Over at The Fix,
Chris Cillizza takes a look at the ten races he sees as the most competitive in the 2006 cycle. They are, in order,
- Colorado's 7th district - OPEN, Rep. Bob Beauprez (R) (Previous ranking: 1)
- Pennsylvania's 6th district -- Rep. Jim Gerlach (R) (Previous ranking: 4)
- Illinois' 8th district - Rep. Melissa Bean (D): (Previous ranking: 5)
- Iowa's 1st district -- OPEN, Rep. Jim Nussle (R) (Previous ranking: 3)
- Ohio's 6th district - OPEN, Rep. Ted Strickland (D) (Previous ranking: 7)
- New Mexico's 1st district - Rep. Heather Wilson (R): (Previous ranking: 6)
- Georgia's 8th district - Rep. Jim Marshall (D) (Previous ranking: 2)
- Florida's 22nd district - Rep. Clay Shaw (R) (Previous ranking: 8)
- Iowa's 3rd district - Rep. Leonard Boswell (D): (Previous ranking: N/A)
- Indiana's 8th district - Rep. John Hostettler (R) (Previous ranking: N/A)
Dropping off the list: Democrat John Barrow (GA-12) and Republican Mike Sodrel (IN-9)
To start off with, Cillizza is missing three easy ones -- all in a single state. Connecticut Republicans Nancy Johnson, Rob Simmons and Christopher Shays all narrowly won reelection in last year, an election that particularly good for Republicans (even in Connecticut, where George W. Bush increased his share of the vote from 39 percent in 2000 to 44 percent in 2004). With even a breeze in the other direction next fall, they'll all have a difficult time getting reelected. Granted, not all three of these races deserve top billing, but at least one certainly does.
Checking down the list, it appears that Cillizza overlooked the competitiveness of Arizona's eighth CD, where moderate Republican Jim Kolbe recently announced his retirement. This race is sure to be a prime target for the Dems, particularly if extreme conservative Randy Graf gets the GOP nod. The exclusion of this race is somewhat acceptable given the short amount of time between the retirement announcement and the publication of this post.
But Cillizza really drops the ball by failing to even mention Ohio's 18th congressional district, which is now held by Republican Bob Ney. For those unfamiliar with the sixth term Congressman, The Washington Post's Susan Schmidt and James V. Grimaldi write the following today:
The Justice Department's wide-ranging investigation of former lobbyist Jack Abramoff has entered a highly active phase as prosecutors are beginning to move on evidence pointing to possible corruption in Congress and executive branch agencies, lawyers involved in the case said.
Prosecutors have already told one lawmaker, Rep. Robert W. Ney (R-Ohio), and his former chief of staff that they are preparing a possible bribery case against them, according to two sources knowledgeable about the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
Given Ney's continuing legal woes, it is beyond my how Cillizza could not include OH-18 in his list of House races to watch. Not only is Ney a particularly
bad candidate for reelection, his Democratic opponent,
Joe Sulzer, is surprisingly good. Although this rural district swings Republican -- Bush received 57 percent of its 2004 vote -- Sulzer would prove to be a particularly able challenger, with
more than $80,000 in his campaign coffers after little more than a month of campaigning, and a resume that includes a tenure as mayor of Chillicothe and service in Vietnam. While I probably wouldn't rank this race number one, I definitely see it in the top ten.
Any other races Cillizza is missing? Texas's 22nd congressional district, home to Tom DeLay, perhaps? Or maybe one of the ever-challenged Republicans from New Hampshire or New York? Or maybe even another seat the Dems have to worry about?