Display:


mccain and the GOP ecosystem (3.00 / 5)

McCain is a professional contrarian. His position in the GOP ecosystem is to say contrarian things. It's a system of mutual advantage: while McCain gets a personal feeling of vindication (or whatever he does it for), the GOP gets an image of tolerance and diversity. Describing McCain as a "professional loser" seems very insightful.

If the GOP is going to change, it's not going to be because of McCain -- it will be when the "mainstream" GOP changes its ways.

I will also say that McCain does strike me as a bit of a loose cannon. I don't think he has a coherent approach to politics. Which, again, helps him maintain his place in the system.

by sdedeo on Tue Jan 03, 2006 at 12:02:19 PM EST

Re: mccain and the GOP ecosystem (3.00 / 1)

That's an excellent point.  I'll have to elaborate on that.  Wow.
by Matt Stoller on Tue Jan 03, 2006 at 12:03:06 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: mccain and the GOP ecosystem (none / 0)

Gets to the whole 'political theater' angle.
by Matt Stoller on Tue Jan 03, 2006 at 12:03:18 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: mccain and the GOP ecosystem (none / 0)

If I recall correctly, Newt Gingrich brought political theatre into it all with Monica Lewinsky.

I guess perhaps, your perspective is that you should take action against the person who is trying to defeat torture in the United States.

Not many people know that Gingrich spent alot of time reviewing old movies of Hitler. He really does get the grassroots movement better than anyone, he helped the GOP to go in this direction.

I am a member of Moveon because I don't like theatre. I like simple, every day action like sidewalks and jogging trails. And drug bills that work, and boring old "peace" instead of weird "pre-emptive self defense" wars on innocent countries.

Tell me truthfully. IF Moveon.org were to take up a kitty against McCain, how many members do you think would support it?

Thought so.  Whats next, stoller?

by turnerbroadcasting on Tue Jan 03, 2006 at 01:16:59 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: mccain and the GOP ecosystem (3.00 / 1)

There's a great (short!) book by Cass Sunstein called "why democracies need dissent", which in part covers (and tries to classify) the different types of dissenters in an organization.

I'm pretty sure McCain is part of the theater; I think it's clear that the establishment accepts McCain and takes advantage of him (though on the other hand, McCain himself isn't I think aware of the nature of his role.)

BTW, another interesting article on McCain is in David Foster Wallace's new book of essays (Consider the Lobster) -- DFW covered McCain's primary challenge in 2000 for Rolling Stone, and while it's rather fluffy and DFW definitely missed the "real story" of the 2000 GOP, it has some interesting material on how McCain was "handled" by his advisors.

by sdedeo on Tue Jan 03, 2006 at 01:36:59 PM EST
[ Parent ]