It's been a rough week for those of us who still think America should set the example for human rights and rule of law. One is tempted to phrase that role in past tense, as in these are things we used to represent. As Congress sleep walks through an agenda orchestrated by the most dangerous, incompetent, and deceptive administration in our history, the American people seem, for the most part, uninterested.
Many conservative writers like to begin their thoughtful debate about human rights and legal procedure by calling people like me cowards. A recent editorial in my local daily described those who do not want people tortured in our name as members of the "cringe party". That kind of cheap shot serves as its own critique. I'm one of those quivering cowards who is hiding from al Qaeda and hoping they don't get mad at me. This is just so readers understand the quality of conservative debate.
That same writer was also the first at his paper to use the term "Islamofascist" which, curiously, the rest of the editorial board rejected in a later editorial. Then, after the "fascist" spin fell flat because it was a transparently obvious attempt to associate the pointless war in Iraq with a more meaningful struggle of the last century, its recent use faded. Well, it turns out that "fascist" does have a definition and it actually is applicable to our times. Here's a pop quiz.
Robert Paxton, a historian who wrote The Anatomy of Fascism, said fascism is comprised of five parts: "1. a sense of overwhelming crisis beyond reach of traditional solutions; 2. belief one's group is the victim, justifying any action without legal or moral limits; 3. need for authority by a natural leader above the law, relying on the superiority of his instincts; 4. right of the chosen people to dominate others without legal or moral restraint; 5. fear of foreign 'contamination'."
How many Republican talking points can readers find in that passage? If less than 5, readers should do more review before the exam.
World War II started when a fascist government invaded a nonthreatening country just because its leader wanted to and for contrived reasons. That same government assumed the power to decide guilt or innocence all by itself without any messy legal procedures to follow, and then went on to use whatever means it deemed it necessary to deal with the threat posed by those it found guilty. Yes, they were the 6 million Jews, and we are all safe from them now.
So after a rough week, what do you do? In my book, giving up is for sissies. If you're a writer, all you can do is keep writing. I couldn't say how many steps it is from where we are now to Nazi Germany. You never know until you get there. I CAN say that this week's "Detainee Bill" was one of those steps. When you stop hearing from guys like me, you'll know you're there.
As for Maine, our moderate Republican senators voted for it. Readers who believe in human rights and the protections of legal process need to ask themselves a question. What's the difference between a moderate Republican and a Republican? Answer - the moderates talk nice in public.
Another a moderate Republican, Senator Specter, tried to prevent the bill from nullifying the concept of habeas corpus. He failed in that quest and then, staunch moderate that he is, he voted for the bill anyway and said, "we'll just let the courts figure it out." And these people call themselves lawmakers.
Eleven Democratic senators also voted for the bill (plus Liebermann, of course). Concerning them, the question is: What's the difference between a Democrat who helps the Republicans pass unconstitutional laws in order to avoid looking "soft on terror" and a Democrat? Answer - A minimal amount of regard for the Constitution.
I frankly don't know if our elected representatives have to take any oath similar to the one I took at commissioning to "protect and defend the Constitution of the United States". Regardless, I am sad to say that I don't think it would make any difference.
|
|
|
Permalink :: 4 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.