Holding State Legislators Accountable

In New York, the Drum Major Institute for Public Policy has undertaken an incredibly impressive mission. Today, DMI issued a comprehensive scorecard grading the state legislature on issues impacting the state's middle class. It's not your standard scorecard, which is typically focused on an individual issue like the environment, labor, or gun control. Rather, it's a much more comprehensive look at the issues impacting New York's middle class and how legislators are responding to them.

Votes examined for the scorecard include everything from card-check recognition of unions and an estate tax exemption to predatory mortgage lending and subsidized daycare. Each legislator's votes are compared to the middle class position and a percentage score is tabulated which is then translated into an easily understood letter grade. For each bill, an overview is also given, describing the legislation, giving key facts and figures about it, and grading each legislative body as well as both political parties.

Take, for example, a Senate bill proposing an expansion of daycare subsidies for working families. Overall, the state Senate failed, with only 39% support. Senate Democrats overwhelmingly supported the bill, earning a 91%/A- grade. Senate Republicans were given an F, with 0% support.  DMI coded the middle class position as a yes vote, citing the fact that families who already qualify often do not receive any assistance because the program is not adequately funded. In explaining the topic, they offer quotes from experts from the Center for Economic and Policy Research and the Greater Upstate Law Project discussing the issue. They also post statistics like the number of children who would benefit from the bill and the number of families who qualify, but don't receive funding, as well as costs associated with daycare.

Beyond the fact that this is an incredibly valuable resource, DMI is using an interesting tactic to promote it. Rather than simply telling you about it, it's worth seeing it in action. The Speaker of the state Assembly is Sheldon Silver, a Democrat from the 64th district. Google him. If you look at the 'Sponsored Links' to the right side of the search results, you should notice that he's earned an A- according to the Drum Major Institute's scorecard. Try it with any other member of the state's Assembly or Senate -- they're all there. (Or just take my word for it, as we don't want to run up massive charges on DMI's account.)

To me, this is brilliant. What better way to get relevant information to people looking up their state representatives than a Google AdWords campaign? Unfortunately, they're only running the ad campaign for 30 days, which I'd assume is a budgetary matter. I really hope this is something they revisit, perhaps for a few weeks leading up to primary or general elections. After all, that tends to be the time when most people are interested in what their representatives have been up to.

I've made no secret of the fact that I think the states actually hold the key to future progressive innovation and power. But within the states, more tools are needed to help politicians move a progressive agenda forward. This is why a group like PLAN are so important. But equally important, especially in states that are already ostensibly blue, is a mechanism to make sure legislators know their voting records are being scrutinized. At least in New York, DMI's outstanding legislative scorecard fills that role and provides a solid model I hope will be emulated elsewhere.



Display:


Great! Why isn't there one for Congress? (none / 0)

Not accusing, just curious.

I'm wondering why an outfit like the Center for American Progress, say, wouldn't have done this before?

Could it have something to do with the fact that, on too many issues, it would identify too many Dems on the side of the fat cats, rather than that of the average Joe?

(I'm thinking bankruptcy bill, energy bill, 'death tax' bill, American Jobs Creation Act - pardon me while I rinse my mouth out...)

Joking aside - and I'm really not sure that was joking - someone should do this for Congress.


by skeptic06 on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 12:36:59 PM EST

Re: Great! Why isn't there one for Congress? (none / 0)

I can't speak for CPA but DMI has been doing the middle class scorecard thing for years now.

We are a progressive public policy think tank in NYC that tackels a gamut of issues but frequently uses the lens of the middle class squeeze to look at policy.

our website is www.drummajorinstitute.org
You can read all our past studies and scorecards there

and I run our blog which is www.dmiblog.com

Glad to have an excuse to explain us on this site.

If you are interested in think tanks that are challenging orthodoxy and promoting ideas in new ways do check us out.
We're the little think tank that could.


by DMIer on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 01:25:17 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Holding State Legislators Accountable (none / 0)

it would be nice to have buckets of money to spend on smart things.


by Lucas O'Connor on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 01:04:38 PM EST

Re: Holding State Legislators Accountable (none / 0)

Hey there guys, DMI does have a scorecard for congress.
Its here:

http://204.200.199.40/library/report.php ?ID=4

and we are doing a third one for 2005 now.


by DMIer on Wed Mar 15, 2006 at 01:20:11 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.