Two races, where Democrats have led all along, Montana and Maryland, are tightening. Two races that were close for a while, New Jersey and Rhode Island, are now moving out of Republican reach. Two races where Democrats have typically been slightly behind, Missouri and Virginia, are now showing Democratic leads. Entering the final weekend, here is the complete Senate polling picture, via
Pollster.com's five-poll averages.
Looking good:
- PA: Casey (D) 51.4%--40.2% Santorum (R)
- OH: Brown (D) 52.6%--42.0% DeWine (R)
- MI: Stabenow (D) 50.4%--40.2% Bouchard (R)
- WA: Cantwell (D) 52.4%--42.6% McGavick (R)
- RI: Whitehouse (D) 48.2%--40.2% Chafee (R)
- MD: Cardin (D) 51.0%--43.8% Steele (R)
- NJ: Menendez (D) 48.2%--42.2% Kean (R)
Looking close, but good:
- MT: Tester (D) 48.2%--45.0% Burns (R)
- VA: Webb (D) 47.0%--45.8% Allen (R)
- MO: McCaskill (D) 47.8%--46.8% Talent (R)
Not looking good:
- TN: Corker (R) 49.2%--46.0% Ford (D)
- AZ: Kyl (R) 49.2%--41.0% Pederson (D)
- CT: Lieberman (CfL) 48.4%--38.8% Lamont (D)
The first tier gives us a baseline of a three-seat pickup, all of which look pretty solid right now. The second group is where we can win the Senate, with both Virginia and Missouri trending our way, and every poll still showing Tester hanging on in Montana. I am expecting undecideds to break our way in most of those ten races.
It may be a surprise to some that I include Tennessee in the bottom three seats, but right now that campaign seems to be moving in the opposite direction of Connecticut and Arizona. I expect Connecticut and Arizona to both get noticeably closer, both because of polling trends and as Pederson and Lamont scoop up undecideds. Ford's campaign seems to be moving in the opposite direction, and I am expecting the undecideds in that race to break for Corker. I actually wouldn't be surprised if both Pederson and Lamont outperform Ford. Later today, as I begin rolling updates to the House and senate forecast, Montana will be downgraded to "toss-up," and Tennessee will be downgraded to "lean Republican." Arizona could very well be upgraded to "lean Republican," but I haven't quite decided yet. Washington and Michigan will be placed back on the board as "likely Democratic."
Overall, I still think a five-seat gain for Democrats is the best bet right now, and taking control of the chamber has clearly become a possibility. Right now, polling shows us ready to take "control" to the tune of 49-49-2, and our momentum is generally quite good. Further, both
the Incumbent Rule and
the "blowing breeze" theory suggest we have additional advantages on top of our small leads in Montana, Missouri and Virginia. I think this suggests Democrats have about a 35-40% chance of taking the chamber by one seat, pending Lieberman and any unforeseen surprises. For us to have gotten even that close in a year when we have both more open seats to defend, and more overall seats to defend, is mind-blowing. I am not writing that as a sort of pre-emptive moral victory line, but simply to remind everyone how difficult taking the Senate this year was always going to be. Democrats will probably win more total senate races, 22-23, than either party has won since 1980. Republicans could be kept to single digit Senate victories this year. That will be a remarkable achievement, even if we come up just short in the chamber overall.