NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters

Jim Walsh, the long-term Republican incumbent from NY-25, is very mad at the voters for nearly removing him from office:
Rep. Jim Walsh was smiling Friday, hours after accepting Democratic challenger Dan Maffei's surrender in the 25th Congressional District race.

But the narrowest victory in Walsh's 18-year House career didn't leave the incumbent as happy as some might think.

In January, he'll return to Congress as a survivor, former appropriations committee powerhouse fighting for influence in a body where the GOP will be in the Õ7WalshÕ minority for the first time in more than a decade. And he'll go there knowing that his hometown - the city where his dad was mayor and where he served as president of the Common Council - voted against him.

"I was very disappointed in the people of the city," Walsh said. "I've worked harder in the city of Syracuse than I have in any other part of the district. I have given my heart and soul to that city. And I'll continue to do that, but I've got a little hole in my heart."
How dare the plebs vote for anyone but the local lord, whose seat was handed down to him by his father since time immemorial? I mean, Syracuse is a thriving city, that has consistently been lavished with benefits from our various Republican masters in Albany and Washington, D.C. Of course the elected representative should be mad at the voters, rather than the other way around. Worst. Victory. Speech. Ever.

This must be what happens to members of congress who are only seriously challenged once every decade or so. They feel it is the responsibility of voters to support them, rather than the other way around. See Lieberman, Joe for another case study in this sort of attitude. How dare the people who actually vote have a differing opinion on a given war than the DLC wonks at my cocktail party!

Walsh only defeated Dan Maffei in this district by about 1,000 votes, even though Maffei received virtually no support from either the national party or, for that matter, from the netroots. This is one we alllet slip through our fingers. However, after the November 7th slaughter of the Republican moderates, the NY-25 is now the fifth most Democratic district in the nation held by a Republican, with a partisan voting index of Democratic +3.4. Combine this with Walsh's condescending, aristocratic attitude toward the voters, and the NY-25 has the makings of one of our best pickups opportunities in 2008. If Walsh can only squeeze out a 1,000 vote victory without being targeted either by the netroots or by the DCCC, then he is in a lot of trouble in 2008. Given that this is my hometown district, I can't wait to help to the presumptive Democratic nominee as much as possible. And this time, I mean a lot more than moral support and the occasional canvassing trip Upstate.



Display:


Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Heh... Republicans do the same thing when we dare to challenge them in one of their "safe" districts.  See Cubin, Barbara.


by Tom on Mon Nov 20, 2006 at 11:46:26 PM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I think that NY-25 and NY-29, where Walsh and Maffei ran, will be Democratic pickups in 2008.  Now that we have NY-24, getting those two should be a priority for New York Democrats.


by LionelEHutz on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 12:09:27 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Draft Chris Bowers for the NY-25


Mark
by Mark J. Bowers on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 12:14:27 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

It's not entirely accurate to say that NY-25 was not targeted by the DCCC.  It WAS targeted by the DCCC--just a little too late.

Tray.com lists the following DCCC expenditures in NY-25:

11/3: $100k media buy in support of Dan Maffei
10/30-31: $160k media buy in support of Dan Maffei, $160k media buy against Jim Walsh

There may have been more, but I'm not sure.  But I will agree with you, however, that the DCCC dropped the ball here--if they entered this district a little earlier and amplified Walsh's negatives for another week or two, we could have very well seen Maffei squeak out a win here.

But to suggest that the national party did nothing in this district is erroneous.  The cavalry came too late, but they did come.


Swing State Project: Campaign & Election News - Covering Key Races Around the Country
by HellofaSandwich on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 12:27:38 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Yes, they were late. I do give them credit for sending General Clark to help Maffei, Massa, and Gillibrand on the final weekend. Given that General Clark was, along with Obama and President Clinton, the most frequently requested surrogate, that's no small thing.


by lhuynh on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 03:00:53 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I could be hallucinating, but either the day before or the day of the election, I could have sworn that I saw a picture on Yahoo News of Bill Clinton campaigning (i.e. doing a speech) with Dan Maffei.  I know he also did an event with Jerry McNerney like this, so it wouldn't be outside the realm of possibility for the Big Dog to do an event for Maffei--a guy who enjoyed at least double the Independent Expenditures by the DCCC that McNerney got.


Swing State Project: Campaign & Election News - Covering Key Races Around the Country
by HellofaSandwich on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 03:21:37 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

What do we know about Maffei?  Is he moderate or prog?

I know some people have problems with this way of thinking, but, now that we have a majority, my very limited financial support will only be to Democrats who are on the progressive side of the party.


McCain is defining Obama, and Obama is neither defining himself, nor McCain. This is awful.
by jgarcia on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 12:56:42 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

another Onondaga County exile here.  how sweet it will be to see my hometown finally go blue.  


by chiefscribe on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 01:32:12 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

From what I've heard, people are pissed about his "speech". He made no attempt to hide his arrogance and once again the people are subjected to an entitlement attitude from a "Representative".

I hope Maffei runs again. With more support, from all corners, we could take this seat easily. We SHOULD have in November.


by kml on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 01:33:09 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Oh, goody. That reminds me of Rick Santorum's treatment of the voters. He made at least a week's worth of arrogant comments when his 6 children were denied Pennsylvania funding for their Virginia cyberschooling. Then when he came back to Pittsburgh to respond to a jury duty notice (he ducked the previous dozen or so), he said to the TV cameras, "If the citizens of Pennsylvania feel I have nothing better to do with my time---"

He was burnt toast with the voters at that point.


by joyful alternative on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 06:08:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Is Maffei considering another run? (none / 0)

Now that he has name recognition and experience, it seems to me that he could very well pick up that seat next cycle.


by RedDan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 02:03:48 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Hermanos, this will date me, but I worked for the Democrat Rosemary Pooler when she took on Jim Walsh in his first race -- he won by what I remember was less than 450 votes!  One of the closest elections in upstate history.  We were very, very crushed by this -- so close!  Pooler went on to become a state of NY judge, and a very good one, though, so that honorable lady served the public interest with all her heart, mind, and soul.  

For a Republican, Walsh turned out to be not the worst -- not the best, either -- he marched in lock-step to Republican authoritarians, as did they all.  But he's vulnerable now for being a chupamedias to Bush.  And now a sore loser.  

The Dems should go at him again -- in fact, keep running negative ads on him from time to time, starting about next March and on to the election cycle.  He needs to go!  !Echarlo a la calle!  


by diego277 on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 04:23:32 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I worked for the Democrat Rosemary Pooler when she took on Jim Walsh in his first race...Pooler went on to become a state of NY judge

Thank you very much for that news on Pooler.  I remember the race quite well from just across the line to the east.

Tells you that turkeys like Walsh have never been invulnerable.  All that has ever been lacking is the will to dig them out of their rathole.

Best,  Terry


by terryhallinan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 12:27:58 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

You know IMHO all 6 of the GOP districts are ripe for a takeout in 2008.

NY-3 - Mejias should run again
NY-13 - We need a good candidate Harrison was third or fourth choice.
NY-23 - ditto bush only got 51% in 2004 here.
NY-25 -  Maffei should run again.
NY-26 - My kingdom for a candidate who will campaign.
NY-29 - Massa should run again.


by BENAWU on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 09:11:25 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Maffei would be a great congressman.  He's definitely progressive and he's extremely knolwedgeable about the issues.  

He started off a little weak -- the first time I canvassed for him, it was just me and him.  But by the end, he was a strong political performer.

I think Maffei should run again.  I think he'll win.

Walsh is a fraud -- he pretends to be moderate but votes with Bush 90% of the time, he pretends to think the Syracuse economy is strong but claims it only survives on hand-outs from his (now gone) appropriation committee chairmanship.


by Pogues Fan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 10:10:54 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

NY-23 - ditto bush only got 51% in 2004 here.

I don't know why they haven't fielded anyone but Johnson the last 2 cycles.  There must be some stronger candidates in Plattsburg or possibly in the southern part of the district which includes relatively affluent Madison County.  


by Pogues Fan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 10:13:02 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

That bit of his victory speech is going to make one heck of a campaign ad against him next time around.  Benawu is right, with good candidates in the remaining six Republican-held districts (ideally meaning Massa and Maffei run again and Harrison, Davis, and Johnson don't -- not sure about Meijias) and a presidential candidate with some decent coattails, New York could be solid blue in the 111th Congress.

I wonder whether Hillary as the nominee would help or hurt?  Given the inevitability of her winning New York, she might be reluctant to campaign with House candidates there when she could be fighting for a state that's not a foregone conclusion.  Maybe in a Hillary vs. Rudy race she'd need to work a bit for NY, but I don't see Rudy winning the primary.   (If he did he'd probably be the best thing that could happen to the Republican House candidates there, making our job a good deal harder.)


Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama for President! Beat McCain!
by Alex on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 11:00:19 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I'm one of the grassroots/netroots that supported Maffei in very red, very rural Wayne County.  I contacted his campaign headquarters to ask for literature to hand out as getting to downtown Syracuse or Rochester was difficult for me.  I also participated in MoveOn's "Call for Change" and called 90 homes in District 25.  I'm afraid it was Wayne County that put Walsh over the top.  I don't believe Dan spent any time in Wayne County and people don't vote for candidates they know nothing about.  I'm hoping that he runs again and comes to my neck of the woods.  Glad to hear that we're considered an excellent pick-up opportunity for Democrats in two years.


by lavaughn on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 11:34:23 AM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I'm afraid it was Wayne County that put Walsh over the top.  I don't believe Dan spent any time in Wayne County and people don't vote for candidates they know nothing about.

Very bad mistake I think.  

The lady from Missouri probably wouldn't be going to D.C. as a senator if she didn't spend a lot of time with the hillbillies outside the big cities.

Next time maybe you won't be so lonesome in grand country.  Good places to visit even if they are red.

In fact I think they are good to live in too, which is why we do so.

Best,  Terry


by terryhallinan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 07:24:04 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

If any of you lives in NY-25, you should write a letter to the Post-Standard or your local paper about this.  It's a really, really stupid thing to say and we need to make an issue of it.

I'm writing mine tonight.


by Pogues Fan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 01:00:13 PM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

Syracuse is a thriving city?  Sheesh, I'd hate to see a depressed city.

But I'd love to see Syracuse sans Walsh.  When I went to school there I couldn't stand the way he threw his ego around, as if the town should kneel before his awesome powers.  


by mikeajo on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 01:50:27 PM EST

Re: NY-25: Jim Walsh Is Very Mad At The Voters (none / 0)

I'm afraid it was Wayne County that put Walsh over the top.  I don't believe Dan spent any time in Wayne County and people don't vote for candidates they know nothing about.

Very bad mistake I think.  

The lady from Missouri probably wouldn't be going to D.C. as a senator if she didn't spend a lot of time with the hillbillies outside the big cities.

Next time maybe you won't be so lonesome in grand country.  Good places to visit even if they are red.

Actually we think they are good places to live in too, which is why we do so.

Best,  Terry


by terryhallinan on Tue Nov 21, 2006 at 07:19:50 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.