Display:


unbiased questions (none / 0)

For me, this underscores something I've been meaning to post in one of the "MyDD sponsored poll" threads.  If part of the goal is to get MSM coverage, it's going to be incredibly important to be very careful about the wording of the questions.  People like Morin are out there ready at a hair trigger to claim that the results aren't newsworthy because of biased wording.

So, for example, paradocs had a great suggestion, seconded with some modification by Paul Rosenberg, that began with:

President Bush has recently acknowledged that at his direction and with his approval the National Security Agency has been monitoring the communications of American citizens for some time within the United States without first obtaining a court warrant. Critics of this activity have pointed out that this violates federal law and the prohibitions against such in the United States Constitution.

But of course Bush has claimed it wasn't illegal, and even inasmuch as that might seem self-evident to us, chances are that many people believe him.  I.e., it's part of the controversy.  So, a more neutral way to phrase it would be something like:

[...]obtaining a court warrant.  President Bush has argued that he has the legal authority to do this, and that he has carefully monitored the program to preserve civil liberties.  Critics have argued that this violates federal law and prohibitions in the United States Constitution, and sidesteps the U.S. Congress.

Or some variant; then ask if people think it was illegal.  This may be too long, and I'm not so much concerned with the specific example -- the point is that fine-grained edits will be incredibly important throughout the poll, to make sure they are as unimpeachably neutral as possible.  Otherwise, the results will be too easily ignored by MSM editorial staff.  Morin's assertion that even mentioning impeachment is biasing demonstrates what kind of a hurdle we have to jump over; squeaky-clean is going to need to be the rule.

by arenwin on Tue Dec 20, 2005 at 08:57:11 PM EST