Strange Poll On CA-50

I received a strange poll over email today on the CA-50 race. I don't know who commissioned the poll. I don't know who conducted the poll. In fact, I don't know when the poll was conducted. I do know that it has a very strange age sample (only 5.2% of those in the survey are under 35), and that is was a poll of "802 special election likely voters." But, even with that huge grain of salt, I am going to post some of the results anyway, because I am a poll junkie and rarely do I get hot tips like this:
On April 11th, there will be a special election in the 50th Congressional District. If that election were held today and you had to vote, would you be voting for . . . (Candidates have been rotated)

Francine Busby, Democrat, Trustee, Cardiff School Board 33.5%
Brian Bilbray, Republican, Immigration Reform Consultant 14.8
Eric Roach, Republican, Businessman 7.9
Howard Kaloogian, Republican, Charitable Trust Attorney 7.1
Bill Morrow, Republican, California State Senator 4.7
Alan Uke, Republican, Business Owner 3.6
Bill Hauf, Republican, Businessman 1.5
Chris Young, Democrat, Retired Bank Executive 1.2
Richard Earnest, Republican, Business Entrepreneur 1.0
Another Candidate 1.1
Unsure (Not read) 23.4
In the head to head matchups that would take place if no one wins 50% on April 11th, Busby easily defeats anyone except Bilbray, Roach and Morrow. She is statistically tied (very slightly ahead or very slightly behind) with all three of those candidates.

Busby's lead comes largely from her strong name ID and positive favorables. She is at 80% name ID, with a slightly better than 2-1 favorable to unfavorable ratio. Morrow, Roach and Bilbray have 61%, 72%, and 88% name ID respectively. Busby is way ahead of those candidates in terms of "very favorable." She has 22% in that category, compared to 13% for Bilbray, 7% for Roach, and 6% for Morrow.

Is this poll worth the html it is encoded with? I have no idea. It could be shady, it could be old, it could just be a bad poll. If it is an accurate poll, that it clearly shows the Busby has good a shot in this thing. When it comes to undecideds, her high favorables could cancel out just how red this district really is (43% Democratic performance). I guess that I would even post a poll this mysterious is something that would make elitist journalists demand that we convene a blogger ethics panel, but whatever. I'm with Dewey on this one, not Lippman. I have told you everything I know about this poll, and you are free to make up your mind on your own.



Display:


Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Chris, you missed my diary ;)

This one is from Competitive Edge.  I found the numbers over at the conservative California blog Flash Report.  They say these guys are good pollers, but I know nothing about them.  The sample size is pretty good, so I would say this may be pretty legit.


by juls on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 03:14:57 PM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Comments on Dailykos say this a Competitive Edge poll taking from this site:

http://www.flashreport.org/blog.php?post ID=2006031421320062


by PAprogressive on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 03:15:34 PM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Or I'm too slow and juls has the diary posted here too ;)


by PAprogressive on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 03:16:00 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

:)  Hey man I am on the ball.  I always new Bowers would be more likely to pay attention to polling than the FP guys over at dkos.

Like I said in my diary, this poll shows that we need to make sure that Busby is funded through June 6th.  She will have the advantage of having the Westly/Angelides matchup, while there is no equivalent for the Republicans.


by juls on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 03:19:23 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Seems legit. I'm surprised that Morrow is doing so badly, though. Would have thought he'd at least be in second or third place as a well-known State Senator. Surprised that Roach is doing so well.

Well, looks like it'll be Bilbray anyway. Why does he get to be called an "Immigration Refom Consultant"? Shouldn't he be called "former U.S. Congressman" or something like that?

Busby won't get anywhere near 50% on April 11, but hoping she can win on June 6.


My ActBlue page
by Ament Stone of California on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 03:16:36 PM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

I saw that same poll late yesterday. I didn't post because, contrary to some comments above on the thread, I thought it was very bad news for Busby. While on the one hand she seems to do well in hypothetical matchups, the fact is that she is enormously better known than any of the R's except Bilbray, and not coincidentally he's the one she would lose to. More importantly, she only gets 33.5% right now in the special. In a race with something like 12 other candidates, all Repub, I would think she needs more like 45% or so to have a chance in June. Figure she gets a few more percent from the undecided column (I believe 5% of the undecided when pushed went for her), and she hits a ceiling right around normal Democratic performance in this district. There is no evidence she is drawing any substantial number of Republicans yet, which is what she needs to win in June and, more importantly, in November for the full two year term.

By the way, Bilbray fought to be recognized as an "Immigration Advocate" or whatever. He's a complete Neanderthal, way past the racist line, on immigration, but is actually quite moderate, even liberal on other stuff, particularly environmental issues.


by ColoDem on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 04:14:58 PM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Two thoughts: Competetive Edge is a Republican operation.  My son worked for them and could not believe some of the stuff they did in terms of push poling and the obvious Republican bias.  Secondly, Bilbray is definitely the establishment candidate, therefore Competetive Edge would find a way to support him.  

I live in CA 50.  Busby got 38% against Duke last time in a bad year for Dems. It just does not make any sense that she would be less than that this time. This feels like a Bilbray funded effort to dry up his oppositions funding.


by surfk9 on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 06:10:04 PM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Interesting info about the firm.  reid fan over on my dkos diary wrote that the local PBS station uses them.

I agree, it seems a bit odd that Busby is so low in this poll, especially when it shows her matching up so strongly head to head.


by juls on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 06:31:26 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Poll is legit.  But, the actually timing of the survey is unclear.  What is interesting is that the conservatives in the race (Morrow, Kaloogian and Roach) are cancelling each other out and leaving the door wide open for the more moderate Bilbray.  In a way, this works to Francine Busby's disadvantage.  Bilbray has a more moderate record, which fits the 50th.  He would gain back his seniority if elected, which helps keep the district on the funding gravy train.  His anti-immigrant activitism is a plus as illegal immigration is the number one issue among likely voters.

Busby runs well against Bilbray, but she will need to really define her position on immigration and hit Bilbray on his lobbying career choice.  

Despite the April 11 election date, this race is a marathon not a sprint.

San Diego Politics has some good posts up regarding the fall out from this poll and internals being done both several Republican candidates.

Words Have Power has some questions about the top conservative Republican in the race.


by Words Have Power on Thu Mar 16, 2006 at 12:39:29 AM EST

Re: Strange Poll On CA-50 (none / 0)

Actually, Bilbray would be an ideal opponent. He is tainted by the same money that brought down Duke. This is a good fit for the anti-corruption theme Busby is running.

I still think the poll stinks.  And the local PBS station is much more right-wing than most.  And it is a part of the good-old-boys network that runs this town.  Don't be fooled.


by surfk9 on Thu Mar 16, 2006 at 11:32:11 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.