LA-2: The "Most Murderous" City in America

As the party raged, police manned nearly every corner on Bourbon Street last weekend -- some on horses, some on foot, others massed in groups on intersections.  About a half-mile down the street from the lively French Quarter, fights began breaking out near the Central Business District off Canal Street; business owners began closing early for the evening; a man was stabbed multiple times and died.

Add another to the counter in New Orleans, the "most murderous" city in country.

Crime, that old menace of the old New Orleans, is back, and it's bedeviling a city trying to recover from Hurricane Katrina. There have been 147 people killed in New Orleans this year, police say, down from 204 by this time in 2005. But the city's population is about half what it was before Katrina flooded 80% of the city, forcing an almost-complete evacuation.

That means New Orleanians are murdering each other at a rate of 73.5 murders per 100,000 residents. That figure is above that of the nation's most murderous city -- Compton, Calif., whose rate was 67 murders per 100,000 people in 2005, according to the latest FBI statistics.

Because many traditionally violent areas flooded and remain nearly empty, crime has moved to upscale, high-traffic areas such as the Marigny, the French Quarter and Uptown, leaving residents with one more reason to question their decision to remain in the city.

"This is a city out of control," says Fine, 78, who stands drinking a beer outside the Spotted Cat as a Billie Holiday song wafts out of the bar's open doors. "Something's changed here."

Maybe now that the crime and murder are beginning to directly impact the more affluent (see "white") communities in New Orleans, the problem will receive more national attention than the easy to digest storyline of black folks shooting black folks over drugs.  This is a dangerous city, I could see it nightly on my drive from the CBD to Uptown every evening.  It was one of the first things I talked with Stoller about after arriving in NOLA.  One of Karen Carter's staffers was apparently car-jacked during the campaign.

Amazingly, this isn't really an issue I've heard much about from either candidate in the press.  It was an issue in the Mayor's race, but in this one ... not so much.  And like all issues in this election, it's all part of Katrina.  Whether it's exacerbated poverty problems since the storm, a lack of police on the street, or post-storm psychological issues, it's yet another indication this city has been left to fend for itself since the storm.

And it's not just the East Bank of the Second District suffering from high crime and murder rates, it's happening on the other side of the bridge as well:

Sheriff Harry Lee said he's ready to take "extreme" measures to curb Jefferson Parish's highest homicide rate since at least 1980, including using video cameras _ some in armored vehicles _ to monitor streetcorner groups and the license plates of cars that travel through targeted areas.

Lee, who last month prompted outrage by suggesting his deputies could randomly question young black men gathered in high-crime areas, said he expects his latest plan to offend some people. But added, "I don't give a damn."

"We will go right up to the line," Lee told a news conference.

So far this year there have been 53 homicides in Jefferson Parish, an 83 percent increase over this time in 2005. Lee said he expects the figure to top 60 by year's end. Most of the victims and the alleged killers are black, sheriff's deputies said. About 45 percent of the killings are drug-related.

Lee said he's frustrated by the growing number of killings, a problem he believes has spread to Jefferson from neighboring New Orleans. That city, which has less than half its pre-Katrina population, had recorded 140 homicides _ also mostly black-on-black _ as of Tuesday afternoon, a police spokesman said.

I have been trying to get in touch with Mayor Nagin's office to quiz him on this issue specifically, but have been fruitless in every attempt to even get a simple call-back.  For his part, the Mayor's team insists NOLA's crime strategy is "second to none," but many aren't buying.  The Police Chief plans on asking the National Guard to stick around to complement a depleted force.  It was only this week, a full year-plus since the storm and food that the first police recruits began training to fill city's thinning ranks.

This election is going to come and go.  Maybe Congressman Jefferson will get re-elected, or maybe Karen Carter will provide a new voice for the district in the House.  Who knows.  But whatever happens, this city needs a tremendous amount of help that simply has not been forthcoming.  It's hard to imagine the greatest country in the world would abandon an entire population center, but while some things have gotten better August 2005, neglect has led others to sprial out of control.  It's now in the hands of a Democratic-controlled Congress to pick up the pieces left behind by the old guard on their way into the minority.  



Display:


"Most Murderous" City in America (none / 0)

If New Orleans was a city full of white swing voters they would have gotten all the help they need from the Bush administration a long time ago.

Maybe the solution is for the people of NOLA to shut down the docks there.  It is one of the biggest entry points in the nation for freight....


by global yokel on Fri Dec 01, 2006 at 04:56:10 PM EST

Another Brilliant GOP Theory Bites The Dust (none / 0)

And, as usual, with life-and-death consequences for ordinary people.

Remember all that talk a year or so ago about how the new New Orleans would be smaller and whiter, which (as far as they were concerned) added up to better?

Like I said, another brilliant GOP theory bites the dust.


by RT on Sat Dec 02, 2006 at 08:03:57 AM EST

"Most Murderous" City in America (none / 0)

As a Marigny resident I feel compelled to add my 2 cents

Crime has long been an issue here. In the early 90's, during the Bartholme admnistration things were incredibly bad with police presence pratically non-existent (someone told me there was one patrol car for the entire 3rd district) - and notoriously corrupt. Friends who had lived in the area for years, finally fled.

It improved somewhat under Morial with Pennington as police chief. Thanks to the Clinton administration we even had a neighborhood police presence with bicycle cops for a while. (When I had my purse snatched back then, 3 cops and a detective came in less than 5 mintues. Not nearly as helpful as my transvestive neighbors who chased him down in high heels, but that is another story).

Pennington left after an unsuccessful bid to replace Morial, and of course we know what the Bush administration did for the funding of police officers - so things had started to go down hill again long before Katrina. When a fugitive with a knife and blood on his shirt literally landed in my backyard after a stabbing the police finally sent in 2 cops too fat to bend down and look for him. I spoke with one officer who said there were so few operational patrol cars in our precint that she figured soon she'd be calling United Cab to respond. In my opinion we were well on our way to a return to the bad days of the 90's before Katrina hit.

The bad days aren't/weren't neighborhood specific. Don't underestimate the downtown/uptown divide. Those of us downtown think uptown is wildly unsafe (certainly more subject to theft) while up town people appear to life in fear of Frenchman street without an armed guard. And black/white neighbood labels are difficult for these areas. Drive 2 blocks in from St Charles in the right direction and you are not in a white neighborhood. Walk 5 blocks in Marigny/Bywater and you're likely to change your mind on how to label the neighborhood 3 times. Pre-Katrina you could have had the same experience in Gentilly.

Things were surreally safe here in the post Katrina fall. Everyone remarked on the amazing ability to walk around day or night. Things started down hill that winter. We've been facing the increase in crime with a diminished police force that, in my opinion, was already on the decline. This may be new national news, but for us it has been going on for months.

Many of us thought the mayorial election was our chance to change the variables in this equation that are determined locally. We didn't win. We did make some strides on the city council - and thank heaven's for the National Guard. We view this (without much optimism) as primarily a local/state problem.

While controlling crime also has a national component (witness the cops we got during the Clinton administration) it is of course not on the top of anyone's list of what we need from the Feds. We need levee's and a wetlands protection program and a decent share of the oil and gas revenue more than anything.

None of these made Pelosi's 100 hour list. I want a representative who can change that.


by lb0313 on Sat Dec 02, 2006 at 08:51:29 AM EST

Nitpicking on Orleans Parish pop and murder rates (none / 0)

From USA Today: Riley and other city leaders dispute the federal government's official count of 187,000 residents and believe it to be 200,000.

What Federal government official count?!  The Census Bureau's most recent official count, through the American Community Survey, is clearly from pre-Katrina 2005, showing a housing unit population (i.e. excluding group quarters such as prisons, college dorms, and nursing homes) of about 437,186.  (Go here, put "Orleans Parish" in the city/town/county/zip box, and select Lousiana as the state.)

The only "official" recent estimate was done by agencies of the State of Louisiana - with technical assistance from the Census and the CDC, but they didn't actually conduct the survey.  And it shows an Orleans Parish population count of 200,665 (albeit with a margin of error of nearly 19,000).

Now, the murder rate: 147 people out of 200,665 is 73.3 per 100,000 - but that's just in the first 11 months of 2006.  Annualized, that's a murder rate of 79.9 per 100,000 per year.


by RT on Sat Dec 02, 2006 at 11:27:38 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.