Display:


Re: Clark or even better.... (none / 0)

Warner/Clark is an even better ticket.  If you analyze geography as an important indicator of electoral success, Warner would be more successful than Clark.  Clark has not held state-wide office and it is by no means a given he can even win Arkansas, let alone some of the other states you mentioned.  

Warner, on the other hand, has a great chance in a number of states, obviously Virginia is the most notable.  

As for the opinion by other posters that location has no relevance, I respectfully disagree.  Although ideology and leadership are more important qualities in a candidate than where you're from, location certainty does matter.  

Bill Clinton was successful for a number of reasons.  Living in Arkansas, and thus appealling to a wide range of moderate conservatices, put him at a distinct advantage.  He forced Bush to protect his own supposed turf rather than the other way around.  

Location does matter.  From an electoral point of view, Warner would be one tough candidate to beat.  

by Eric11 on Fri Nov 04, 2005 at 06:24:25 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Clark or even better.... (none / 0)

If Bush had been from California, he would still have won the south.  Geography is a factor, but not an extremely important one.  TO pick a candidate and have that be one of the top factors is ridiculous... especially since being from a certain area does not mean you will score a victory.  Gore lost Tennessee and didn't get a southern state.  Edwards was on the ticket and didn't manage to bring a single southern state.  Even Clinton only pulled a few of them.  If you respect Warner's policies, then support him.  If you respect Clark's policies, then support him.  But if the main reaon you like either of them is one is from Virginia and the other is from Arkansas, you are following the same archaic thinking of most electable that FAILED miserably against a vulnerable president in 2004.  You are operating under the assumption all the blue states turn blue.  Again, the only way you can do that is by looking at another candidate.  Illinois probably isn't going to support a brownback or Allen, but I will bet money that a Guiliani or McCain can win here against a Clark or Warner.  DOn't take location for granted... it is foolish and doesn't guarentee a victory.  
http://www.imvotingrepublican.com/ McCain Sucks!
by yitbos96bb on Fri Nov 04, 2005 at 08:52:12 PM EST
[ Parent ]