Only charisma can beat him... he will wax the floor with Hillary or Mark Warner or John Kerry. There's some hope for Bayh because he's a centrist and has rural/Red State appeal. Edwards could match him smarmy smile for smarmy smile, but has weaknesses that Allen doesn't have.
I think Bayh is the best matchup for Allen.
I'm no Allen lover, but I've seen him operate in Virginia and like I said, no one should underestimate him.
among the choices mentioned, i agree with you that Bayh may be the best matchup against Allen because of his red state/rural appeal .
Warner needs more political experience under his belt to show.
that's why I hope Mark Warner challenges Allen in 2006. that would be a heavyweight battle. If Warner pulls it off, Allen can kiss '08 good bye.