While I am sure that Americans would express a great deal of confidence in Democracy as an abstract concept, when it comes to actual institutions that are, at least ostensibly, Democratic, they tend to express very little confidence. According to the latest Gallup poll on the subject, 44% express confidence in the Presidency, 24% in organized labor, and only 22% in Congress. By contrast, Americans express a great deal of confidence in situations that are not only undemocratic (the military, the police, organized religion), but even frequently rely upon force for their authority. Granted, a lot of this is because Americans are not thinking in the abstract when they answer these questions. When people are asked if they have confidence in the Presidency, they almost invariably think of the current President, rather than the institution itself. This is evident in the internals of the poll, where confidence in the Presidency is divided along lines similar to partisan approval of Bush (Democrats have very low confidence in the Presidency, and Republicans have very high confidence. Also, confidence in the military has increased significantly over the past four years, just as it did in 1991 following the first Persian Gulf War. People tend to express confidence much more confidence in the military during a time of war than they do during times of less conflict. Also, confidence in Congress is pretty much always abysmal, so there is nothing new there.
What is perhaps most disturbing about this poll is that along with rising confidence in the military, the nation is expressing rising confidence in the police. In fact, at 63% this year and 64% last year, confidence in the police has reached an all-time high. If you couple rising confidence in the police and the military with declining confidence in the criminal justice system, elected institutions and the news media, you have the makings of a populace that would be comfortable with a police state. Now, while I personally think comparisons to our current government and Nazi Germany are absurd, offensive and based in ignorance, the growing national comfort with authoritarian and totalitarian measures cannot be ignored.
|
|
|
Permalink :: 22 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.