Republicans About To Steal Katherine Harris's Old District?

Update: The Florida Democratic Party needs naother $4,075 $2,475 to fight this. You can contribute to the effort here.

There are some very worrying things happening in some districts. Florida-13 is probably the worst one of those (emphasis mine):
A review of Sarasota County voting results shows that in almost every precinct a high percentage of voters didn't cast ballots in the hotly contested 13th Congressional District, a trend that likely affected the outcome of the race.

Democrat Christine Jennings lost to Republican Vern Buchanan by 368 votes, making it the second closest congressional race in the country.

More than 18,000 voters who showed up at the polls voted in other races but not the Buchanan-Jennings race.

That means nearly 13 percent of voters did not vote for either candidate -- a massive undercount compared with other counties, including Manatee, which reported a 2 percent undervote.

If the missing votes had broken for Jennings by the same percentage as the counted votes in Sarasota County, the Democrat would have won the race by about 600 votes instead of losing by 368, according to a Herald-Tribune review. Even if the undervote had been 8 percent -- more than three times what it was in Manatee -- Jennings would have won by one vote.


While some have speculated that people simply chose not to vote in the District 13 race, many voters say the unusual undervote was caused by badly designed touch-screen ballots, which they say hid the race or made it hard to verify if they had cast their vote.

More than 120 Sarasota County voters contacted the Herald-Tribune to report such problems, almost all regarding the Jennings-Buchanan race.

At a press conference Wednesday, Supervisor of Elections Kathy Dent said she did not know specifically what caused the undervote.

"I do not know what to attribute it completely to. It's not a mechanical issue; it would be voters overlooking the race. We did not have any equipment failure," Dent said. "I'm not a mind reader. I can only give you conjecture."

But prior to the election, Dent had sent notices to her poll workers to warn voters that the District 13 race was easy to miss as they scrolled through their touch-screens to vote.
(...)

"I'm not sure there's even a problem," said Jenny Nash, a spokeswoman for the Florida Secretary of State, who oversees elections. She said the office had not received a single complaint or contact about the race.

Nash repeated Dent's suggestion that voters may have intentionally decided not to vote in the congressional race.

"It could be a protest vote. There's a lot of different reasons people undervote," she said. "Certainly undervoting is the voter's prerogative."

Nash said no state investigation is planned.
No investigation planned, huh? What a surprise. Perhaps fittingly, this is the district that Katherine Harris vacated. Christine Jennings must not concede this race. It seems pretty clear that more people went to the polls or their absentee ballots ready to vote for Jennings. She should be Representative-Elect Jennings now. She has posted the following statement on her website:
Dear Friends,

It is overwhelming to think of how many of you have spent your free time making phone calls, knocking on doors, and stuffing envelopes. Thank you for your support. I couldn't have gotten this far without you.

The Supervisor of Elections reported today that there were 18,382 undervotes in this Congressional race - that means more than 1 out of every 7 ballots cast did not record a vote for the 13th District Congressional race. This is a staggering number. Sarasota voters have been victimized by not having their vote count.

I hope my opponent agrees that the most important thing is to make sure every vote throughout the district is counted and counted accurately. This is about ensuring fair elections.

Concerned and frustrated voters have been calling us since the beginning of early voting. On Election Day, we received dozens of reports from voters who experienced a problem at the polls. Today, it is overwhelming, the number of emails and phone calls we have received. We continue to document the cases as they come in, and the phones are still ringing off the hook. We've had members of the media, people who trained pollworkers, and even pollworkers themselves contact us.

By law, there will be a mandatory recount. Our goal is to assure every voter that we will have a fair and accurate election process. We will not rest until every vote is counted.

Sincerely,
Christine Jennings
Any information and resources on how to fight for what appears to the imminent theft of Katherine Harris's congressional seat in Florida would be appreciated.

Update: The Florida Democratic Party needs another $4,075 $2,475 to fight this. You can contribute to the effort here.



Display:


Chris (none / 0)

Good to see you got some rest and sharpen your pen. The country is fallen apart lead us


by KevinB on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:01:57 PM EST

EVEN WORSE - NO PAPER TRAIL (none / 0)

It seems Saratosa County has no paper trail possible. The other counties do.

A manual recount will be automatically triggered, but: there is no way of counting the undervotes. NONE.

The lack of paper trail just got a seat stolen from us.


by FrenchSocialist on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:03:51 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

There is probably nothing that can be done here with this race, but it reinforces the point that there needs to be a voter's bill of rights passed within the first 100 hours by our newly minted Democratic Congress, including the following:

a) Verifiable voting machines w/ a paper trail that the voter can take with him or her as a receipt

b) In federal elections reducing the requirements that the states now place on voters including felony lists, any poll ID requirements

c) Multiple day voting in federal elections

d) Vote by mail where possible (ie sending out ballots to all registered voters).

e) Elimination of all voting supression techniques w/ both stiff fines and lengthy jail terms. On top of that create some kind of RICO like approach to it where people can't wiggle out of it as the RNC has been doing by pretending- oh we didn't know.

f) Outlawing newer suppression techniques such as robo calling at the federal level.

g) the creation of non partisan org whose sole function is to ensure elections are run well throughout the country- by the federal govt. Make sure that no district goes without machines working properly

h) Improving HAVA

Those are some things off top my head that I believe would prevent this issue.


by bruh21 on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:14:44 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

voter time off act- some kind of thing similar to time off for family leave act- to allow people time to get to polls during day etc.


by bruh21 on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:16:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

National Voter Holiday... To make it so that you don't have to pay federal workers more, take away the day off for Columbus day or President's day (probably the less controversial).  Maybe have businesses do soemthing where they pay the holiday pay if the person votes and brings proof, but the person has to use vacation time if they don't vote.  


by yitbos96bb on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:06:07 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

You don't even need another holiday.  Just move Election Day out a few days to Veteran's Day.


Enough is enough!
by Bear83 on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 09:13:51 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

I would add to that list random audits of all electronic voting machines.


by nmonster on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 07:11:43 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re (none / 0)

I wonder if the problem is like what we had here in TN. We have new touch-screen machines and at any time you can press the final "submit vote" button even if you're not done paging through all the races. Many voters thought they were supposed to "submit the vote" after each race, then "confirmed" that vote, only to then be told they were done and unable to continue voting in the other races. Don't know if that could have caused many to miss the House race. I'm sure lots of FL was focused on Gov. and Senate. Still, 1 out of 7 undervotes sounds ridiculous.


by DonBinTN on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:30:45 PM EST

So much for one "advantage" of e-voting (none / 0)

One of the claimed advantages of electronic voting is that the machines lead the voter through the process and make it harder to overlook races or mistakenly skip voting for a candidate. Looks like in this case the machine made it more likely that voters would make a mistake.


DC Drinking LiberallyDC for Democracy

by KCinDC on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:35:37 PM EST

Here's one touch-screen that worked (none / 0)

Those machines do exist! We used a touch-screen model for early voting in Cook County, Illinois, that provided a summary at the end which alerted the voter to any undervotes, with the ability to page backwards and complete voting.

The model includes a paper audit trail contained within the machine, and the voter reviewed those printed pages one by one before exiting the session. It would have been very difficult to end the session accidentally.


by Books Alive on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:19:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

MOre Florida ballot fraud... (none / 0)

The Democratic Atty General candidate's NAME was LEFT OFF THE BALLOT in some heavily Democratic districts.

http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/new s/local/states/florida/counties/broward_ county/15965816.htm


by Hesiod Theogeny on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:45:23 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal Katherine Harris's (none / 0)

Good Lord.  There has to be some way to make this right...


by beeswax49 on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 12:46:43 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To (none / 0)

The undervote is messed up and clearly there was something wrong... either voters had a hard tiem with the machine, there was fraud or something else... but in the absense of proof of fraud, what can be done to recitify the undervotes?  


by yitbos96bb on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:00:44 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal (none / 0)

Has anyone forwarded this to Glenn Greenwald or Marty Lederman at Balkinization? Perhaps our Lawyers could come up with something.


by Grandma M on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:01:23 PM EST

Re: Republicans (none / 0)

I believe the House can refuse to sit the member.


by RAULC on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:09:51 PM EST

Re: Katherine Harris's Old District (none / 0)

"But prior to the election, Dent had sent notices to her poll workers to warn voters that the District 13 race was easy to miss as they scrolled through their touch-screens to vote.(...)"

The most likely thing is that poll workers got busy or lazy or lax about warning people.  But unless there's evidence of systematic bias against Democrats, or something like that, then the result should stand.

We'd look pretty hypocritical complaining about the design of the screen after crossing our fingers that lots of Joe Lieberman voters would have that problem.


by drlimerick on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:12:06 PM EST

Great potential (none / 0)

One of my moveon callees from Sarasota said she is a banker and could be a great leader. I hope she gets a recount.


--donna darko. I don't read or respond to comments. There's too much hate and misogyny here.
by nonwhiteperson on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:28:57 PM EST

Absolute nonsense that it's undervoting! (3.00 / 2)

This page shows the summary votes for Sarosota County including the undervotes.

http://www.srqelections.com/results/gen2 006sum.htm

Take a quick scan at the numbers below--they tell the story.

Total votes cast: 142,284   56.8% turnout

In BALLOT order(!):

Senate undervotes: 1,617
Congress undervotes: 18,382   <=== !!!!
Governor undervotes:  1,821
AG undervotes: 6,203
CFO undervotes: 6,299
Comm Ag undervotes: 7,371
State Rep 69 undervotes: 1,173
State Rep 70 undervotes: 1,971
State Rep 71 undervotes: 5,614
Charter review board member undervotes: 12,978
Charter review board member undervotes: 23,668
Charter review board member undervotes: 14,224
Charter review board member undervotes: 14,417
Charter review board member undervotes: 13,995
Hospital review board member undervotes: 14,106

From this point forward were several judge retention ballot items where undervotes ranged from 21,000 to 27,000.

Absolutely no way would any reasonable person think that so many people avoided the Congressional race.  It didn't happen for any other partisan race

Here's what you need to see!!!!!!!

For Senate:
Republican votes: 58,238
Democratic votes: 80,038

For Congress
Republican votes: 58,534
Democratic votes: 65,367

The only way this makes sense--and it doesn't make sense--is that about 15,000 people voted for Nelson (Senate-Dem) but couldn't bear to vote for Jennings (Congress-Dem). No way!

Jennings was robbed!


by sawgrass727 on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:49:26 PM EST

Re: Absolute nonsense that it's undervoting! (none / 0)

sawgrass727,

Thanks for looking up these numbers. With all the news stories talking about ballot design, I assumed both the Dem and Rep votes were undercounted. These numbers show that argument is nonsense. Lazy, stupid reporters! This clearly affects Dems way more than Reps.

Jennings needs to release these numbers and raise them all over the media. She needs to call all their Dem ID's voters in Sarasota and let them know 15,000 of their votes were not counted. They need to rewalk their precincts and let the Dems know their votes were not counted. Take affidavits, now. Then they need to march on the election board, impound the machines, and bring in the computer scientists. They need to own the framing of this controversy as Dem voter disenfranchisement.

OK, I'll go see what Bradblog.com is organizing.

This is not a glitch. A glitch would have reduced both Dem and Rep votes. Now that we are pretty certain it affected Dems way more than Reps, the glitch story, the idea that the race was hard to find on the ballot is just a misdirection, a coverstory. We should treat it as a lie, not an oh so reasonable explanation.


by alcatholic on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 04:18:58 PM EST
[ Parent ]

10 Undecided Seats - Any More Pickups Possible? (none / 0)

Anyone know?  

Any information appreciated!


by jc on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 01:51:36 PM EST

Regarding stolen seats and Repub tactics (none / 0)

I really think that the powers that be should prosecute some of the phone dialing stuff that was being discussed earlier, as well as concentrate on fixing local systems so that local voting is secure and transparent.

You MUST prosecute for robo-calling violations so that actual people who do it, will find there is a penalty, and, hopefully, jail time.


by jc on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 02:10:49 PM EST

down to $2000 (none / 0)

good work everybody!


by lutton on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 02:33:04 PM EST

Power of incumbency (none / 0)

As Bilbray and Stephanie Herseth show by way of example, once these folks are in, it's hard to undo later.  So even though we won the house, we might need these seats in '08 or '10 to keep the house.  So PONY UP!!


by magster on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 02:37:48 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal Katherine Harris's (none / 0)

Hoyer's district (MD-5) is culturally conservative.  It includes, very roughly, southern Maryland south of U.S. 50 outside the Beltway, with some adjustments to the contours of the adjacent majority-minority District 4, and some territory for the outer DC suburbs in northern Prince George's County, where the Goddard Space Flight Center is located.

This is former tobacco country; the county seal of Calvert County includes a tobacco leaf.  It includes many relatively poor whites, many descendants of the early English Catholic colonists in St. Mary's County scattered among many, many small rural Catholic parishes; a substantial but low-profile Amish/Mennonite community; the descendants of many African-American and Native American families who intermarried and produced descendants known humorously and in good spirits as "Wesorts" [of Black, wesorts of "Indian". etc.]  There are a number of military bases in or very near this District - Patuxent Naval Air Station, Fort Meade, Bolling AFB, Andrews AFB, NSA, the Naval Academy, etc. are either in the District or are a very short drive from it.  Many newer residents are African-Americans with some means who are (with others) building and buying many of the new homes in Charles County, making the County both blacker and wealthier/higher income at the same time.

This District:

  1.  Is diverse like America in many ways;

  2.  Is filled with people who have a strong sense of connection to history and heritage, more explicitly so than in many parts of the "the world was born when I was born" America that baffles some foreign visitors;

  3.  Is heavily Democratic but NOT culturally liberal;

Hoyer should be judged based on the foregoing.
Bruce Godfrey
www.crablaw.com


by Crablaw on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 06:11:56 PM EST

Re: Republicans About To Steal Katherine Harris's (none / 0)

Sorry, misposted.  Please delete, wrong thread.


by Crablaw on Thu Nov 09, 2006 at 06:12:21 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans About To Steal Katherine Harris's (none / 0)

RAULC's post above refers to the House being able to not seat the member.  The first sentence of Article 1, Section 5 of the U. S. Constitution applies:  

"Each house shall be the judge of the elections, returns and qualifications of its own members" ...

Therefore, one action all of us can take is to pressure Democratic members of the House of Representatives to exercise their power in this race (and possibly other races) and not seat the GOPiger.


by Airpower on Fri Nov 10, 2006 at 12:56:40 AM EST

CA GOV RACE- ANGELIDES' BIG MISTAKE (none / 0)

Well it was truly a great day for Democracy in California and across our nation. We've made incredible gains and started a new positive momentum. Too bad Phil Angelides didn't accept a brave offer by Controller Steve Westly to keep the Gubernatorial Primary clean and respectable. Though Angelides'  decision to ignore Westly's positive campaign offer may or may not have had a decisive impact on his chances, Californians are certainly tired of wasted time and money being pumped into useless negative campaigning. Westly's positive offer was truly refreshing. One thing is for sure though, no one could have done more to support Phil Angelides and our Party's candidates than Steve Westly. After barely losing an extremely disappointing primary, Westly certainly stood tall in support of our shared Democratic values. It was great to see how he came FULL-TIME to Phil's side even as so many other Democrats simply disappeared. I want to thank Mr. Westly for helping to put forth a truly valiant effort to defeat our Bush-promoting, middle class bashing, immigrant disparaging Governor.

Steve Westly's actions (and not just words) will certainly be remembered should he ever again decide to go forward with public service aspirations. True Democrats always reward candidates who PROVE themselves loyal and unselfish, especially when it comes to relentlessly championing our mutual Democratic values.


by Eddie Democratic Strategist on Fri Nov 10, 2006 at 01:59:54 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.