Contrasting Visions

The Democratic vision of post-Katrina America, from John Edwards:

Now every single resident of New Orleans, regardless of their wealth or status, will have terrible losses and life-altering experiences. Every single resident will know and care about someone who was lost to this hurricane. But some, ranging from the very poorest to the working class unable to accumulate a cushion of assets to rely upon on a very, very rainy day, will suffer the most because they simply didn't have the means to evacuate. They suffered the most from Katrina because they always suffer the most.

These are Americans some of whom who left everything they possessed behind in order to save those they loved. These are Americans huddled with their children or pushing a wheelchair between rows of those too beaten or weak to stand. In this moment, we have to remember they are part of us, Americans who love their country and are part of our national community. In this moment, it is hard because our hair is clean and our clothes are washed and our eyes are not glazed with hopelessness. But these are our brothers and sisters, and we have to remember this not just for them, but for us. We must finally recognize that when any of us suffer, we are all weaker; it affects us all.
. . .
There are immediate needs in New Orleans and the Gulf Coast, and the first priority is meeting those, but after that, we need to think about the American community, about the one America we think we are, the one we talk about. We need people to feel more than sympathy with the victims, we need them to feel empathy with our national community that includes the poor. We have missed opportunities to make certain that all Americans would be more than huddled masses. We have been too slow to act in the face in the misery of our brothers and sisters. This is an ugly and horrifying wake-up call to America. Let us pray we answer this call. Now is the time to act.

The Republican vision of post-Katrina America, from Bill Frist:

Senate Finance Committee members were informed this morning that Sen. Bill Frist will move forward with a vote to permanently repeal the estate tax next week, likely on Tuesday, ThinkProgress has learned.

One stands in awe of Sen. Frist's timing. Permanently repealing the estate tax would be a major blow to the nation's charities. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office has "found that the estate tax encourages wealthy individuals to donate considerably more to charity, since estate tax liability is reduced through donations made both during life and at death." If there were no estate tax in 2000, for example, "charitable donations would have been between $13 billion to $25 billion lower than they actually were."

I've never been more proud to be a Democrat.



Display:


John Edwards is so eloquent (3.00 / 1)

He is a model speaker for our party.

I am proud to be a member of the Democratic Party as well.  And today, John Edwards speaks for me.

by Sam Loomis on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 08:03:08 PM EST

This is why I *used* to be a centrist (3.00 / 1)

I can't even remember anymore... where along the line did ordinary conservatives completely forget to consider others? This ridiculous @#!$% is par for the course for today's Republicans... me, me, me, NO MATTER WHAT might be happening to fellow citizens.

Next time, they will complain that they don't want the few tax dollars they still pay spent on relief efforts either... oh, wait.

The voice of John Edwards serves as a reminder of what real community is about. The man is a Democratic treasure and should be given a prominent role in the rebuilding of our ideological message.

by dal20402 on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 09:36:33 PM EST

Edwards is No. 2 on my list of Presidential (none / 0)

Candidates followed by Feingold. Edwards is so right on this and i to have never been more proud to be a Democrat.
Running the Davis, Nelson Klein team in Florida.
by Liberal on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 09:47:12 PM EST

Re: Edwards is No. 2 on my list of Presidential (none / 0)

If Edwards is number two and Feingold is number three, who is number one?
by craverguy on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 09:55:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]

eh sorry came out wrong ment to say Feingold. (none / 0)

is my first pick Edwards is my second. typo.
Running the Davis, Nelson Klein team in Florida.
by Liberal on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 10:04:55 PM EST

I second your pride in being a (none / 0)

Big D, Big Tent, Dem-Dem-Democrat.
BlueNC - Progressive NC Politics
by Robert P on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 10:43:16 PM EST

FILIBUSTER!!! (3.00 / 1)

If the Dems in the Senate don't filibuster this bill... and if we don't put the heat on them RELENTLESSLY to make the filibuster hold... then the Dems not only don't deserve to be a majority party... they don't deserve to be an OPPOSITION party!!!
by dryfly on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 12:17:25 AM EST

Re: FILIBUSTER!!! (none / 0)

I see your point, but I disagree. Filibustering will do nothing but extend the debate, pushing back other efforts for Katrina-related inquiries, legislation, etc. Instead, the Democratic caucus should announce that they will vote 'no' in one big block against anything and everything that isn't relief-oriented without debate. Force the GOP into a position of either taking up pressing matters immediately or pushing their greed agenda. Either way, we ultimately win.
by Scott Shields on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 12:39:08 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: FILIBUSTER!!! (none / 0)

It's time to draw a line in the sand.  It's time for a "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" moment in the Democratic Party.  Instead of growing a heart, it's time for the party to grow a spine.  I'm tired of the excuses.  I'm tired of the rolling over and playing dead.  It's time to say NO MORE!  NO MORE tax cuts for the wealthy, while people are dying due to neglect and incompetence.  NO MORE falling into the trap of being called obstructionists for standing up for what's right.  Fight Back!!!!  Tell the American people that it's the Republicans that are more worried about the Paris Hiltons of the world, than the people suffering from a disaster in the United States.  NO MORE voting for bills that only benefit the top 10% of the American people while ignoring the other 90%.  NO MORE excuses for the debacle called Iraq.  It was wrong and it's time to say so.  

After all that has happened this week, a vote on the estate tax will be the tipping point for me.  If the Democratic Party allows the repeal to pass, I will not have left the Democratic Party, the party will have left me behind.  

by noheadspin on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 07:45:35 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Imagine (none / 0)

Imagine if Bush gave that speech today instead of a few wisecracks about Trent Lott's porch and partying up in the New Orleans of old.
by elrod on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 12:47:08 AM EST

When Congress returns (3.00 / 1)

I hope the Democrats finally bring their backbone with them. If they keep rolling over and letting Bush and Frist pick off ten or fifteen votes on every piece of legislation the Democratic Party is finished.

Harry Reid better find his backbone and start enforcing some discipline and start opposing something. The filibuster is not the only weapon a Senate minority leader has to stop and/or slow down legislation. Harry Reid better start exercising some of those parliamentarian skills he is supposed to have.

by Gary Boatwright on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 03:45:48 AM EST

Democratic Nominee in 2008? (none / 0)

Let's go with a total shock to the system.

How about James Lee Witt, former head of FEMA under Clinton, who was just hired by LA Governor Blanco as "state reconstruction czar."

By 2007, we'll be in a position to see what a hardheaded, competent manager can accomplish in NOLA, when all the odds are against him.

by CaseyL on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 05:55:32 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.