Carter Delivers Deathblow to Bush's Immigration Bill

Well, sort of.

Suffice it to say that Jimmy Carter isn't the favorite President of most conservatives. In fact, he's probably the least favorite of a lot of the nuttier folk on the right. And it's not as if time has lessened conservatives' visceral hatred of the one-time peanut farmer from Plains, Georgia. Just take a look at CensureCarter.com, a website and television ad campaign funded by Move America Forward aimed at getting Congress to... censure Jimmy Carter.

So with the President struggling to connect with his party's conservative base going into November's midterms and Congressional Republicans seemingly unable to come together on an immigration bill, the last person George W. Bush needs running to his side is the 39th President. But as Doug Gross reports for the AP, this is exactly what Jimmy Carter has done.

Former president Carter, a Democrat and frequent critic of President Bush, sees eye-to-eye with him on immigration.

Carter on Wednesday called the Republican president's commitment to immigration reform "quite admirable," saying he agrees with Bush's support of a system that would eventually grant citizenship to some illegals.

[Let me preface the following with a note that I greatly admire Jimmy Carter, certainly do not believe he was a bad President and immensely respect the work he has done since leaving the White House.]

I can already see the ad right now. Perhaps it was paid for by the Constitution Party, perhaps it was sponsored by the Minutemen, perhaps we never find out who put up the money for the spot. Cue stock footage of Jimmy Carter and George Bush shaking hands. (It would be better if they were hugging, but I'm assuming such footage doesn't exist). Snarky sounding announcer throws some of the tired conservative rhetoric at Jimmy Carter before slamming George W. Bush for aligning with Carter on immigration. The ad runs on Fox News and during the 700 Club -- prime viewing time for the nativist base of the GOP -- and more conservative voters end up staying at home on election day than in any other election in recent memory (even more so than in 2000 voters found out just days before the election about George W. Bush's DUIs).

By no means am I encouraging the Pat Buchanans of the world to make an ad like this; rather, I only mean to say that it is not beyond them to do so. After all, as I noted above, they're currently running television ads calling on Congress to censure Jimmy Carter. So just don't be surprised to see George Bush's face blend into Jimmy Carter's while you're watching television in the not too distant future.



Display:


Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow (1.00 / 0)

And 2008?  Will McCain and Graham have to endure such commercials during the Republican primary?


by illinois062006 on Fri May 26, 2006 at 12:20:35 AM EST

Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow (none / 0)

Jim Gilchrist has already decided that if McCain (or presumably anyone but Tom Tancredo) runs with the nomincation, it's third party time


by Lucas O'Connor on Fri May 26, 2006 at 03:03:41 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow to Bush's Immigratio (none / 0)

Gotta say Singer...it sounds like the logical next step would be for Democrats to do the ads themselves.  Or perhaps, more broadly, to start talking about ways in which Bush is actually liberal.  Not saying that I agree with such a notion, just sayin, that's the first thing I thought of.


by Lucas O'Connor on Fri May 26, 2006 at 03:05:12 AM EST

What a Rovian Idea (none / 0)

No wait, I know...we type up a memo from Hillary's Clinton service in the Texas Air National Guard and then leak it to FOX...

You figured Planet Ailes is desperate for stuff that would damage the Dems. So just make up fake information that looks believable and then watch Brit Hume do his best impression of Dan Rather...


by risenmessiah on Fri May 26, 2006 at 03:36:51 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow to Bush's Immigratio (none / 0)

Shouldn't do it. Because then the GOP pundocracy will rush to our aid, labeling Bush a liberal and saying "look! see what liberals did! Bush sucks! Let's vote the next GOP guy in because he's a REAL conservative!"

Cute someone worse than Bush.


by MNPundit on Fri May 26, 2006 at 04:38:53 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow to Bush's Immigratio (none / 0)

MNPundit is right.

Bush bashing is right in its own sake, but it won't help much in 2008. May I repeat: Bush will not run for president in 2008.

GEORGE Bush, that is.


by GermanDeaniac on Fri May 26, 2006 at 05:34:07 AM EST
[ Parent ]

I beg to differ (3.00 / 0)

The first thing that must be done to the 2008 GOP nominee is tie Bush to him and explain by voting for the GOP nominee you are re-electing Bush, because the GOP nominee supports the same failed ideology and bad policies.

Democrats ran against Hoover until Ike was elected

In 1932 we were attacking the citadel of special privilege and greed. We were fighting to drive the money changers from the temple. Today, in 1948, we are now the defenders of the stronghold of democracy and of equal opportunity, the haven of the ordinary people of this land and not of the favored classes or the powerful few. The battle cry is just the same now as it was in 1932, and I paraphrase the words of Franklin D. Roosevelt as he issued the challenge, in accepting nomination in Chicago: "This is more than a political call to arms. Give me your help, not to win votes alone, but to win in this new crusade to keep America secure and safe for its own people."

Now my friends, with the help of God and the wholehearted push which you can put behind this campaign, we can save this country from a continuation of the 80th Congress, and from misrule from now on.

Republicans ran against President Carter until President Clinton was elected

We tried this -- look, we tried this once before, combining the Democratic Governor of a small southern State with a very liberal Vice President and a Democratic Congress. America does not need Carter II. We do not want to take America back to those days of malaise.

Its an opportunity to push the debate in a left direction, because you get to argue that X will continue the failed discredit policies of George Bush AND you argue for a more left leaning policy.  Let's not waste the opportunity.


"Once in a while you get shown the light In the strangest of places if you look at it right"
by molly bloom on Fri May 26, 2006 at 08:12:03 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Carter Delivers Deathblow to Bush's Immigratio (none / 0)

I wouldn't want to ruin my granpa's good name with those sorts of ads.

:)

Sarah


by Sarah R Carter on Fri May 26, 2006 at 02:57:48 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Overanalysis (none / 0)

I'd call this overanalysis.  I just don't think Carter is quite the bogeyman anong enough people to really influence the immigration bill.  An ad like that would paly very well at a Republican wingnut gathering -- maybe a right wing blog ad campaign -- but not anyewhere else.  This thing is going to rise or fall depending on backroom dealing at this point.  I predict it falls and they pass virtually nothing.


by howardpark on Fri May 26, 2006 at 09:33:08 AM EST

Move America Forward (none / 0)

I love these guys. Way to waste money that could be spent on other conservative causes that might have some impact on 2006.


TAKE BACK OUR PARTY: Democracy Bonds
by LiberalFromPA on Fri May 26, 2006 at 10:50:29 AM EST

They will attack Carter (none / 0)

until Carter agrees with them (now), and then...

"Former President, Nobel laureate, and noted Democrat and Democrat Jimmy the Democrat Carter likes the President's immigration plan. See? We told you he was a uniter".

In retrospect, actually, I must say that Bush is a uniter, not a divider. He has united the country against himself.


by brownsox on Fri May 26, 2006 at 11:03:37 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.