Gallup: Low Approval Ratings "Could Make Republicans Very Vulnerable"

Regardless of questions about Gallup's polling methodology and possible partisan slant, one thing they certainly have going for them is a wealth of data collected over the years to help provide historical context to the current political environment.

In recent weeks, Republicans have been throwing out every possible argument claiming that they are not really in danger of losing control of the House of Representatives this fall. The Democrats don't have any ideas, they claim, despite the fact that the GOP itself can't even come close to creating a positive vision of their own this year. There aren't enough open seats this year, Republicans say, and the Democrats can't possibly knock off enough GOP incumbents to make up their deficit in the chamber, disregarding the fact that there are actually a significant number of GOP open seats -- in competitive districts, no loss. Finally, things aren't so bad, GOP spinmeisters promise. The problem is, Gallup knows they're wrong and has the historical data to prove it.

A recent Gallup Poll, conducted March 13-16, 2006, finds just 27% of Americans approving (and 65% disapproving) of the way Congress is handling its job. Congress' approval rating has been below 30% since October 2005, and the current rating marks the continuation of a slow descent from record-high congressional approval after the Sept. 11 terror attacks.

In fact, the recent ratings of Congress are the worst Gallup has measured in more than a decade. An Oct. 22-25, 1994, Gallup Poll shows 23% of Americans approving of Congress just before a Republican landslide in that year's elections. The lowest approval ratings Gallup has recorded for Congress were 18% in March 1992 and 19% in June 1979.

Not only do the folks at Gallup show that the situation is indeed bad for Republicans by historical standards, they also show evidence of a fairly strong relationship between Congressional approval ratings and election results during midterm elections.

During recent midterm election years, low congressional approval ratings have been associated with greater shifts in the partisan composition of the U.S. House of Representatives. In the five elections since 1974 in which Congress' approval rating was below 40%, the average net change in U.S. House seats from one party to the other was 29. In the three midterm elections in which congressional approval ratings were above 40%, the average change was five seats. [emphasis added]

After nearly 12 years, the American people have seen enough of the Republican House to draw a fairly strong conclusion: they don't like the way the GOP runs things up on Capitol Hill. And if the historical trends prove true this fall -- if the Democrats pick up the average of 29 seats, or even only half of that number -- the United States House of Representatives will be back in Democratic hands come January.



Display:


Demoralized on both sides? (none / 0)

It occurs to me that we may be starting to see demoralization on both sides -- the right is demoralized because every indicator is that they're headed for an ass-whooping, but the left is demoralized because the experiences of 2002 and 2004 have sapped their confidence that they can capitalize on opportunity.  (When/if Bush's ratings creep back up to the 40s, look for panic on our side.)  Hence the lowered expectations of Kos and other bloggers who had high expectations dashed in 2002-4.

I think it's very important that Democrats should exude confidence that they're going to win and that the Republicans will lose, because the party that appears more confident does tend to have an advantage.  Karl Rove knows that, which is why he always predicted massive landslides for Bush even when he was neck-and-neck with his opponents. Party leaders need to talk confidently about November and dismiss talk of 2002 with the simple point that Congress (and Bush) were much more popular then.


by maestroanonymo on Fri Mar 24, 2006 at 03:57:35 PM EST

Re: Demoralized on both sides? (none / 0)

By being confident and always predicting blowouts, Rove projected a sense of inevitability regarding Bush's election and reelection.  This sense of inevitability is more important and can help more than people think.  It's in our progressive nature to be pessimistic but we need to be confident, because that encourages our base and encourages the media narrative, over time, that we'll pickup the Congress.

Who cares if we were disappointed before?  Big deal.  What, are we weak pussies who can't handle disappointments?  Get over it and put a smile on your faces.


McCain is defining Obama, and Obama is neither defining himself, nor McCain. This is awful.
by jgarcia on Fri Mar 24, 2006 at 08:17:40 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Gallup: Low Approval Ratings (none / 0)

Polls tend to prove that there's no question but that a significant political opportunity awaits us, but we must not forget that down does not me out.  The Republican Party is down, but they are, by no means, out.  Watching their poll numbers drop, can amount to inaction on our part.  Just as surely as night follows day, we've watched these guys pull themselves off the mat before.  To keep them down, we must start the count this instant.  We cannot wait until November.  November is the time of the people.  Our party's time is now.

Here's what we need to do and you can start it.  We need to remind people that it is the Republican Party that is in charge and who screwed this whole mess to the wall.  I can think of one phrase that will do that... "IT'S THE REPUBLICAN PARTY!"  My apologies to Carville or Bagala (It's the economy, stupid).  

That simple phrase will stick if said often enough, in every context and, given the way things are, it will not be construed as a flattering remark.

Our time is not in November; it is now. Right now!  As the Republican Party slips farther and farther down into a political abyss we can either watch the polls and waste time slapping our collective thighs or we can take decisive action.  People need to be reminded of how they have been bamboozled, lied to, bullied, cheated and otherwise screwed.  They should be reminded each second of every day.  And IT'S THE REPUBLICAN PARTY! will do that.  Every day.  Every second. Over and over again.  By the time November gets here people will remember why they need to vote in great numbers for the Democratic Party...IT'S THE REPUBLICAN PARTY!  

I respectfully recommend that you start with a banner on MYDD.  


by sergeantmajor on Fri Mar 24, 2006 at 04:51:49 PM EST

Re: Gallup: Low Approval Ratings (3.00 / 1)

I agree with you on that, but with one point added. Unless the Democrats have a clear and simple message of their own, it'll be very hard to make any gains. Until people can say why they're a Democrat in 10 words or less, the Democratic Party has a problem.


by cwilson on Sat Mar 25, 2006 at 12:46:26 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.