Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup

Photo of T-shirtI saw Borat last night. The movie has its defenders and its detractors. I think that Borat is one of the most subversive movies since Farenheit 9/11. Two different movies to be sure. But like Michael Moore, Sacha Baron Cohen seeks to expose the truth behind the lies we tell ourselves about our country. Borat uncomfortably rips the lid off of what many Americans, unfortunately, really think. There's a lot of humanity and kindness. There is also a lot of racism and anti-Semitism that is casually thrown around. When the frat boys openly wish slavery still existed in America and bemoan the fact that in their minds, minorities actually "have more power", we all know: those drunk jerks speak for far too many. We don't really have the "upper hand" just yet, dipwads, but we're working on it. Like F 9/11, I've got some problems with the movie. But any movie that exposes the dark racist and homophobic underbelly of America and gets people talking about it is ok with me. Also, it's really funny. And just in case you're not sure of Cohen's intentions, know that he has a long history as an civil rights activist (Props: Racialicious). His dissertation at Cambridge, "A Case of Mistaking Identities - the Jewish Black Alliance" focused in part on the 1964 murders of James Chaney, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner in Mississippi. (Photo: Sepia Mutiny)

But who cares what I think! See it for yourself or tell me what you think in the comments. For what's happening this week at the crossroads of race and politics, check out these quick links:

* Folks are still trying to figure out why Harold Ford Jr. came close to winning, lost and what it means. Check out Stoller vs Armstrong. Here's a local perspective and a couple of black perspectives here and here:

While voters of color displayed immense political solidarity and sophistication on election day, there are still sobering numbers that call for reflection.  In Tennessee, Harold Ford, Jr. ran a losing Senate campaign that was widely regarded to be the best of any Democratic Senate candidate this cycle.  In garnering 48% of the total vote, Ford came close to capturing the needed number of white votes-thought to be in excess of 40%.  But having fallen short, he needed a disproportionate black voter turnout to offset his opponent's white margins.  Ford took 95% of the black vote, but that vote only accounted for 13% of the electorate in a state where blacks constitute roughly 16% of the population. (Source: BlackProf)

* Tim Tagaris travels to New Orleans to cover the run-off for LA-02 between Dollar Bill Jefferson and Karen Carter. Good window into the post-Katrina political landscape.

* Republicans baffled the nation and notably, other Republicans, with their choice of racist Trent "Dixiecrat" Lott for Minority Whip. Wow, they really want to keep losing.

* In a desperate and likely to be futile attempt to broaden their appeal, the G.O.P. named Sen. Mel Martinez over Michael Steele for Chief Brown Front Man, ahem, RNC Chairman to go head to head with Howard "50 State Strategy" Dean. Hmm, good luck with that.

* UCLA cops over-exercise their authority taser-torturing a "macaca" Mostafa Tabatabainejad in front of dozens of other students in classic, garden variety, race-based police brutality. AmericaBlog has the story with truly disturbing video and African-American Opinion has a good news roundup. Sorry, and I say this with love for my white brothers and sisters, but it is very hard to imagine this happening to a white kid named say, Mark Taylor who left the dorm to study at the library and forgot his I.D. behind. But is that really an America we want to live in? I guess so, since there's a new energy drink on the market called "GreenCard."

* Houston police run over peacefully demonstrating janitors striking for healthcare and livable wages. With their horses. Stoller has photos/video. FireDogLake has background on the strike.

Brought to you by Jack and Jill Politics



Display:


Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

I didn't see anyone actually run over/trampled in the videos themselves. They were definitely being herd by the horses and dragged by the police but I didn't see hooves hit a person.

If I missed the act point me to the spot.

(Not that I think it was good for the police, blech.)


by MNPundit on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 04:30:46 PM EST

I'm also not saying they WEREN'T trampled (none / 0)

...just that it wasn't in the filmed portions that I've seen.


by MNPundit on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 04:32:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Borat (none / 0)

I agree that Sasha Baron Cohen is exposing what people really think.  I was one of his victims a few years ago on HBO.  Please feel free to read about it at http://BeatingBorat.blogspot.com and give me your opinion.  


by TheKarateGuy on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 04:48:53 PM EST

Re: Borat (none / 0)

{I wasn't going to create a Google account just to be able to comment over at your other site, so I'm putting this here.}

I can't say I'm "really into" the Borat thing, but I did just see the movie, so when I saw this comment, I wandered over to read your account (I can't load YouTube on my clunky dial-up at home, so I've only read your written account).

It sounds like you handled yourself quite well with "Borat". I'm guessing that a lot of us (probably myself included) would not behave with the same steady grace under such social duress.

As far as the book idea goes, I'm wholly unqualified to speak on this, but since I rarely let that stop me, I venture a guess that there will not be much of a market for it. Visits from Sacha Baron Cohen, Jamie Kennedy, and other "ambush comedians" are something very, very few of us will ever experience. In the wider picture, there are many unstaged situations where people from different cultures interact, so I'm sure appropriate skills are required by diplomats, international business people, military intelligence officers, evangelists (of the non-jerk variety), etc., who are new to cultures with which they need to do business. Some of the descriptions of your response to SBC - attempts to relate to him on his (faked) level, showing respect for his supposed culture without compromising your own principles - would, I think, be of value to the professions I listed previously. [Do you think your international travels helped you in this situation, or have you always had the empathy that makes for a good "people person"?]

The only other situations I can think of at the moment where your skills could come in handy are in encounters with those one might suspect of being con artists, but until confirmation of this, need to be treated with a modicum of respect until their intentions become clear. Now that might serve as the basis of a useful book/pamphlet, especially as those of us in the baby boomer demographic enter into our senior years in increasing numbers, and can expect to become marks for door-to-door scam artists and TV hucksters in greater numbers. Such precautionary literature has already been published, but updates must certainly be required as new scams come on line. I don't know if this is the sort of book you would ever want to write, but the market for this sort of thing will certainly be growing in the upcoming years.

By the way, did HBO ever get out of cheapskate status by coming through with a donation for Nice Ninjas? That looks like a really good organization you have!
Steve-MD04
by SteveMD04 on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 12:48:45 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

When the frat boys openly wish slavery still existed in America and bemoan the fact that in their minds, minorities actually "have more power", we all know: those drunk jerks speak for far too many. We don't really have the "upper hand" just yet, dipwads, but we're working on it.

I agree that those guys were troglodytes.  I hope that their lawsuit goes down in flames.  That said, I'm not all that pleased about comments like yours about minorities working to get the upper hand.  Exchange one unfair situation with another?  How is that progress?  What the hell is wrong with plain old equality?    


by wilder on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 05:44:06 PM EST

Re: Racial Equality or Better! (none / 0)

In life you almost never get 100% of your goal,
but always fall a little short.

If your aim truly is 100% equality, you're likely
to fall short. And you'll fall short in part because
at least a few others have the goal of keeping
themselves on top and you somewhere under them.

So aim for a little more than equality, it's O.K.
You may fall short and have to settle for mere
equality, but hey!

(I took "we're working on it" as a throwaway line,
but if others are taking it seriously, then so can I.)


by Woody on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 06:15:28 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Equality or Better! (3.00 / 1)

Um -- hello, HUMOR? Anyone? I was joking, sorry. Although, I don't mind the idea of getting the upper hand on guys like Trent "Dixiecrat" Lott.


by Jill Tubman on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 06:18:31 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Equality or Better! (none / 0)

I do.

If I use my hands to hold down Trent Lott they'll get too dirty.


by MNPundit on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 06:55:22 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (3.00 / 2)

Thanks for sharing your experiences. I agree that racism overall is declining and have written about this in the past on this blog. It's way out of style. Even over my brief lifetime, I have seen improvements in how I personally am treated. I have been given opportunities that my grandmother could never have even dreamed of. Many of those opportunities would not have been possible without the positive encouragement of white people. And that includes writing weekly on MyDD.

Yet, surely you must agree that while overt racism is on the decline, there are negative feelings that many people still harbor beneath the pleasant daily surface interactions. Those viewpoints factor into racial profiling, police brutality,  anti-immigrant legislation and um, Katrina.

So to you, my naive friend, I would say not grow up (as you sound plenty grown), but look around and take off the blinders.


by Jill Tubman on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 05:47:43 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

And then there's the sex factor, too, Jill. I've had opportunities my grandmothers never had, and we're all more-or-less white. And that's even though I'm old enough to have been restricted by male and female help-wanted ads, to have experienced being told to my face that the job I wanted was a man's job, to remember when all the Harvards and Yales didn't admit female undergrads, and all that crap.

Both racism and sexism are more polite now, with not much of the old in-your-face insult, but they're alive and well, and often it's a struggle to figure out exactly what's going on.

(At least with sexism, a woman reaches the age of invisibility, which I find mostly good.)


by joyful alternative on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 11:12:27 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Politics This Week (none / 0)

"When the frat boys ... bemoan the fact that in their minds, minorities actually "have more power"

-----------

That struck me as such a Fox News line of attack, I swear they must have got it from there.

When I used to watch Fox, I'd always hear about "political correctness" repressing the white majority for the benefit of minorities.


by Bush Bites on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 06:28:26 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week (none / 0)

Yeah, I think the same thing everytime I hear people whine about Christians being persecuted.  Sure, we've had a REALLY rough go of it for the past 230 years in America!

Incidentally, when I saw (Photo: Sepia Mutiny), I misread it and thought it said SEPTA Mutiny, which is something I could totally get behind.


by RisingSign on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 11:50:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Brooks. (none / 0)

   David Brooks of the NY Times jumped the shark this week by creating another one of his fake backlash narratives.  That's right, he said that people who liked the Borat movie are "snobs."  Brooks called other people snobs.  David Brooks is the king of out-of-touch elitism.  We need more movies that make fun of people who think that homosexuals should be hung in public squares.  That guy didn't get much play, and his performance was among the most disgusting.  We don't need to apologize for bigots who happen to be southern.  The more controversial this film becomes the more I like it.  Fuck Brooks.  I am not a snob if I support making fun of violent bigots for being violent bigots.  Tnaks for the post


Jim Oberweis
by cilerder86 on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 07:18:26 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

I've been made a bit uncertain by the way some of my friends laugh at the commercials, kind of in a 'look at the funny foreign man' sort of way. It's interesting to see exactly what it is that Americans are laughing at about Borat. Cohen said that the joke was on people who believe that such a character could actually exist.


by Matt in VA on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 07:59:35 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

it ain't difficult to see good, especially as there are enough of you people to judge that see only the bad.

Who is "you people?"

As long as very real racial differences are mired in prejudice and ethnicity, there will be racism however benign it might appear.  Medical practice and science is greatly retarded by the kind of nonsensical black and white prejudice dominant in society.

The children of South Asians are underdiagnosed with the "Caucasian Disease," cystic fibrosis, because doctors see the skin of "macacas" like George Allen and do not realize they are looking at Caucasians.

One company sells a forensic tool that has helped track down at least one serial killer by identifying his mix of racial heritage from his DNA. The software is little utilized because of fear of stigmatizing an imaginary race.  Even scientists who should know better deny what is evident like the inquisitors punishing Galileo for pointing out what any could see.  Better to sacrifice innocents to serial killers than disturb society's prejudices.

We are all mongrels.

Isn't that news simply dreadful?

Now who is "you people?"

Best,  Terry


by terryhallinan on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 08:01:46 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

An' who ye calling a mongrel

:-)

Met one of the Barrys on a bus from my hometown where I had justed visited my father in an isolated little town in high desert country.  Naturally we got to talking about "our war" since we had both been in Vietnam.

Both our fathers were Irish immigrants.  Where else would two Irishmen go but to a bar when we got off the bus?

Funny thing though.  

While I was Irish because my mother was a Finn, he was a Klamath Indian because his mother was a Native American. Made a great deal of difference in our lives.  Shouldn't methinks but one is a fool if he thinks otherwise.

I have never been real good at figuring out how these things can be.  

Take care, my friend.  You seem to be one of us.  Hope that doesn't offend.

Best,  Terry


by terryhallinan on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 09:31:42 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Borat is hilarious... plain and simple. (none / 0)

The character and the movie....

there is absolutely no two ways about it, you get to see the nature of a persons true character by their interaction with this "idiot".

it's the same way with all of Cohen's characters.

Boutros Boutros Boutros Boutros Ghali?
Good sport.

Newt Gingrinch? Asshole.

The backlash is hilarious as it comes from the same people who complain about people being "too uptight" about ring wing humor like South Park has become.

Hyp - o - crites.

it's deep satire, and it's hilarious.

-C.


by neutron on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 08:02:10 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

I think that the racist underbelly of America thing has been pretty overplayed.  I'm sure that those frat guys are basically the worst America has to offer (and really, does it get much worse?).  A lot of why people go along with Borat's terrible hijinks is because their multiculturalized moral compass doesn't work as well as they thought, and it takes only a small amount of social pressure to keep people from speaking out when someone's displaying anti-semitism or whathaveyouism.  Borat puts you into an uncomfortable situation, and there's a lot for you to process.  "Did he really just say that?  "  "Is it maybe a Kazakh word I don't know?"  "Maybe his culture is just unfamiliar to me."  "He's so friendly, though."  "I don't really want to make a scene."  "If I have a fit, Kazakhstan will think Americans are psychos."  Etc.  Cohen has a talent for keeping people just confused enough that they can't really react to the horrible things he's saying, even as they're pretty sure they ought to slap him in the face.    


by saraeanderson on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 08:51:01 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (3.00 / 1)

I think seraanderson has a strong point.  A lot of the people (not all of them obviously) are just trying to politely put up with a strange guy from another country.  I wonder how many people on the left side of things would immediately argue with a visitor from Cuba or Venezuala who said some favorable things about Stalin versus just smiling, nodding, and putting up with him as best they could?  Does that mean they really harbor secret harbor fantasies of mass murder beneath their innocent looking exteriors?    


by Counterfactual on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 09:18:37 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

Of course, the fact that people will just stand by and let it happen is scary in its own right.  Borat was unsettling, even if I didn't walk out of the theater worried that my fellow red-staters want to throw Jews down the well.  


by saraeanderson on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 10:13:01 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

Here's the thing, though: if you watched the movie again, no one forces those frat boys or the guy at the rodeo who wants to hang homosexuals to say what they said. Borat's opinions make it safe for these guys to say what they really think. He's not holding a gun to their head and they certainly aren't just nodding and smiling.


by Jill Tubman on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 10:04:34 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

I think Sara's right as well.  When I watched the original "Throw The Jew Down The Well" bit, I actually felt sorry for the rednecks in the bar.

That's right, I said it.  :)


by RisingSign on Sat Nov 18, 2006 at 11:53:48 PM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

Perhaps one of the worst films I've seen all year - certainly the most over-rated.  Jackass meets a tediously-long SNL skit.  Who doesn't know what is supposed to be learned from these fart jokes?


by Chango on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 12:42:27 AM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

Caseybabes, I am afraid I won't be as gracious as Jill. Let me put it to you like this: Anytime a bunch of white people would rather have a bag of sh&% at their dinner table than a person of color, there is racism in America!

I am glad there is no longer racism in YOUR America, but in the America I see every day, it's alive and well. And yes, it cuts many ways. I know black people who can't stand white folks, and Puerto Ricans who can't stand Dominicans.

BTW, I still live in Philly, and it's still a segregated city. So with all due respect to you and Jill, we haven't come that far after all.

Now the question we must ask ourselves is, how do we go about changing things? I think the first thing we must do is stop being hypocrites about our feelings towards one another, and stop making excuses for each other when we are exposed.        


field-negro
by field negro on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 09:01:14 AM EST

Re: Racial Politics This Week -- A Roundup (none / 0)

Borat is a brilliant scewering of American attitudes toward race, gender and sexual orientation-in fact, sex, period.  It is Colbert on steroids. Andrew Dice Clay turned on his head and inside out. Those who are offended by it, other than those who simply don't have the belly for such "tastelessness", don't like this movie because of its open confrontation with aspects of the country and perhaps even themselves that they don't wish to deal with at all. Encapsulating the entire movie is the scene where Cohen comes downtairs from the bathroom with what is supposed to be a bag of turds. Just peel back the layers and gape.  The frat boys are suing because he made them look stupid? What's the old saw? Stupid is as stupid does.  My God, how would an encounter between Forest Gump or Chance the Gardener and Borat have turned out.  Chance and Forest would, I suspect, turn out to be far more human.


by Retired Catholic on Sun Nov 19, 2006 at 11:49:02 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.