months that contain details on the whereabouts and purpose of a number of political demonstrations throughout California.

For some time we have known about these types of activities in the Golden State. In March one of my professors at Pomona College, John Seery, reported at The Huffington Post that members of the L.A. County Sheriff's Department/F.B.I. Joint Task Force on Terrorism had shaken down a professor of Venezuelan descent after having appeared on CNN talking about Hugo Chavez.

But what we did not previously know was the extent of this program -- that the state of California under Arnold Schwarzenegger's watch had a concerted effort to spy on citizens with whom it didn't agree politically.

Schwarzenegger is in some serious trouble these days. His poll numbers aren't terribly good. His campaign was just fined more than $200,000 by the California Fair Political Practices Commission. Now, news that his government was spying on Californians -- including people who attended a rally at which Rep. George Miller spoke. If things continue to move in this direction, it's going to be increasingly difficult for Schwarzenegger to defeat Democratic nominee Phil Angelides this fall.



Display:


Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

Schwarzenegger's aide may have denied the knowledge of the program, but the story seems to indicate that the Office of Homeland Security -- even if it was funded by the feds -- was under Schwarzenegger, not Lockyer.


My Direct Democracy
by Jonathan Singer on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 06:27:18 PM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

Sgt Schultz defense doesn't cut it, not in the age of "trust me (not)".  His crib, his responsibility.  He sets the tone, he sets the policies.  CHP is a direct line to him I believe. So let him denounce the policy and fire the brass, or say nothing and validate it.  OF course CHP may tell their side, maybe a little story about how he was in the loop but on the basis of deniablity which is precisely the kind of thing this creep would love.  Shcrivernegger considers himself this really cool operator.

I went to a lot of those anti war protests and I have to tell you there were a lot of cameras and it always creeps me out to see them, ever since the sixties.


You're nobody...until you've been banned at dkos because you had an original thought or spoke truth to power.
by NorCalJim on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 06:41:12 PM EST

Lockyear and Arnold not buds, but still... (none / 0)

Anybody who tells us the Governor doesn't know what the State DHS and Highway Patrol are doing in his state is asking for us to undertake that critical suspension of disbelief that makes science fiction, international intrigue thrillers and detective stories interesting.

If he doesn't know, he's as dumb as as a fire hydrant (or GW Bush).  Unadmirable, yes.  Unintelligent, no.

Someone explain exactly why who is attending George Miller political events isn't something that Arnold wouldn't care about?  

There aren't many turnip trucks in Portland to fall off of - or many in CA either.  

In these times, when some evidence indicates wrongdoing, then it is best to assume the worst.  As the pest control folks say: If you see one cockroach in your house, then assume you have more than a thousand and maybe a million.


"Pay any price, bear any burden"
by JimPortlandOR on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 08:54:09 PM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (3.00 / 1)

I had to note that Dennis Mosher registered just for this purpose -- just to argue that the buck doesn't stop with the CEO of California, and trying to pin this on a Democrat.  

And when Mr. Schwarzenegger tries to take credit for something good that happened on his watch, I have to trust that Mr. Mosher will be back, arguing that he had nothing to do with that, either, and that it's really the Democrats who should get credit for those good things as well.

No?  Not?

Incidentally, Mr. Mosher's predictably Republican "no command responsibility" talking point is also factually incorrect.  From testimony to the U.S. Senate, by the current Director of the California Office of Homeland Security:

The California Office of Homeland Security was established in the Office of the Governor by Executive Order.  The Office is charged with developing and coordinating a comprehensive state strategy that includes prevention, preparedness, response and recovery. It is responsible for coordinating homeland security activities throughout California. Under this Executive Order, all state agencies and departments are directed to cooperate with the OHS. Some of the key state partners include the Office of Emergency Services, the State Military Department, the California Department of Justice, the California Highway Patrol, Department of Health Services, the Department of Food and Agriculture, and the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA).

OHS is an administrative agency created and run entirely by Schwarzenegger.  He appointed the current head of OHS.  OHS's screwups are his screwups.


by jsw on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 09:59:18 PM EST

Smackdowns (none / 0)

You've just got to love well delivered smackdowns in blogtopia (yes, we know, skippy did indeed coin the phrase!).


543,895 votes
by Michael Bersin on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 10:11:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

The same "Ahnold" who had the street dug up so he could personally fill in the pothole? Yup. Give us a friggin break!


by blues on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 10:12:55 PM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger (none / 0)

Mommy, make some popcorn.

Bit of a box, I'd say for AS. It is either:

a) Adolf Schrivernegger bringing to California the reprehensible practices of his Vaterland and his SS Poppa, or

b) Gov Sgt Schultznegger ("I know nothing...NOTHIHHHINK"), a carboard cutout buffoon who knows absolutley nothing about what goes on in his so-called administration because he's a stupid bodybuilder who is little more than PR representative of a cabal culled from former Republican governors.

He appears to be going for "b".


You're nobody...until you've been banned at dkos because you had an original thought or spoke truth to power.
by NorCalJim on Sat Jul 01, 2006 at 11:38:48 PM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (3.00 / 2)

Republican schmibertarians are a dime a dozen in the blogosphere.  Witness Glenn Reynolds.  

An actual libertarian would actually be worried about the violation of civil liberties, not leaping to the defense of the Republican Governor who appointed the Director and who retains within the Governor's Office the apparatus that said Director runs.  Schwarzenegger chose the leaders of the OHS, Schwarzenegger is responsible for their programs and their accidents.

Again, "no command responsibility" is a Republican talking point, not a libertarian one.  See, e.g., Jim Henley and Arthur Silber.


by jsw on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 12:09:44 AM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

And Uncle Adolf had a big influence on yours.

After all he didn't even know the SS was killing Jews.  He knew nothink, I tell you, nothink!

If AS didn't know what was going on then he is incompetent.  I actually think he did.  Agency heads in California don't freelance on anything as consequential and sensitive without a  political OK. That is in their job descriptions. This was not some lower level cop on a beat.  This concerns the mission of the depaartment.


You're nobody...until you've been banned at dkos because you had an original thought or spoke truth to power.
by NorCalJim on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 02:08:52 AM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

Was Nixon ultimately responsible for watergate?  Why shucks no, you claim.  The plumbers were outsiders, hired men, consultants if you will.

So you are saying that professional time was used and paid for and work product was developed but it wasn't asked for, and the guy who didn't ask for it was just doing it for fun and he wasn't asked to produce it. Prove it.

Mr Mosher has never worked for the government, where the details of such matters, who does what when & why, are meticulously attended to.


You're nobody...until you've been banned at dkos because you had an original thought or spoke truth to power.
by NorCalJim on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 02:21:18 AM EST

Re: Obama Masthead (none / 0)

My Mommy refers to him as O'Bama.  'cause he's so fuckin' wh... er, uh, Irish.


You're nobody...until you've been banned at dkos because you had an original thought or spoke truth to power.
by NorCalJim on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 02:33:14 AM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying (none / 0)

This has already been reported in both Farenheit 911 and Now on PBS.

If the governor didn't know about it, he's either lying or he's stupid.


by cynicalgirl on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 09:21:18 AM EST

Re: Schwarzenegger Taskforce Spying on Political D (none / 0)

Reading the comments on AS higher up, I just have to wonder if the writers are so hung over this morning that maybe the best thing they could do in the cause of rational discourse is to take a couple of aspirins with a ig glass of water and go back to bed for a few hours.

What a way to spend a sunday morning!


by almostboiledfrog on Sun Jul 02, 2006 at 11:19:12 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.